Skip to comments.Perry tells NH no to border fence
Posted on 09/03/2011 1:35:22 PM PDT by NormsRevenge
click here to read article
What about tunnels? Israel has a wall, but there are tunnels.
We need land mines and troops. And mostly, a government that says, “If you come here illegally, you will be stripped of assets and deported with a criminal record. You will never be allowed here again. Any employer that hires you will be fined/penalized.”
Hadrian’s Wall then? :)
A fence may work well in some places, but the California border (and Arizona and New Mexico borders, for that matter) don’t have the Big Bend/Rio Grande separating them from Mexico.
Completely different situation from Texas.
He didnt want the same law in Texas. You should get your attacks straight.
Now that's the kind of cognitive dissonance we've come to know and love from our government drones. IOW, that's talking out of both sides of his mouth.
“The fence is useless. We need land mines and/or troops on the border.”
I go for both. About 15 years ago I called a conservative talk show and said that we should just start shooting people who cross the border because we probably wouldn’t have to shoot more than a few hundred and the problem would be permanently fixed - and was howled off the radio in a rant. I say I was right then and I’m still right. CA probably wouldn’t be bankrupt today if they had taken steps decades ago. We are governed by sissies and our enemies know it, especially the ROP.
at keeping people imprisoned.
Is that what you want?
What? Canada’s not sympathetic to illegals?
It would be impossible to build a fence the length of the border between TX & Mexico.
I like Perry just fine and have defended him often, but I just disagree with him here and he seems a little weak to me when it comes to securing the border.
There is no reason we can't build a border fence. The only thing really stopping it is bogus law suits and a complete lack of will.
Great, he's for boots on the ground, but I am suspicious that anyone who doesn't want a fence won't be serious about the boots on the ground piece either when it comes time to walk the walk.
The anti-Perry folks spit out a lot of stuff that doesn't concern me. His flubs over Gardasil and the TTC don't bother me too much, but being weak on securing the border does.
If we had the will securing the border would not be very difficult and everyone in the world knows it. Build the fence, put large numbers of National Guard on the border, and train up 25,000 more border police. Problem solved. We need all of the above.
This is coming from someone that likes Perry and defends him constantly. He needs to assure people like me that the status quo on the border will change.
whats to stop someone from meixco from just coming here for a day and staying? thats why i dont understand what a border fence would do...
Bush also put “boots on the ground” he just didn’t allow them to have ammo and they had a standing order to retreat if confronted.
There is a river except where there is a lake.
Neither a wall or a fence is feasible in Texas. Either is a stupid suggestion. I mean lame brained, ridiculous, idiotic.
The solution is ruthless capture of hundreds or even thousands of illegal border crossers. Rather than kissing their asses, harsh and long remembered incarceration of men,women and children will solve the problem and be more reliable and a lot cheaper.
Mortal fear is the only solution
The ignorance of Texas geography on this thread is astonishing, since it is essentially a thread about Texas geography.
People just running their mouths (or keyboards) without knowing the facts.
I’m very tired of this humanitarian crap. We are being overrun. It’s time to get serious.
“They OWN property on the other side”
And just how does that work, since Americans can only LEASE, but not OWN land in Mexico?
The few yards of border’s edge land required for the fence construction might be the first legitimate use of eminent domain in decades.
me too. I think it’s a great idea. I don’t know why we havent used them in Af/Pak. Mine the entire border where the Taliban goes in and out.
I can’t imagine it would be too popular politically, though.
Not only that but it does not at all address the tens of millions already in the country, or the reason we have them here.
HERE ARE THE FACTS. MEXICO IS SENDING LOW IQ GRUNTS AND CRIMINALS INTO THE US AT ABOUT 500K / YEAR. TEXAS IS THE FRONT LINE - SO DO SOMETHING G-DAMMIT.
Those numbers appear WAY too low, I suppose that is just the invaders from Mex. & So. America?
Needs to add the invaders from the rest of the world too in order to be accurate.
There were about 30 Mexican Army just last month who drove their humvees across the Donna international bridge but claimed they were lost when they got caught. We did nothing but point them south.
Riiiight, and I’m the toothfairy.
It’s an amazing thing ain’t it. Before 0bama I didn’t give it much thought but you know, his dictator wannabe personality makes me nervous about having a border wall now.
I agree completely. People are letting their anger talk so loud their brains can’t think. There are tunnels now so there will be tunnels where ever a fence is built. Patrols with the power of enforcement and a foreign workers visa allowing a specific type of employment and time of stay need to be available and controlled by the Federal Government as States make their needs for workers known to the Government slots can come available.
The states all need to decide to get behind enforcing the laws we have and identifying illegal visitors, deporting them into their countries - far beyond the border by plane. While squatters from abroad are being empowered by liberals to stay and demand benefits, accommodations in our schools and workplaces, free medical care and monetary support they will flood any barrier that can be built. The Berlin wall was to keep Berliners in not foreigners out.
I agree with Perry, Americans need to stand together as a country and deport people who are not willing to make their legal commitment to America, speak our language and uphold our values of religious freedom, freedom of speech and civic responsibility. Any foreign worker should have his/her visa revoked and be deported if a crime is committed by them or if they are unable to find a job. No welfare. No more anchor babies, parents need to be green card holders to get citizenship for their children.
