Skip to comments.Broke Down Under
Posted on 08/09/2011 11:56:30 AM PDT by Kaslin
The housing boom in Australia is now an escalating bust. Many Australian homeowners put every cent they had into their homes and they needed double incomes to just scrape by. Unfortunately, those jobs are disappearing in a construction and commercial real estate bust.
I warned about this event for years, but in Australia, like everywhere else "It's Different Here" until it's not.
60 Minutes Australia picked up the Secretly Broke story in "The Big Squeeze". Click on link for a 60 Minutes video. Here is a partial transcript.
ALLISON LANGDON: To the world, Tracy and David Dodd are the very model of Australias relaxed and comfortable middle-class. Theyre living the dream three kids, a mortgage and a suburban family home on an acre block. But Tracey and David have been keeping a secret from their family and friends theyre drowning in debt. No-one to look at you would think that you are struggling.Blame Galore
TRACY: It might look like we have got everything but you dont see the mortgage, you dont see the loans. You dont see everything and nobody wants to talk about it you know, because it is embarrassing.
ALLISON LANGDON: Has it taken a toll on you both?
TRACY: Mmm sorry.
DAVID: Oh it has it has taken its toll but youve just got to do it.
ALLISON LANGDON: Like most young couples, the Dodds invested their heart and soul and every spare cent they had into the ideal of home ownership the biggest mortgage their double income would allow. But last June, Tracy lost her job in the construction industry and David was made redundant. Just to keep money coming in, hes taken a lower-paying job. Ever since, the Dodds, like tens of thousands of middle class families have been going secretly broke in the suburbs.
TRACY: We went from having a really great income including a company car, fuel card, phone things like that to basically losing all of that.
ALLISON LANGDON: So do you have more money going out each week than what youve got coming in?
ALLISON LANGDON: How much difference are we talking about?
TRACY: Probably its getting very embarrassing probably about 400 bucks $400.
ALLISON LANGDON: This is the outskirts of the Gold Coast. When you look around and see the big, shiny new houses, the nice lawns and two cars in the driveway, you cant help but think, life must be pretty good here. But this version of the Great Australian Dream is just a facade nowhere is mortgage stress being felt more keenly than right here. And the figures are staggering one in 50 families are at risk of losing everything. The number of Australians behind on their mortgage repayments by more than a month is at an all-time high. Areas of mortgage stress can be pinpointed right around the country. Mostly in areas, that just five years ago, were booming. Families who borrowed to the limit in the real estate gold rush are the ones who are now struggling to pay their bills.
The party is over in Australia. Many anti-dollar investors and Pollyannas living down under just don't realize it yet. Nonetheless, Australia faces an economic crunch as family finances collapse under the burden of record debts, rising interest rates and utility bills.Flashback January 10, 2011: Australia's "Tulip Mania" About to Crash; 44% Jump in Property Listings Proves the Proposed Housing Shortage is Gargantuan Myth; Playable Actions
For years I have been hearing about a housing "shortage" in Australia. That myth has been shattered by latest stats that show a 44% jump in property listings.I am curious, did anyone down under reading that post exit the stock market and pick up some popcorn?
I rather doubt those interest rate hike are coming. I would guess there is one more hike at most. Then at some point there will be panic cuts by the Reserve Bank of Australia.
History suggests it will not matter one bit once.
Remember the housing "shortage" in Florida? People stood in lines overnight and entered lotteries for the right to buy condos. Others were going door to door making offers on homes that were not even for sale.
From that aspect, it sure looked like there was a shortage. There wasn't. It was nothing more than a speculative mirage much akin to the shortage of quality tulip bulbs in the year 1635 during Holland Tulipmania.
The day of reckoning has finally arrived for Australia. A day of reckoning awaits Canada, China, and the UK as well. It's too late now to do much of anything except
- Exit the Australian stock market
- Get out of the Australian dollar
- Pick up some popcorn
- Stay on the sidelines and watch the collapse unfold
It is amusing to watch Australian analyst after analyst cite the same silly myths regarding housing that we saw in the united states.May 13, 2011: Economic Bust in Australia:Near-Record Corporate Bankruptcies, Employment Drops Unexpectedly; Rise in Bad Home Loans;Record Low Property Transactions
- It's Not Different in Australia
- There is Not a Shortage of Housing
- Australia is in a Bubble
- Now is Not a good time to Buy
- It's Better to Sell Now than Next Year
Those looking for bad news can find plenty of it in Australia, which in my opinion is soon headed for recession and rate cuts.May 16, 2011: Australia Real Estate Bulls Trot Out Every Cliché Known To Man
RBA Calls For Unemployment Rate to Drop
What the hell is it that the RBA sees that I dont? The property bust is underway and going to accelerate, retailers are going under, and consumers are tapped out.
