Skip to comments.Herman Cain acknowledges his electric border fence idea isn't a joke after all
Posted on 10/18/2011 4:39:29 AM PDT by Cincinatus' Wife
PHOENIX - After first apologizing for suggesting an electric fence along the border, Republican presidential candidate Herman Cain told reporters here Monday that he still thinks it's a good idea for controlling illegal immigration.
"I'm not walking away from that," he said.
Cain has spent the last several days explaining a controversial comment about building an electrified fence along the U.S. - Mexico border that he said could kill people trying to enter the country illegally. On Sunday, he said his comments were "a joke." But talking to reporters here after a meeting here with Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, who has made a national reputation for cracking down on illegal immigrants, Cain reversed course.
Initially Cain apologied when told his remarks had upset some in the state. "Mea culpa, mea culpa, mea culpa," he said, using the Latin formula for expressing contrition. But when a reporter challenged his description of his comments, saying he didn't seem to be telling a joke, the retired pizza executive acknowledged: "You're right." He said he still believes in the need for a border fence "and it might be electrified."
(Excerpt) Read more at cbsnews.com ...
I still want land mines.
Thank you for posting this.
Mr. CAIN cares about America.
RINO “Open Border” “Freebies for Mexicans” Perry not so much.
I wonder how many lobs who fret about the idea of a border fence have visited and admired the Great Wall of China?
Opps wrong hat!!
Whatever happened to the alligator moat idea? Or better yet, snakes! Build the moat and then comb Texas and Arizona for every rattlesnake you can find. Toss them in the moat. Make it like something out of Indian Jones. Every couple of days dump in a truckload or two of rats and mice to keep them fed. I’d love to see anyone try and cross that.
Apparently, my iPad doesn’t like libs.
At the end of the day, the barbarians still took China over.
Enuf with the cartoons.
FOCUS on the campaign.
Tell RINO Rick to become a VOCAL CONSERVATIVE
or just admit he is a Rove-picked Gore-derived
puppet for Romney.
Cain is the best of those we have running, but he’s still not ready for prime time.
Hey, while we're reviewing the serious subject of "Romney Puppets"...
...and you could make nature films....
You need to change Perry’s comments to “Snore”, “Snore”, “Snore”.
I don’t think rattlesnakes like water that much. Snakes don’t eat all that often.
That might work to, but my idea has lower costs. Though your idea does remove the cost of feeding. One would assume that having lasered the illegals into small pieces then the sharks could feed on what was left.
True. Instead of providing public television with money we could provide free documentaries. Even more savings.
David Gregory: Would you deport illegal immigrants in the country right now?
Herman Cain: Here is my approach to illegal immigration. Here again, this is whats resonating with the people. How I would solve the problem. Its not as simple as, would you deport. We must secure the border. It would be a combination of a physical fence, technology and in some areas we might have to put troops there. We must secure the border. Secondly we must promote the path to citizenship thats already there. We need to clean up the bureaucracy. Third enforce the laws that are already there. The way you do that is number four, which is a bold idea empower the states to do what the federal government cant do and wont do as far as dealing with illegals that are in the United States today.
Gregory: Why you and not Mitt Romney?
Why me and not Mitt Romney? Mitt Romney is a great businessman. I have a lot of respect for him. He has been more of a Wall Street executive. I have been more of a Main Street executive.
Meet the Press October 16, 2011 Aprox 25 minute video
I viewed it as being a dry moat. Since we don't have the alligators then we don't need the water.
Cain's not perfect, but he is honest and willing to admit his mistakes. Maybe that's what we need instead of prime time ready politicians.
>> I dont think rattlesnakes like water that much.
I don’t know whether or not they *like* it, but I have seen enough of ‘em swimming in and across rivers and ponds around here to know that they’re *comfortable* in it.
>> Snakes dont eat all that often.
Maybe that’s just because they’re tired of the same old stuff. :-)
Jeeze—nearly 4 years ago Mr. Cain gave some support to Mitt.
OMG! That’s horrible. Guess I’ll have to vote for ole pointy boots now........
We should make the prez’s whole life (except for the obviously private bits) a reality show!