Check out my posts 87 asnd 99 on this thread — with links.
———there are tunnels.-——
Where are there tunnels under the wall?
Where is there a wall along a river border?
I don't mind having a guest worker program for certain industries, but that doesn't mean bringing the whole family. When a legal immigrant shows up they have to be able to support themselves and the illegals get a pass.
In the meantime the two governments collude to sucker literally millions out into the desert southwest into some of the most dangerous terrain around. There they are fleeced by "coyotes", held captive by smugglers, and killed by violence or the elements.
It’s our border. We are a sovereign nation. Illegals are running over our border. It’s time to do something serious.
Let’s quit jugging the hot potato and deal with the issue. We graduate over 50,000 illegal aliens a year from our public high schools.
HOW DOES THAT HAPPEN? It’s bull... pucky.
at keeping people imprisoned. Is that what you want?
Please don't be silly. You know we're talking about the physical effectiveness of a wall here, not the political decisions for the wall.
In Israel there are tunnels. You can Google.
They’re sympathetic but becoming less so all the time.
Several years ago they let some 1500 illegals from Mexico into Windsor from Detroit on a temporary basis while things were sorted out. They’re still there.
Illegal immigrants are a huge problem, and FWIW I strongly disagree with Perry on in-state tuition for illegals.
That said, a fence across our entire Southern border is just a feel-good solution that will cost an unbelievable amount of money and won't actually get the job done.
Liberals are notorious for those. Conservatives should be better than that.
You couldn't travel the border between TX & Mexico, much less build a fence.
I went through Checkpoint Charlie...what made the Berlin Wall work was the armed guards in guard houses along the wall ready to shoot...and did.
It was built in the city to split East from West Berlin...and was built to keep people in, not to keep people out.
We need a physical barrier because the politicians WILL NEVER EVER ENFORCE IMMIGRATION LAWS. The nation is corrupt.
Why is it you guys keep coming up with this foreign worker visa business? Just pay the help.
not accurate. she is the only way to state explicitly that they will be deported if they cannot follow the rules. Since it is clear she is “not for sale” there is no motivation for her to back an amnesty plan. Perry has a record of avoiding this issue.She also spoke out against the DREAM ACT on Ellis Island.
Perry sucks on this issue everyone knows it and Americans are pissed off! We want enforcement and if Palin runs the liklihood is substantially higher that she will do the toilet scrubbing needed to get it done.
We well understand the nature of Texas geography, and we still think a fence should be considered.
A Predator B costs $10 million for a bird with only a camera. In Arizona CBP is required to escort those aircraft out to the small track and back. You could do a better job with a Cessna Caravan and a Wescam MX-15 and not be limited to one area.
No more One World RINO candidates.
Perry has just proven himself to have the heart and soul of a RINO.
PS Individual Texans, doing what Texans have always done, made the “Texas Miracle”, not their governor or any other Texas bureaucrat.
That’s right, could never happen here, right?
America says GUARD THE BORDERS !!!!
and Perry hears ‘gardasil’
Go back and think about what you just said and still see if you want an inpenatrable wall at the border...TSA at the airports, ship ports, bus and train stations....hey, if you’re a law abiding citizen what do you have to fear, right?
I guarantee you these Freepers that are against the fence/wall are all probably well off and have nannies, maids, cooks and gardeners that are from south of the border - like Perry does.
It doesn't make sense -- from El Paso to Brownsville.
The Rio Grande is the only water source for fifty miles thru much of that area. A fence that blocked cattle, livestock and irrigation pumps off from the river would make millions of acres worthless and impoverish thousands.
There are smarter, more effective ways to approach the problem. Let's try those, instead, rather than dogmatically repeat the mantra "Build a fence!"
"Create a barrier" to illegal aliens! How about that?
I agree that's true for much of the border. But that's not a problem because the fence does not have to be built right up on the border. Build it to take advantage of the terrain, even if it is often a distance from the border at places.
I did, and I am still not buying the reasoning for not building a fence.
From your post:
There are places along the border that strategic fencing worked, particularly in the metropolitan areas, Perry said. The idea that were going to build a wall from El Paso to Brownsville doesnt make sense cause the fact of the matter is you know, number one, youd never get it built, and itd cost billions of dollars ... by the time you go from Tijuana to Brownsville. Perry said that he does support putting boots on the ground and using aviation assets (i.e. aerial drones) to secure the border.
I see more excuse making here. He is saying building a fence from El Paso to Brownsville doesn't make sense because it would never get built and cost billions of dollars. It hasn't been built because there is no political will, and billions of dollars to secure the border with Mexico seems like a very solid national security investment to me.
I like Perry and of the candidates in the race, I think he is probably our best choice, but the good that is going to come out of this primary is that each of our folks gets fully vetted. As I said, most of the anti-Perry cut and paste jobs and rants about Gardasil are not persuasive, but we definitely need to change the status quo on the border and I think a fence is a darn good place to start. It certainly won't work in a vacuum, but it can be a piece of an overall national security border strategy.
Agree 100% with you. A fence is not a realistic, viable solution.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.