Skip to comments.Professors offer more than $10,000 for proof that Bachmannís story about HPV is true
Posted on 09/15/2011 1:35:21 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
Minnesota Rep. Michele Bachmann's story about a woman who claimed that her daughter suffered "mental retardation" after receiving a vaccine against HPV could fetch the woman's family thousands of dollars. But the family can only collect if Bachmann or the unnamed woman can prove the story is true.
Two bioethics professors have offered to pay more than $10,000 for medical records that prove the anecdote Bachmann told after Monday night's Republican presidential debate is true, the Minneapolis Star Tribune reports:
Steven Miles, a U of M bioethics professor, said that he'll give $1,000 if the medical records of the woman from Bachmann's story are released and can be viewed by a medical professional.
His offer was upped by his former boss from the University of Minnesota, Art Caplan, who is now director of the University of Pennsylvania Center for Bioethics. Caplan said he would match Miles' challenge and offered $10,000 for proof of the HPV vaccine victim.
"'These types of messages in this climate have the capacity to do enormous public health harm,'" Miles said of why he made the offer. 'The woman, assuming she exists, put this claim into the public domain and it's an extremely serious claim and it deserves to be analyzed.'"
Bachmann told the story after she criticized opponent Texas Gov. Rick Perry for using an executive order in 2007 to mandate that all girls entering the sixth grade receive a vaccination against the Human papillomavirus, a sexually transmitted disease that can cause cervical cancer.
(Excerpt) Read more at news.yahoo.com ...
Easy bet, because there is no proof.
Put up or shut up.
$10,000 dollars says they can’t prove it is not true.
Consensus = proof nowadays.
All she needs is a gaggle of “professionals” to agree with her....done!
You know you can’t prove a negative.
She said it and it’s up to her or her supporters to prove what she said is accurate.
I bet the professor $1million that what Obama said of Obamacare won’t increase deficit is false. Obama/Biden lies all the time and the media never call them on it
Bachmann really stepped in it.
She managed to take a good debate performance and wreck it by creating this controversy. She just couldn’t resist going overboard with the Gardasil thing.
I think she’s done now. She wasn’t likely to win the nomination anyway, but this thing really blew up in her face.
These dopes have nothing better to do with money or their time than hunt down some poor woman who talked to Bachmann after the debate?
I have always believed this story to be true whether or not Gardisil is a dangerous vaccine or not.
We need to find this woman and report her to Attack.com.
michelle is done
As Joan Rivers used to say: oh, grow up, America!
Do you really think that the left needs this story to demonize a female Republican candidate for prez? How naive.
There is no proof, she is a liar.
This won’t be the first time a politician has offered up an anecdote to support their position that was later proven to be fallacious.
It generally tends to be a Democrat though.
Michelle IS done - she’s probably going home to Chicago. Michele, on the other hand, is still a viable candidate.
That should be easy. All she has to do is prove that some woman told her the story she said the woman told her. In the mean time these asshat professors know that proving their challenge is also proving a negative.
“Leave the virus obsession to those with nothing better to think about.”
In other words, “Move On” right, LOL. Unfortunately untill it’s addressed properly it will dog her.
Take a look at this. Rick Perry really stepped in it. He has given the left all they need.
He is toast, done, over, finished, unelectable, he needs to get out now. I mean right now. He is too impulsive and emotional when it comes to his alien buddies.
$10,000 for proof “global warming” is manmade. And algore’s ridiculous PowerPoint slide show doesn’t count.
Bingo! She needs to handle this mistake (it is a bump) like Palin handled all the garbage thrown at her and like all the garbage in the gossip magazines. Someone needs to get the facts for her before she steps in it. Learn and move on.
NEVER use ONE verbal example, parent source or doctor source, for a government based decision.
I don’t doubt that the women did indeed approach her and maybe even say what Bachmann said she did.
But MB also gave it credence with her final statement to the press on the incident, therein lies the rub.
Look it up.
This was her “I’m not a witch, I’m you” moment. Sayonara Michele!