At least Herman Cain will come out with details. Most other politicians won’t.
Really? You want to go there?
Cain supported Romney!!!
At this stage, I’d rather have Rudy
Rick Perry has battled back Karl Rove in two elections:
1998 (where he wanted Perry to take hits from his democrat opponent in the Lt. Gov. race to help GW Bush win more votes when he tossed his hat into the ring in 2000) -- Perry won -- and became the first Republican Lt. Gov. in Texas since Reconstruction.
2010 (when the Bush-Rove-Hutchison-trial lawyer machine tried to win the primary for Kay Bailey Hutchison) -- Perry won and brought along a GOP super majority.
The poster to which I replied chose the subject — I didn’t bring it up, I’m just contributing to their original line of thought. Doesn’t that make it fair game?
How does he plan to run it on the Rio Grande? Our horse fence runs along a creek and between the flooding, fast growing weeds shorting it and burning through and the horses stamping around in the mud making the poles fall down it needs frequent fixing. And THAT’S only 10 acres!
It seems Bachmann didn’t find Herman’s joke too funny, either.
But Bachmann wasn’t laughing.
“That was a joke and this is no laughing matter,” she told reporters when asked about Cain’s comment. “It’s important that we take this issue very seriously in dealing with the fence, as all of the individuals in front of me are doing, they’re dealing with it very capably and very seriously.”
I don’t see how this helps—saying something, then saying something is a joke, then turn around and say it is not a joke.
How are people who don’t spend a lot of time investigating candidates supposed to make a decision? One can’t see what the truth/plan is.
He changes his story twice in a couple of days?
Wow... And he wants to be President?
I keep saying it... He’s gonna really embarrass us.. Even if he’s your first choice, don’t slam on the other conservatives on case Cain crashes and burns... Worst thing that happens is we end up with Romney... Unfortunately, Cain wouldn’t be too crushed in that scenario
Those are details? Besides he keeps changing the "details."
These are details from an executive who actually has to deal with it.
Oct 6, 2011 Interviewing Rick Perry On Illegal Immigration [10 Points]
"I have long been a proponent of strategic fencing because it is a critical component of border security, and it works when used in the right places.
I think what caused the hang up was that after it was passed, it was amended to give Homeland Security complete discretion on how, when and whether the fence ever gets built. Obviously with this president, that means it will never be completed.
If Im elected, I will direct my Secretary of Homeland Security to expedite construction of strategic fencing along the border, especially in high traffic areas where manpower alone is insufficient to do the job.
But its important to remember that fencing is only one component of an overall border security strategy. A fence is only as secure as it is manned.
Thats why I would increase manpower on the border, starting with thousands of National Guard and border patrol agents, and Id also make greater use of unmanned aerial vehicles to help gather real-time law enforcement intelligence.
We know for a fact that increased manpower is effective, because weve proved it in Texas with our $400 million border security effort."
The federal DREAM Act is an amnesty bill, and I strongly oppose amnesty. The Texas educational residency bill was vastly different.
Because the federal government has failed in its basic duty to protect our borders, states are forced to deal with illegal immigrant issues.
In Texas, we had to deal with the children of illegal immigrants residing in our state and attending our schools, as the federal government requires states to educate these children through the public school system. Lawmakers in Texas indisputably one of the most conservative states in America were virtually unanimous in their decision.
The Legislature determined the payment of in-state college tuition is available to all students who have lived in Texas for at least three years and graduated from a public high school. If you meet those requirements, you pay in-state tuition, whether you relocated from Oklahoma, Idaho, Canada or Mexico. The only difference is that Texas residents who arent documented must be on the path to pursue U.S. citizenship to be allowed to pay in-state tuition.
There were a number of reasons the bill received widespread support among conservatives. Importantly, it has never had a cost to Texas taxpayers. In fact, our institutions of higher learning would actually lose tens of millions of dollars in lost tuition payments if the law were repealed.
And it would lower the odds that these students would receive subsidized health care or end up in prison. Protecting taxpayers was a serious concern, given that a Supreme Court decree already requires taxpayers to pay for K-12 education for undocumented students.
The Berlin Wall was a very popular tourist spot too.
What this does, because you have a lot of African-Americans located in cities like Detroit, disproportionately, it would encourage businesses to stay in business there or to move there. It would encourage people to work there, because if you live in the empowerment zone, youre going to pay a smaller percentage in taxes. Herman Cain CNN
Exactly. People need to know the facts before going off half-cocked.
Knocking mitty for his mittycare and even knocking Cain for his 9-9-9 interim tax plan is fine because both are defined policies; but to go berserk over whether Cain wants the fence to have electricity flowing through it is nutz.
The thing that bothers you so much is the fact that perry is weak on ILLEGAL ALIENS and has protected and promoted them for 10 years.
GWB was the same way, because he came from a state that has five million ILLEGAL ALIENS living and working there and both have compromised their values for votes.
It embarrassed Bush and Perry and you, and you all go hyper to attack any one that contrasts that position.
February 4, 2008
Why I Support Mitt Romney: Leadership Substance
by Herman Cain
The dynamics of political party connections, the political process itself and public perceptions have once again yielded the top two contenders of each major party in the 2008 presidential race. And once again, the public can only hope that the ultimate winner of the White House will be a candidate with the most leadership substance.
My vote is for Mitt Romney.
I believe that would he Harry Belafonte. Lol
Talk to the Federal government.
Don’t get me wrong, I like the idea.
What about piranhas?
>> I believe in empowerment zones.
Affirmative Action is a *GREAT* idea! Let’s code it into TAX law and let the IRS administer it! ;-)
I’m not sure anymore what he wants, but I think he is saying that he still thinks an electric fence would be good, but doesn’t want it to kill people. I’m guessing the “kill people” part of his speech was the joke.
We had so much fun with this last night, with some Caniacs missing the sound of retreat and bravely soldiering on fighting for the absolute right to kill every illegal that crosses our border. Apparently, the sight of dead bodies piling up by the fence was supposed to be an effective deterrent. I had a blast, it was so much fun I actually stayed up all night just commenting back to them.
The best was when one of them “revealed” the “shocking truth” that I had supported Romney in the 2008 election. They then all started calling me a RINO liberal for supporting a guy like Romney. When I pointed out the hilarity of CAIN supporters attacking a freeper for supporting Romney in the last election, they explained why it was “different”. They couldn’t explain the part about why Cain saying he supported Romney in 2012 wasn’t germaine to the conversation.
I think blaming people for who they decide to support is stupid, but it was just funny. I did get one to admit that while he wanted to shoot illegals crossing the border, he wouldn’t shoot them if they had already made it across safely.
The question of the day — if something happens to Cain, and it comes down to Romney or Perry, who will the Cainiacs support? We know Herman Cain will support Romney over Perry. Will they follow suit? Better yet — will they admit it now?
I don’t know whether I’m supporting Cain, or Perry, or some other candidate, but I know I’ll never choose Romney over any of them that have a chance (thus eliminating Huntsman).
OK, if it’s between Romney and Ron Paul, I may just run down to the border, stand on the mexican side, call up a Cainiac supporter, tell them I’m illegal crossing the border. That way I won’t have to shoot myself.
I had fun with that. A Cainiac tried to explain that with Cain, the first thing he says about a subject is what he really believes, and everything after that is a political lie to smooth things over.
So when someone posted the 2010 comment from Cain that he would find jobs for people who made it past the alligators, I asked if that meant that Cain wanted to reward illegal aliens with green cards.
3 3 3! *for select people*
It's just that he makes so many of them.
10/02/11""My reaction is, that's just very insensitive," Cain told Fox. "[There] isn't a more vile, negative word than the N-word, and for him to leave it there as long as he did, before I hear that they finally painted over it, is just plain insensitive to a lot of black people in this country."
10/03/11: All I said was the mere fact that that word was there was insensitive, Cain said outside Trump Tower in Manhattan, N.Y., according to the National Review. Thats not playing the race card. I am not attacking Gov. Perry. Some people in the media want to attack him. Im done with that issue!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.