Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Ban on hearing aids is forcing out veteran New York City police officers
www.goupstate.com ^ | Monday, June 20, 2011 at 5:20 a.m. | JOSEPH GOLDSTEIN

Posted on 06/23/2011 5:50:16 AM PDT by Red Badger

The New York Police Department’s policy regarding a job candidate’s hearing ability is straightforward enough: Applicants who fail a basic hearing test will not be hired as officers.

But for police officers already on the job, the policy is not so clear-cut.

After years of informally allowing officers to wear hearing aids, and even paying for some, the department in late 2009 began enforcing a ban on the hearing devices, forcing older officers who had them to retire and instructing younger officers to stop wearing them at work.

Two of those forced to retire have filed a complaint with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, contending that the policy forbidding hearing aids is discriminatory toward those with hearing loss, according to the officers’ lawyer, Colleen M. Meenan.

The former officers, Daniel Carione, 44, and Jim Phillips, 40, also contend that the policy serves as a deterrent to officers who otherwise might report their hearing loss.

“This just forces the ones with hearing impairments to hide,” said Mr. Carione, a former deputy inspector who received a hearing aid in 2009 that was paid for by the department, only to be forced into retirement two years later.

“It sends a message to anyone who is suffering from hearing loss that if you come forward and make that known, we will end your career,” he said.

The two men say that because the department does not routinely test officers for hearing, the hearing-aid ban does little to weed out officers with hearing loss.

One officer, who normally wears a hearing aid but removes it while on duty, said he believed that his hearing deficiency left him less equipped to adequately serve.

“I do everything I can to reduce the odds of getting myself hurt, or someone else hurt,” said the officer, who insisted on anonymity because of his condition. He acknowledged that there were times when he could not properly hear communications on the police radio.

“I had to do a warrant check and I couldn’t hear the words,” he said. “I could hear the sound, but I couldn’t hear the words.”

Paul J. Browne, the department’s chief spokesman, said it was “not actively looking to see if people have hearing aids.”

“But presumably if someone came forward and said, ‘I need a hearing aid,’ and it indicates that your hearing is diminished, then that could lead to a disability retirement,” he added.

The department has not publicized its ban on hearing aids for active officers.

In three cases, the Police Department has told officers to stop wearing their hearing aids even though it had previously authorized their use, Ms. Meenan said.

Mr. Browne said those three cases involved “officers who were under the impression they needed hearing aids, but did not.”

Mr. Browne said hearing aids were incompatible with police work because they were vulnerable to “mechanical failure, earwax buildup or any number of things,” and could not completely compensate for hearing deficiencies that might render an officer unable to hear a command properly.

In challenging the department’s policy, Mr. Carione and Mr. Phillips also raise questions about the extent of job-related hearing loss among police officers, who hear some of the loudest noises the city has to offer, in higher doses than ordinary citizens experience.

Over the years, many police officers who had spent their careers working in the subways complained of hearing loss, said Robert Valentino, a former spokesman for the transit police, which was a separate police force until 1995.

“You work in the subway over time, no matter what, you’ll have hearing loss,” said Mr. Valentino, who said his own hearing declined noticeably between 1968 and 1980, the period when he worked underground. “The noise is just incredible.”

A study about noise in the city’s mass transit system that was published in The American Journal of Public Health in 2009 found that “exposures of a few hours to as little as 2 minutes a day” to the noise levels on some subway platforms “would be expected to cause hearing loss for some people given chronic exposure.”

Mr. Carione’s hearing loss dates to July 4, 1996, he said, when he shot and killed a drunken man who was menacing him with a knife. Another officer fired five shots less than two feet from Mr. Carione’s ear.

Mr. Carione pointed out that in 2004, despite his impairment, he could hear well enough to dive off Canarsie Pier while fishing one night and save a drowning autistic man.

“I heard enough to hear that splash, didn’t I?” Mr. Carione said in a recent interview.

He said he sought a hearing aid about three years ago when he was given command of the Queens division of the Internal Affairs Bureau. His new office, in Queens Plaza, was next to the elevated tracks, and the noise compounded his hearing difficulties.

When Mr. Carione asked for a hearing aid, the Police Department obliged, sending him to an audiologist and paying for the $3,000 device. As a result, Mr. Carione could hear again on his right side, he said. But a few months later, at a follow-up visit, a department surgeon told him the hearing aid could mean the end of his career.

When he later learned that the police pension fund’s medical board would retire him, he recalled, “I wept and I begged them to put me back to work.”

Mr. Carione and Mr. Phillips both have at least 20 years on the job, a term of service after which many police officers retire because they are entitled to a pension at half-pay. Both, however, are asking the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission to seek to have them reinstated. Mr. Carione said he always thought of himself as a “lifer” and had planned to stay in the department until he was 63, the mandatory retirement age.

Mr. Phillips, who was a sergeant in the Bronx, said he began to lose his hearing in October 2008, after he was assigned to police a loud, whistle-blowing protest by hundreds of construction workers.

After complaining of hearing problems, he was fitted in October 2009 with two hearing aids, each with a small clear tube that runs along the outside of his ear. Although he was initially sent back out on the streets with the Bronx Task Force, he was forced to retire in March.

“They told me that a perp can knock your hearing aids out,” said Mr. Phillips, using police slang for a criminal. “But eyeglasses can be knocked off, too. I contend that if you draw your weapon, you’re better off not having hearing aids than not having eyeglasses.”

Thomas Graham, a former deputy chief, wore a hearing aid, and he said he knew of no policy forbidding them during his 37 years on the force.

“If you wanted a hearing aid, as long as it’s not pink and dangling out of your ear, nobody is going to bother you over it.” said Mr. Graham, who retired last year at age 63.