The “intellectual” left should be completely ignored by Rep. Bachmann. She is not accountable to them, nor should she succumb to their extremely political interference.
However, if any vaccine had made a perfectly normal 12 year old mentally retarded, that case history would have been world famous and cited in every medical journal and newspaper headline in Western Civilization.
Bachmann repeated, as a fact, on the national stage, in prime time, without any checking, something that a total stranger had claimed.
Bachmann essentially made herself the Joe McGinnis of the Presidential debates.
No thanks, it’s not that important to me. Only those with an agenda to hurt Rep. Bachmann think it’s much of an issue.
from CDC link you cited:
In the 32 reports confirmed, there was no unusual pattern or clustering to the deaths that would suggest that they were caused by the vaccine and some reports indicated a cause of death unrelated to vaccination.
Don’t think, much “thinking” went on when she made such a statement without any supporting evidence. Bachmann was probably listening to a ronpaul kook, whom pretended to be an innocent Tea Party person. I am sure Bachmann wishes she could put this back in the bottle.
I would prefer to consider Bachmann just impulsive, which considering the position she is striving for, can be damgerous on a global scale.
As for the truther site: Get real.
Too bad, this has legs now. Next thing Michele will be back on the bus pouting like at Waterloo, Iowa.
Hope this link works:
It’s about the old boys Democrat network shoving aside decent female candidates in the NY/Queens/Brooklyn race in favor of the creepy bewigged Weprin.
Thought it had major implications for the Republicans, as well.
If the link doesn’t work, please go to today’s New York Post and read the article. It’s very interesting.
Damn! If a link goes on for half a page, it usually ain’t gonna work!
Her problem is she acted like a Democrat. We have higher standards.
32 reports? How selective a cherry picker you are.
First, grasshopper, this list is a LOWER LIMIT.
Second, the serious problems (e.g. cancers induced) will
show up LATER (usual latency is 7 to 20 years).
Third, there were 18,727 reports of adverse events.
Four, there were 68 VAERS reports of death.
Fifth, did the RINO Perry warn the 6th graders
they might die?
Six, .... or does he just brag (and lie) that
he PREVENTS CANCER?
“I have always believed this story to be true whether or not Gardisil is a dangerous vaccine or not.”
WOW, to say the least.....
“Feelings” orientation is the best reason to tread very cautiously with promoting just any woman to POTUS.
Yep and they are here of course
>You know you cant prove a negative.
There are no flying spaghetti monsters in my office.
(I look up, I see none).
did I just prove a negative?
The claim was that a perfectly normal 12 year old became mentally retarded.
Bachmann will need to produce a mentally retarded teenager that was known to be perfectly normal to her community, her friends and her teachers before she received the vaccine.
No such teenager exits and a dozen professionals can't fake the existence of such a teenager.
Only an entire community could theoretically fake such a story in a "Waking Ned Devine" scenario.
LOL, ouch, I think I’m gonna cry.
Seriously, although Bachmann is not my first choice I have no major issues with her.
That being said, she needs to dispense of this or it will continue to haunt her, wait and see.
It’s certainly going to have legs pushed by all you Michele haters here on FR.
When did you stop beating your wife?
Cute, but specious.
At least - despite my “feelings” - I can write a coherent post. Unlike you, you twit.
Well indy, this seems to be the week for sighing and rolling our eyes like pinwheels.
http://www.drugs.com/clinical_trials/studies-gardasil-merck-s-cervical-cancer-vaccine-hpv-16-vaccine-component-gardasil-presented-7192.html ~ this has Merck’s OWN study. There were 24 deaths among those in the study group 2 of which involved overdose/suicide. Now, about that reward ~
Rick Perry owes her big time for her big mouth. She scored big points at the debate, although I didn’t agree with her, but like my wife and most women.....when she had won the argument...she couldn’t shut up.....and with that little fib...she lost big time and I doubt seriously if we hear anymore about guardasil in the next debate... Thanks Michelle!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.