Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Frozen Planet scandal: Sir David Attenborough defends fake polar bear footage
Daily Mirror (UK) ^ | 12/13/2011 | Simon Boyle

Posted on 12/13/2011 7:21:19 AM PST by Mount Athos

SIR David Attenborough yesterday defended Frozen Planet’s fake polar bear footage – by comparing BBC nature documentaries to movies.

In a surprising justification for duping millions of viewers, the TV star argued that owning up to splicing archive film with real Arctic scenes during the programme would have spoiled the mood.

His blunt remarks came as more footage from the series was exposed as a sham.

Speaking after our exclusive story yesterday revealed shots of a polar bear and her newborn cubs were staged in a zoo using fake snow, Sir David, 85, said: “The question is, during the middle of this scene when you are trying to paint what it is like in the middle of winter at the pole, to say ‘Oh, by the way, this was filmed in a zoo’.

“It ruins the atmosphere, and destroys the pleasure of the viewers and destroys the atmosphere you are trying to create.

“It’s not a falsehood and we don’t keep it secret either. But to say actually in the middle of that sequence, I mean how far do you take this?

“Do you say this is a penguin, but actually it was a different penguin colony than this one and this one is a different one? Come on, we were making movies.”

It yesterday emerged BBC producers also misled viewers about footage of a frozen caterpillar in hit seven-part series Frozen Planet.

In an episode on November 2, Sir David said: “Beneath the rock the caterpillar is out of the wind, but the cold penetrates deep into the ground.

“Soon it’s heart stops beating, it ceases to breathe, and it’s body starts to freeze – first it’s gut, then it’s blood.”

The footage included a wide shot of the caterpillar’s natural habitat above ground, and a close-up of the creature beginning to freeze underneath snow and ice.

But some of it was actually filmed in an artificial habitat – in fact, a box.

Another scene involving snowflakes forming at close range was also set up and produced in a controlled environment using time-lapse photography.

The BBC admitted: “There’s a sequence with snowflakes which is set up – it’s filmed in a controlled situation, so they can get really close footage. And there’s another section with a woolly caterpillar, but the vast majority of it is filmed in the wild.”

In a further blow to wildlife fans, corporation bosses yesterday confessed that staging footage was standard ­practice in natural history programmes. They insisted such editing tricks were necessary to create the ­documentaries, and added the programme met the expected editorial standards.

A spokesman said: “While the great majority of footage for Frozen Planet is filmed entirely in the wild, on occasion certain sequences need to be filmed in controlled conditions – otherwise we wouldn’t be able to bring these stories to our audiences.

“This type of filming is standard practice across the industry when creating natural history programmes.”

The spokesperson added the narration was carefully worded so as not to mislead ­audiences – and the details of the zoo footage was explained on the BBC’s website.

But last night Mediawatch hit out at the corporation’s excuse. Vivienne Pattison said: “I’m sorry, but it’s a bit pathetic to argue that the details were available on the website. How many people would have looked at it?

“It would have done them no harm to explain how they did the filming at the end of the episode where they give viewers a look behind the scenes. Viewers are grown up, they would understand why it could not have been done in the wild.”

Sir David said filming a bears’ nest in the wilderness would have been too dangerous. He told ITV’s This Morning: “If you had tried to put a camera in the wild in a polar bear den, mother’s den, she would have either killed the cub or the cameraman, one or the other. I mean, it is out of the question.”

Last night the BBC refused to disclose the precise location and name of the Dutch zoo where the filming took place.

A spokeswoman would only say: “It’s not set up to be deluged with calls from the media.”

Frozen Planet, watched by an average 8.7 million viewers, has been sold to more than 30 countries.

Jim Shelley - verdict

NO ONE wants to criticise Sir David Attenborough, given the amazing television he has made and the work he's done to preserve wildlife and educate us about the way we are destroying the planet.

But in the case of Polar Beargate, he would be better to recognise that what he and the BBC did was duplicitous and simply apologise.