It is unclear exactly what prompted the Police Department’s crackdown on the use of hearing aids. After Mr. Carione was told he would be retired, he lobbied top departmental officials unsuccessfully, trying to persuade them to rethink the policy.

Many officials were briefed on his case, Ms. Meenan said, including the police commissioner, Raymond W. Kelly. Mr. Kelly himself wears hearing aids, but as a member of the department’s civilian leadership, he is exempt from its physical and age-related requirements.


TOPICS: Crime/Corruption; Culture/Society; US: New Jersey; US: New York
KEYWORDS: ear; health; hearing

Tinnitus RING List!..............

1 posted on 06/23/2011 5:50:23 AM PDT by Red Badger
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: joe fonebone; SamiGirl; gitmogrunt; Freee-dame; ROCKLOBSTER; ryderann; Red_Devil 232; ...

Sounds like an ADA Lawsuit made to order...................


2 posted on 06/23/2011 5:51:07 AM PDT by Red Badger (Nothing is a 'right' if someone has to give it to you................)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger
"Nowadays, they picks the younger men by the cut of their jib, not the old 'uns for their experience."


3 posted on 06/23/2011 5:57:37 AM PDT by arderkrag (Georgia is God's Country.----------In the same way Rush is balance, I am consensus.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger
"hearing aids were incompatible with police work because they were vulnerable to...earwax buildup."

Interesting fact...Ears are also vulnerable to earwax buildup. I wonder if they are compatible with police work...

4 posted on 06/23/2011 5:58:46 AM PDT by Onelifetogive (I tweet, too...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: arderkrag

You don’t have to be “old” to have hearing loss


5 posted on 06/23/2011 6:00:08 AM PDT by mom4kittys (See you in another life, brotha)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger
Another officer fired five shots less than two feet from Mr. Carione’s ear.

That is how I got tinnitus in my left ear. My cousin fired his shotgun about three or four feet above my ear when we were dove hunting. We were cleaning the birds on a tank dam and I'd already taken out my ear plugs.

6 posted on 06/23/2011 6:19:56 AM PDT by Arrowhead1952 (zero hates Texas and we hate him back. He ain't my president either.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Arrowhead1952
My cousin fired his shotgun about three or four feet above my ear when we were dove hunting

You're Dick Cheney's cousin?....................

7 posted on 06/23/2011 6:24:21 AM PDT by Red Badger (Nothing is a 'right' if someone has to give it to you................)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: Onelifetogive
Ears are also vulnerable to earwax buildup. I wonder if they are compatible with police work...

Obviously having stuff between your ears is incompatible with police work..................

8 posted on 06/23/2011 6:25:52 AM PDT by Red Badger (Nothing is a 'right' if someone has to give it to you................)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger
You're Dick Cheney's cousin?....................

LOL. No, but I learned to keep my ear plugs in until all the shotguns are unloaded and in the truck.

9 posted on 06/23/2011 6:39:42 AM PDT by Arrowhead1952 (zero hates Texas and we hate him back. He ain't my president either.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger

Many years ago, eyeglasses would eliminate you from being considered for the NYPD. There were also height restrictions as you had to be better than 5’7. All that went by the boards as they were deemed discriminatory. As a retired member of the NYPD, I think the comparative argument of eyeglasses is a good one. Also, keep in mind, that the NYPD can rid themselves of 1 experienced officer and hire almost 2 more with the same money. Pensions are an entirely different pool.


10 posted on 06/23/2011 6:44:31 AM PDT by cumbo78
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: Arrowhead1952

“I learned to keep my ear plugs in until all the shotguns are unloaded and in the truck.”

Sound advice.


11 posted on 06/23/2011 6:44:48 AM PDT by ButThreeLeftsDo (FreeRepublic.com. Now, More Than Ever.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: cumbo78

NYPD couldn’t wear contacts?

And what about hearing implants? ................


12 posted on 06/23/2011 6:46:55 AM PDT by Red Badger (Nothing is a 'right' if someone has to give it to you................)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger

Between age discrimination law and the Americans with Disabilities Act, looks like this will be a Full Employment Program for New York City lawyahs for years to come.


13 posted on 06/23/2011 6:55:26 AM PDT by Buckeye McFrog
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger

What New York cops have got to do is lose weight. We have always had the fattest cops imaginable. Imagine trying to chase down a fleet-footed criminal!

In my little town in NJ, the cops are tall, well-built and in really good shape. They are also friendly and give me great confidence in their ability to go after crooks.


14 posted on 06/23/2011 7:04:45 AM PDT by miss marmelstein (FR haters of Sarah Palin are wearing me out)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 12 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger

Thanks for the ping.


15 posted on 06/23/2011 7:17:48 AM PDT by lysie
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: ButThreeLeftsDo

Even having been on tractors without mufflers on the farm, and years in the military firing various weapons, I still have fairly good hearing. I need to keep my hearing as good as possible.


16 posted on 06/23/2011 7:24:35 AM PDT by Arrowhead1952 (zero hates Texas and we hate him back. He ain't my president either.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Red Badger
Next thing you know, walking sticks, leg braces, and peg legs will be on their list.

Regards,

17 posted on 06/23/2011 7:25:08 AM PDT by alexander_busek
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: miss marmelstein

THEY NEED TO BRING BACK “WALKING THE BEAT” PATROLS...............


18 posted on 06/23/2011 7:27:35 AM PDT by Red Badger (Nothing is a 'right' if someone has to give it to you................)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: alexander_busek

...and glass eyes..............


19 posted on 06/23/2011 7:43:46 AM PDT by Red Badger (Nothing is a 'right' if someone has to give it to you................)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson