Skip to comments.Transcript – Fox News-Google GOP Presidential debate September 22, 2011 Orlando, Florida
Posted on 09/23/2011 1:46:11 AM PDT by iowamark
BRET BAIER, ANCHOR: Welcome to the Orange County Convention Center in Orlando, Florida, the site of our Republican presidential debate. It is being sponsored by Fox News and Google in conjunction with the Florida Republican Party.
Besides watching us on Fox News Channel, we are being streamed on YouTube.com/Fox News and heard on Fox News Radio.
Now lets meet the candidates.
Texas Governor Rick Perry.
BAIER: Former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney.
BAIER: Congressman Ron Paul.
BAIER: Congresswoman Michele Bachmann.
BAIER: Former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich.
BAIER: Businessman Herman Cain.
BAIER: Former Senator Rick Santorum.
BAIER: Former Utah Governor Jon Huntsman.
BAIER: And former New Mexico Governor Gary Johnson.
BAIER: Joining me at the big desk tonight, my Fox News colleagues Megyn Kelly and Chris Wallace.
BAIER: With our partner Google, we have some new features wed like to quickly tell you about.
Throughout the night well be playing some questions from viewers who posted their video and text questions on YouTube. We will also be polling viewers on key issues while the debate is under way. We will have updates from our own Shannon Bream.
Our rules are similar to previous Fox debates, one minute for answers, 30 seconds for follow-ups. And after an outpouring of e-mails from dog owners who said the last bell sounded like their doorbell, we have a new sound for the candidates if they run too long.
Thank you to Google for that sound. We hope after a string of debates we dont have to use that too much.
Now, we received thousands and thousands of questions from around the world on different topics. Each one of these pins on the map is another question from health care and immigration, to foreign policy and social issues. But the highest percentage of questions dealt with jobs, the economy, debt, and government spending. And that was even before todays major market slide.
What makes this debate unique is that not only did you submit the questions, you voted on them, letting everyone know which questions you think the candidates should be asked tonight.
We received questions from all 50 states, but our first question comes from Dave Meldeau, right here in Florida.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
QUESTION: As a small business owner, one of the obstacles I have in growing my business in todays economy is having the confidence and incentive to go out and hire new employees. Im wondering what each one of our candidates would propose to do as president to help incent small businesses like mine to hire new employees and to confidently grow our business in this troublesome economic environment.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
BAIER: Governor Perry, Ill put that question to you.
GOV. RICK PERRY, R-TEXAS: Yes, sir.
Well, Rick Scott is sitting right over there, and he and I compete every day with trying to get jobs into our states. And what we have done in the state of Texas over the course of the last decade is to lower that tax burden on the small businessmen and women, have a regulatory climate that is fair and predictable, and sweeping tort reform that we passed in 2003 that told personal injury trial lawyers, dont come to Texas, because you are not going to be suing our doctors frivolously.
PERRY: Thats the way you get the government off of the back of small businessmen and women. And thats the way you free up those small business entrepreneurs, where they know that they can risk their capital and have a chance to have a return on investment.
If it will work in the state of Texas, it will work in Washington, D.C. And thats exactly what Im going bring to Washington when I go there in November or, excuse me, in January of 2013.
BAIER: Governor Perry, the thing weve heard from most people who submitted questions is they wanted specifics, they wanted details. Most of the people on the stage, opponents, have a specific jobs plan on paper that people can read.
Where is your jobs plan?
PERRY: Well, you will see a more extensive jobs plan. But the fact of the matter is, you look at the state of Texas and see what weve done there from the standpoint of lowering that tax burden, the regulatory climate in the state of Texas. Weve taken those types of regulation off the throat of small business operators.
People understand that the state of Texas, during the last decade, something special happened there. It was the number one state for relocation for five years in a row. And we plan on keeping it that way, Rick.
BAIER: Governor Romney Governor Romney, you have a specific plan. In recent days, actually, the top rising search of your name on Google actually dealt with people searching for specifics of that plan.
But a Wall Street Journal editorial recently called your 59-point economic plan, quote, surprisingly timid and tactical considering our economic predicament. Specifically, the editorial board had a problem with you picking the $200,000 income threshold for eliminating interest, dividends, and capital gains taxes, writing that you were afraid of President Obamas, quote, class warfare rhetoric.
How do you response to that criticism?
MITT ROMNEY, FORMER MASSACHUSETTS GOVERNOR: Well, lets go back lets go back and talk microphone on? Can we get the mike on? There we go.
BAIER: There we go.
ROMNEY: Lets go back and talk about the question that Dave asked, which is how to get small business a break. And President Obama has done everything wrong.
I happen to believe that to create jobs it helps to have had a job, and I have (ph). And having had a job in small business and in big business, I know what you have to do is make America the most attractive place in the world for business, and that means our corporate tax rates, our employer tax rates have to be competitive. Small business pays at the highest rate. We need to get those rates down to globally competitive levels.
Number two, government and regulators have to be allies of business, not foes.
Number three, weve got to become energy secure in this country.
Number four, we have to have trade policies that work for us, not just for the other guys, and crack down on cheaters like China.
And my list goes on in my 59 points. But finally, let me tell you this
I I know there are some that say, look, we should lower taxes for the very highest-income people. Other folks have different plans. My view is very simple: The people that have been hurt most by the presidents economy, the Obama economy, has been the middle class.
Thats why I cut taxes for the middle class.
BAIER: So, sir, what
what do you consider rich? Is half-a-million dollars, a million dollars rich? At what income does someone reach your definition of rich?
ROMNEY: I dont try and define whos whos rich and whos not rich. I want everybody in America to be rich. I want people in this country to have opportunity.
And I want everybody to have the kind of opportunities that we on this stage have had. I want people in America to recognize that the future will be brighter for their kids than it was for them.
I know that the the presidents party wants to try and take from some people and give to the others. That isnt the way to lift America. The way to lift America is to give people opportunity and to let them enjoy the freedoms that have made us the envy of the world.
BAIER: Governor, thank you very much. Occasionally, through the debate, we will ask the same questions we ask the candidates to you at home. The first one, what is your definition of rich? You can vote on that answer at youtube.com/foxnews. Well bring some of those results throughout the show with Shannon Bream.
Now to my colleague, Megyn Kelly.
KELLY: Thanks, Bret.
Congresswoman Bachmann, after the last debate, a young member of the California Tea Party said he didnt feel he had had his question fully answered. And its a question that received the most votes on Google and YouTube on the list, as well. The answer his question is a number. And the question was, quote, Out of every dollar I earn, how much do you think that I deserve to keep?
REP. MICHELE BACHMANN, R-MINN.: And after the debate, I talked to that young man, and I said I wish I could have answered that question, because I want to tell you what my answer is: I think you earned every dollar. You should get to keep every dollar that you earn. Thats your money; thats not the governments money.
Thats the whole point. Barack Obama seems to think that when we earn money, it belongs to him and were lucky just to keep a little bit of it. I dont think that at all. I think when people make money, its their money.
Obviously, we have to give money back to the government so that we can run the government, but we have to have a completely different mindset. And that mindset is, the American people are the genius of this economy. It certainly isnt government thats the genius. And thats the two views.
President Obama has embraced a view of government-directed temporary fixes and gimmicks. They dont work. Hes destroyed the economy. What does work is private solutions that are permanent in the private sector. That gives certainty; that will grow our economy.
MEGYN KELLY, FOX NEWS: Senator Santorum, next question is for you. This map from Google depicts 22 states in the U.S. are right-to-work states. In the other 28, if a business is a union shop, you have to join the union if you want to work there. Now, this next question is one of the top-voted questions online, and it comes to us via YouTube from Yates Wilburn of Hilton Head, South Carolina.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
QUESTION: With unemployment numbers remaining above 9 percent, union issues, such as the National Labor Relations Board lawsuit against Boeing and several union battles in state legislatures across the country have become incredibly relevant to the national discussion. For all the candidates, would you support some form of a federal right-to-work law, allowing all workers to choose whether or not to join a union?
(END VIDEO CLIP)
KELLY: Thats for you, Senator Santorum.
FORMER SEN. RICK SANTORUM, R-PA.: I I think the most important area that we have to focus in on when it comes to unions is public employee unions. Thats the area of unionization thats growing the fastest and its costing us the most money.
Weve seen these battles on the state level, where unions have have really bankrupted states from pension plans to here on the federal level, for example, 30 percent to 40 percent union union employees make above their private-sector equivalents.
I do not believe that that state, federal or local workers, unions, should be involved in unions. And I would actually support a bill that says that we should not have public employee unions for the purposes of wages and benefits to be negotiated.
KELLY: Speaker Gingrich, this next ones for you. You criticized extending unemployment benefits, saying that you were, quote, opposed to giving people money for doing nothing. Benefits have already been extended to 99 weeks, and they are set to expire soon. If you were president today, would you extend unemployment benefits? And if not, how do you justify that to the millions of unemployed Americans who are looking in earnest and whose families are depending on those checks?