The dodgy footage was the most touching scene in Episode Five of Frozen Planet - watched by some eight million trusting viewers.

The pictures would have been NO LESS remarkable if Sir David had simply mentioned that they were effectively library footage, shot in what we now know was a German animal park.

After all, as he pointed out on This Morning: "If you put a camera in the wild in a polar bear den, she would either have killed the cub or she would have killed the cameraman." He could have easily explained this at the time. It is disingenuous to claim that this would have spoiled the atmosphere and to argue that the BBC "did not keep it secret".

Attenborough's voiceover for the footage sighed in wonder: "On these slopes beneath the snow, new lives are beginning.

"The cubs are born blind and tiny. In two more months polar bear families will emerge on the snowy slopes all around the Arctic... but for now they lie protected within their icy cocoons."

This is clearly misleading. And viewers will be disappointed to find out that Sir David is yet another TV presenter they cannot totally trust.


TOPICS: Crime/Corruption; Culture/Society; News/Current Events; United Kingdom
KEYWORDS: bbc

1 posted on 12/13/2011 7:21:27 AM PST by Mount Athos
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos
"SIR David Attenborough yesterday defended Frozen Planet’s fake polar bear footage – by comparing BBC nature documentaries to movies"

Then we should treat them as movies. In other words, fiction....
2 posted on 12/13/2011 7:26:31 AM PST by Old Teufel Hunden
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Environmentalists got caught in a lie?
Shocked. Just shocked and saddened.

(it worked for Al gore)


3 posted on 12/13/2011 7:27:12 AM PST by Notwithstanding (1998 ACU ratings: Newt=100%, Paul=88%, Santorum=84% [the last year all were in Congress])
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: steelyourfaith

Pesky polar bear ping


4 posted on 12/13/2011 7:27:22 AM PST by Fractal Trader
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Yes Mr Attenboro we know all Environmental wacko stuff is fantasy.


5 posted on 12/13/2011 7:27:54 AM PST by marty60
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

It’s OK when Lefties lie, because the ends justifies the means.


6 posted on 12/13/2011 7:30:41 AM PST by E. Pluribus Unum (Holding our flawed politicians to higher standards than the enemy’s politicians guarantees they win)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos
This isn't really that big of a deal to me. I've known for a while now that animal programs use different tricks to enhance the experience. Not sure if it's done in every show, but I heard a long time ago that the sounds of the wild are put in later. As long as they are recreating things that actually happen in nature, I don't have a problem with it.

The things that bother me are when they crop a photo (or edit a film), like the famous polar bears on ice, to make it look like they are stuck at sea. Misleading for an agenda is wrong. If that was what Sir David was doing, then I can't be for that.

7 posted on 12/13/2011 7:33:27 AM PST by beaversmom
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos; Berlin_Freeper; SolitaryMan; golux; SteamShovel; Bockscar; Thunder90; rdl6989; ...
 


Beam me to Planet Gore !

8 posted on 12/13/2011 7:35:35 AM PST by steelyourfaith (If it's "green" ... it's crap !!!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Fake but accurate. The UK’s Dan Rather!


9 posted on 12/13/2011 7:35:39 AM PST by Jack Hydrazine (It's the end of the world as we know it and I feel fine!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Fractal Trader

Thanx for the ping Fractal Trader. I was distracted in the midst of being possibly the first respondent on this thread,


10 posted on 12/13/2011 7:38:06 AM PST by steelyourfaith (If it's "green" ... it's crap !!!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: beaversmom

“The things that bother me are when they crop a photo (or edit a film), like the famous polar bears on ice, to make it look like they are stuck at sea.”

Yes, and then there was the woman who said SHE took the picture and it was spring when the ice always melts, and the polar bear and cub were within swimming distance of the ice floe.


11 posted on 12/13/2011 7:39:38 AM PST by kitkat (Obama, rope and chains)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

algore has requested the next polar bear filming in Florida with palm trees, white sand, and beach chairs.