How exactly does that translate to lower unemployment rate?
Norris Way to Optimistic
I disagree with the CBA chief executive Ralph Norris on nearly every point.
- I highly doubt the RBA hikes twice more.
- I expect cuts as the Australian economy slumps into a big recession.
- I expect delinquencies to rise further.
- I expect profits at CBA have peaked or will soon do so.
Except for my economist friend Steve Keen, I have to ask: Has anyone down under learned anything from the property bust in the US?
Select Clichés from the ArticleJuly 10, 2011: Permanently High Plateau Theory Touted for Australia Housing; Real Estate Agents Refuse to Disclose Sale Prices
- "It's definitely a buyer's market" - Richard Wakelin, director of Wakelin Property Advisory
- "This is a really good time for people to be trading up" - Richard Wakelin, director of Wakelin Property Advisory
- "Buyers should be sitting back and watching for opportunities, looking for properties that have been passed in on the weekend" - Mark Armstrong, from Armstrong Property Planning
- Century 21 director Charles Tarbey suggests buyers focus on the $400,000 to $600,000 range in coastal and tourist properties.
Alternative Mish Suggestions
- Trading up now will greatly increase losses
- Tourist properties will be especially hard hit
- Now is a poor time to buy in general
- Wait 5 years, then see what prices are
- In the meantime, rent
Australia's bust has just started. Expect a 5-year decline minimum. As a point of reference, the US housing bust will be 6 years old this summer.
At the height of every boom, bullish clowns inevitably come out of the woodwork touting the "permanently high plateau" prices will not drop much theory.August 4, 2011: Eighty-Five Australian Building and Construction Firms Go Under in a Month; Crazy to Buy a House in Australia Now
Such a theory is presented in the Herald Sun although one might not quickly spot it because of the headline Decade of pain for Melbourne's property market
The implosion in Australian housing is now in full swing as Eighty-five building and construction firms go under in a month.This story is so sad because Australians had every warning in the world. All they had to do was watch the US housing bubble burst. However, you cannot explain anything to anyone with a firm conviction "It's Different Here".
Uncertainty? What Uncertainty?
Peter Jones at Master Builders Australia is blaming "uncertainty". The irony is that it would make far more sense to blame "certainty".
It is quite certain that Australia's housing bubble is now in crash mode. It is equally certain there is not a damn thing the Reserve Bank of Australia or any of the home builders can do about it.
Crazy to Buy a House in Australia Now
If you live in Australia and are thinking about buying a home, here is everything you need to know in a single sentence: It's still a crazy idea to buy a house in Australia at the current prices.
I don’t have an ounce of sympathy for those that get into debt as deep as they can in order to sustain a lifestyle that is above their means.
I’ve always lived in modest homes, and my wife and kids did not suffer ill effects. In fact, they fondly remember the home they grew up in.
I may not be Dave Ramsey approved debt free, but I’m darn close.
I agree with you completely
There would be some highly beneficial effects if people stuck to housing they could actually afford.
Older city neighborhoods would be revitalized with an influx of younger, productive families. That housing stock would get fixed-up and the residents would start caring about local schools, streets, etc. They would stop voting for the sort of candidates the “taker” class elects to City Councils, and would throw a break on the decline of civilization in our cities in general.
I am not sure about that advice.
Obviously, those who borrowed the maximum, like the couple interviewed, are in dire straits if their income falls - which is a natural event during a recession.
But rents are very high in Australia. And they seem to stay high. There has not been the extent of building housing stock which one sees in the USA. If there is a burst of inflation, one might pay rent for five years, and then be worse off.
Best advice is to buy only what you need, and like brownsfan on this thread, be modest and frugal. Don't grab for a lavish property. Many Australians want a 'show off' house. They are very mistaken.
I've never been one to try and keep up with the Jones', instead, I'll wait and catch up with them at the auction sales for pennies on the dollar.