NEWT GINGRICH, FORMER SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE: Well, what Ive said is that I think unemployment compensation should be tied directly to a training program. And if you have to if you dont have a job and you need help, then in order for us to give you the help, you should sign up for a business-led training program so that that 99 weeks becomes an investment in human capital, giving us the best-trained workforce in the world so you can get a job.
But I believe it is fundamentally wrong to give people money for 99 weeks for doing nothing. Thats why we had welfare reform.
And, frankly, the easiest thing for Congress to do, if the president sends up a proposed extension, is to allow all 50 states to experiment at the state level with developing a mandatory training component of unemployment compensation, so youd have 50 parallel experiments, and not pretend that Washington knows best or that Washington can solve the problem by itself. But I believe deeply, people should not get money for doing nothing.
BAIER: Now I turn to my colleague, Chris Wallace.
CHRIS WALLACE, FOX NEWS: Bret, thank you. Good evening, candidates.
Governor Huntsman, in Utah, you offered millions of dollars in tax credits to promote clean energy. In June you said that as president you would subsidize natural gas companies. How is that different from the Obama administration, which gave the solar panel company Solyndra a half-a-billion dollars in federal loan guarantees, and as we all know, that company ended up bankrupt, and we taxpayers ended up on the hook?
FORMER GOV. JON HUNTSMAN, R-UTAH: Chris, first of all, its an honor to be here in Orlando, home of my wife, the greatest human being Ive known in 28 years.
Weve learned some important lessons as this economy has spun out of control. We have some hard decisions to make. And were not going to fix the problem. Were not going to be able to bring our people together in America until we fix the economy.
Im convinced that part of the divide that were experiencing in the United States, which is unprecedented, its unnatural, and its un-American, is because were divided economically, too few jobs, too few opportunities.
We have learned that subsidies dont work and that we can no longer afford them. I believe that we can move toward renewable energy, but were going to have to have a bridge product. Everybody wants to draw from the sun and draw from the wind, and Im here to tell you that eventually that will make sense, but today the economics dont work.
We need something like natural gas. Ive put forward an energy independence program, along with tax reform and regulatory reform. Just by drawing from natural gas, for example, youre looking at 500,000 to 1 million jobs over the next five years. It is ours, its affordable, it has important national security implications, and we should begin the conversion process.
WALLACE: But just a 30-second follow-up, sir. In June, you told the New Hampshire Union Leader as president you would subsidies the natural gas industry.
HUNTSMAN: I would be willing to begin an effort, so long as there was a rapid phase-out. I do not like subsidies. I do not like long-term subsidies. But if there was some sort of way to get the ball rolling with a with a with a quick phase-out, I would be in favor of that.
WALLACE: Mr. Cain, I want to follow up on your 999 plan for economic growth. Thats a 9 percent
Well, they seem to already know what it is. But for the few who dont, its a 9 percent flat corporate tax, a 9 percent flat income tax, and a new 9 percent national sales tax.
Now, conservatives usually say repeal the income tax before you impose a new tax. Isnt there a danger with your 999 plan, with these three taxes, that some government down the road after President Cain is going to increase three forms of taxation on Americans?
HERMAN CAIN, FORMER CEO OF GODFATHERS PIZZA: No, theres no danger in that. And first, let me answer Daves question with the 9, 9, 9 plan. Unfortunately, nobody up here answered his question. He wanted to know as a small businessman what are we going to do to help him as a small business person? I have walked in Daves shoes.
This economy is on life support, thats why my 9, 9, 9 plan is a bold solution. It starts with throw out the current tax code and pass 9 percent business flat tax, 9 percent personal income tax, and the 9% national sales tax. This is the most important part, it eliminates, or replaces corporate income tax, personal income tax, capital gains tax as well as the estate tax.
Then it treats all businesses the same. And the people who are paying only payroll tax, 15.3, that 15.4 they dont have to pay, now they only have to pay that 9 percent.
And unlike Governor Romneys plan my plan throws out the old one.
Hes still hooked to the current tax code. That dog wont hunt.
WALLACE: The rule is if your name is mentioned in an answer you get 30 seconds to respond Governor Romney.
ROMNEY: Thats fine. I put my plan out, I want to make it clear my intent is to help the people who have been most hurt by President Obamas economy. And the people who have been most hurt are the middle income families of Americ