12 posted on 12/13/2011 7:39:49 AM PST by Proud2BeRight
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Episode Seven has Attenborough on camera destroying his reputation and destroying his legacy. He does so fully conscious of his chosen actions and fully aware that he is repeating extremist sensationalist propaganda that has no scientific basis.

The underwater episode footage is just absolutely amazing.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/environment/climatechange/8923287/Lord-Lawson-accuses-Sir-David-Attenborough-of-sensationalism.html


13 posted on 12/13/2011 7:40:37 AM PST by JerseyHighlander
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

“Soon it’s heart stops beating, it ceases to breathe, and it’s body starts to freeze – first it’s gut, then it’s blood.”

Then it’s apostrophes reach critical mass and million’s of them burst forth from it’s brains.


14 posted on 12/13/2011 7:41:38 AM PST by Lady Lucky ( Merry Christmas to all)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Lady Lucky

Lol...nice retort, Lady...:)


15 posted on 12/13/2011 7:46:45 AM PST by EnigmaticAnomaly ("Mantra of the left: 'It's only okay when WE do it.'")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: Lady Lucky

Dittos. It must be painful to be so stupid as to not know the difference between “its” (possessive) and “it’s” (contraction of “it is”).


16 posted on 12/13/2011 7:47:05 AM PST by hsalaw
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

David Attenborough seems to be taking Dan Rather’s lying stance: “Fake, but accurate.”


17 posted on 12/13/2011 7:49:03 AM PST by CodeToad (Islam needs to be banned in the US and treated as a criminal enterprise.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Old Teufel Hunden
Isn't that Michael Moore’s defense when he is confronted with the mounds of falsehoods in his “documentaries?” He has said something to the effect of “Hey, I am just an entertainer!”
18 posted on 12/13/2011 7:54:42 AM PST by Army Air Corps (Four Fried Chickens and a Coke)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: beaversmom
We watched the documentary "Beavers" and it was great. The accompanying "How this was made" part though was sort of disappointing. The beavers were totally conditioned to the film crew so they weren't exactly natural. On the other hand, they wouldn't have been able to get many of the shots they did if the beavers weren't used to them being around. So I guess in the end there's a trade off between filming wildlife completely unaware vs. getting more intimate footage that you couldn't otherwise.

Unnaturally staged or contrived footage is, of course, another story.

19 posted on 12/13/2011 8:02:35 AM PST by facedown (Armed in the Heartland)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Fake? The next thing you know we will find out the Bear Grylls really doesn’t sleep out in the woods when filming Man vs Wild. :-)


20 posted on 12/13/2011 8:13:49 AM PST by Hacklehead (Lets stop bashing Republican candidates and get back to bashing OBAMA.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: facedown

I don’t care what they have to do to get their shots, but TELL US. Full disclosure. Planet Earth series didn’t fake shots and they also told us how they did it. Stayed out in the freezing cold for weeks or months to get a shot. They could have saved a lot of time & money by going to a zoo and faking it. But then it wouldn’t have been REAL.


21 posted on 12/13/2011 8:14:33 AM PST by faucetman
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 19 | View Replies]

To: hsalaw
Dittos.

" " Good shot, hsalaw :) " "

22 posted on 12/13/2011 8:28:17 AM PST by Lady Lucky ( Merry Christmas to all)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Fake but accurate,

so, where is our grant money?


23 posted on 12/13/2011 8:31:07 AM PST by TomGuy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: beaversmom
I've known for a while now that animal programs use different tricks to enhance the experience. Not sure if it's done in every show, but I heard a long time ago that the sounds of the wild are put in later.

Many of the so-called Reality TV programs are also staged, rehearsed, re-filmed and edited before they are shown on TV.

It is the nature of the industry.
24 posted on 12/13/2011 8:38:30 AM PST by TomGuy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: Army Air Corps
"He has said something to the effect of “Hey, I am just an entertainer!"

The left's head minstrel....


25 posted on 12/13/2011 8:39:48 AM PST by Old Teufel Hunden
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos
***SIR David Attenborough yesterday defended Frozen Planet’s fake polar bear footage****

Reminds me of the faked polar bear shooting scenes in the 1971 TV “documentary” SAY GOODBY.
A helicopter is used to haze a mother polar bear and two cubs. Then the “hunter” shoots, and the camera gets a real good closeup of the slow death of the mom, with the final scenes of two little terrified cubs.

Then the truth came out. It was wildlife agents drugging the mom with a dart gun for tagging(you can see the dart leave the barrel when he fires the gun). She was left unharmed after the tagging was done. But oh what good anti-hunting propaganda was made of the film.

Then there was that other travesty that came out about the same time...THE GUNS OF AUTUMN.

26 posted on 12/13/2011 8:44:39 AM PST by Ruy Dias de Bivar
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Hacklehead
Fake? The next thing you know we will find out the Bear Grylls really doesn’t sleep out in the woods when filming Man vs Wild. :-)

Or that it is actually beer that he is drinking...

27 posted on 12/13/2011 8:56:15 AM PST by Dan Cooper
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos
In a surprising justification for duping millions of viewers, the TV star argued that owning up to splicing archive film with real Arctic scenes during the programme would have spoiled the underlying message mood.

----------

Fixed

28 posted on 12/13/2011 9:04:02 AM PST by freedomlover (Make sure you're in love - before you move in the heavy stuff)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

I wonder why this is treated as something new. Sir Davy is just saying ‘Get over it, this is how we do entertainment’.


29 posted on 12/13/2011 9:32:16 AM PST by count-your-change (You don't have to be brilliant, not being stupid is enough.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Just like the beach CD’s where you hear the waves hittin ghte Beaches of Monaco of some such nonsense. In one of them, the producer was searching for a particular sound which he finally achieved by dropping a mic in his toilet and flushing.


30 posted on 12/13/2011 9:35:07 AM PST by cyclotic (People who live within their means are increasingly being forced to pay for people who didn't.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos
“Beneath the rock the caterpillar is out of the wind, but the cold penetrates deep into the ground. “Soon it’s heart stops beating, it ceases to breathe, and it’s body starts to freeze – first it’s gut, then it’s blood.”

The worst thing about this "movie" is that they MURDERED that caterpillar! Not only that, they slowly FROZE it to death!

Murder and torture of a caterpillar! Where is PETA when you really need them. Everyone who was involved in that scene should be jailed!

Furthermore, they can't even spell! They don't know the difference between "it's" and "its." And to think that the BBC used to be a civilized operation!

31 posted on 12/13/2011 9:41:28 AM PST by Cicero (Marcus Tullius)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos
Next thing you know, he will be telling us the Dinosaurs in Jurassic Park were fake.
32 posted on 12/13/2011 9:46:36 AM PST by Kickass Conservative (Liberals, Useful Idiots Voting for Useless Idiots...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

I’m not sure I see a big deal here. Some of those sorts of shots simply have to be set-ups or they’d not be possible. How did people ~think~ they got shots of deep inside an ant colony or a beaver lodge, or any of those kinds of things?

Seems to me the important thing is not so much whether the footage was entirely natural, but whether it shows something that is true or not.


33 posted on 12/13/2011 9:46:44 AM PST by Ramius (Personally, I'd give us one chance in three. More tea anyone?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mount Athos

Scandal? Someone needs their sensitivity med dose reviewing.


34 posted on 12/13/2011 10:08:03 AM PST by Natufian (t)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Cicero
Furthermore, they can't even spell! They don't know the difference between "it's" and "its." And to think that the BBC used to be a civilized operation!

That orthographic howler was the work of the 'Daily Mirror' report, not the BBC.

35 posted on 12/13/2011 12:45:25 PM PST by Winniesboy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson