Skip to comments.Tebow, a ‘horrible' quarterback ;He keeps paying for that pro-life ad
Posted on 01/10/2012 12:23:08 PM PST by Red Steel
Tim Tebow, keep thanking Jesus for life and football. Leave it to The Gazette to thank all those embarrassing neer-do-wells who invested their reputations on a stupid bet that you would fail. They dont like your faith, your lifestyle, your anti-abortion Super Bowl ad and theyd like to forget that you donate millions to help children.
Tebowed! A look at the QB's college and pro career
You have made them fools, throwing for a stunning 316 yards to beat the NFLs top-ranked defense in a playoff game. Some are downright angry. Others should hide in their parents basements, in shame. Here is some of what they said:
DJ Gallo, ESPN columnist, after Sundays playoff win over Pittsburgh: Yet again, we were somehow all caught off guard by Tim Tebow... The image of your average Internet message-board troll is that of a weak, pasty basement dweller whose life is focused on getting people riled up in comments sections. Now imagine if such a troll was a muscled 6-foot-3, 236-pounder who decided to troll the entire country on national television every week? Youd have Tim Tebow. He started the season as the third-stringer, and everyone freaked out. Then he got a start and won, and everyone freaked out. Then in his second start, he played horribly and got crushed, and everyone freaked out. Then he went on a winning streak, and everyone freaked out. Then he went on a losing streak, and everyone freaked out. Then he won a playoff game, and everyone freaked out.
David Jacoby, on ESPN affiliate Grantland, Jan. 3, 2012: Timothy Richard Tebow is an atrocious, dreadful, embarrassment of a quarterback, and Denvers defense won games despite his performance. Either that or he has God on speed dial and is just messing with us.
Jordan Calfee, featured columnist, Bleacher Report, Dec. 21: The Denver Broncos cannot compete with the likes of the Baltimore Ravens and Pittsburgh Steelers come January... You can call him a winner and talk about his college resume and comebacks this season all you want. The fact of the matter is, Tim Tebow is a very poor passer. The folks at ESPN dont criticize him because they are bullies, or because they are somehow anti-Christian...
Ryan Phillips, featured columnist, Bleacher Report, Jan. 5, 2012, on John Elways suggestion that Tebow pull the trigger, by throwing the ball more: While I appreciate Elways confidence in his young signal-caller, that is terrible advice... If he is forced to be a pocket passer, there is no way he can beat a team on his own.
Rob Kelley, The Pigskin Report, Jan. 2, 2012, headline: Tim Tebow is the worst quarterback ever to win division and reach NFL playoffs. Samples from ensuing article: Watching him (Tebow) play is akin to watching a peewee league game from a bunch of kids. The only difference is that peewee quarterbacks can actually throw a spiral from time to time... Tebow seems like a great kid who lives a clean life... But that does not mean that he is a viable starting NFL quarterback. He isnt even close... trust me when I tell you that the Broncos are not going anywhere with Tebow under center... As much as I dislike Ben Roethlisberger and the Pittsburgh Steelers, I truly hope that they walk into Denver and absolutely annihilate the Broncos next Sunday afternoon. Tebow cannot throw the ball. Not downfield, or even across the middle for short gains.
Greg Couch, FoxSports.com, Nov. 3, 2011: Tebow isnt good enough now to be a starting quarterback in the NFL. The Broncos arent good enough to be a team in the NFL, either.
Ryan Alfieri, Bleacher Report, Jan. 8, 2012, a day before the Steelers game: On Sunday night, the Denver Broncos magical season will come to an end, and they will have Tim Tebow to thank for it... It was cute to watch the young guy squeak out wins and get his team in the playoffs, but the honeymoon is now over... Weaknesses tend to be exposed around playoff time, and few players are more flawed and vulnerable than Tebow. I dont just expect Tebow to have a bad outing; I expect him to play himself out of the Broncos starting job.
Mark Kiszla, Denver Post, Oct. 30, 2011: So maybe we need a new definition for Tebowing. Its a prayer for mercy. Please, in the name of heaven, bring us somebody who can actually play quarterback.
ESPN analyst Merril Hoge, tweeting in August 2011: Its embarrassing to think the Broncos could win with Tebow!! He later tweeted: You must possess a skill set to play!
Tebows tweeted response: ppreciate that.
Tebow-bashing is a sports-media obsession and examples are endless. No amount of success will end this. If Tebow someday wins consecutive Super Bowls and leads his profession, these hater-pundits will call it a fluke. We are embarrassed for them.
Wayne Laugesen, editorial page editor, for the editorial board. Friend Wayne on Facebook; follow him on Twitter.
I live in colorado Springs and the gazette is a complete piece of trash. they cant give it away and its slowly going out of business.
316 yards and John 3:16
Those pesky coincidences...
Kind of makes me think of quarterbacks like Billy Kilmer, Bobby Lane, Joe Capp and some others who were not great passers. They did nothing much but win. They were leaders who got the most out of their talent and than players around them.
Most of the folks quoted in this article are on the fringes of the sports media. Heck, anyone can write for Bleacher Report.
Most of the "top shelf" pundits are behind Tebow--Dilfer, Deon Sanders, Michael Irvin, Berman, Eisen, etc. Even Hoge seems to be coming around. It was also nice to see Stephen A. Smith eat crow, although he still doubts if TT can become a consistent performer.
To be honest, I don’t think all of the Tebow bashing is because he’s a Christian. I think a lot of the people are just sick of hearing about him (you can’t listen to ESPN for 10 minutes without hearing his name). AND, on some days, he’s awful, and looks like he has no idea how to throw the ball.
That being said, he can also be fantastic. He made some great throws in the Pittsburgh game, and quite frankly its fun to watch him. And it is nice watching a lot of loudmouth sportswriters chew on crow.
In the case of Mr. D.J. Gallo, “ESPN columnist”, hiding in his mom’s basement for a while won’t do him any good.
He needs to find a different line of work. He is a TERRIBLE writer.
And then there is Tim Tebow - the most controversial NFL player ever! Wow, there really are no journalist left in the world.
...and yet, as starting quarterback for the Broncos, he did, defying all expectations, throw for 316 yards, including the 80 yard game winner, and did beat the best defense in pro-football, the Pittburg Steelers in overtime.
Whatever else happens, Tebow has proven his worth to the Denver Broncos.
I believe that coincidence is God’s unseen hand moving in people’s lives.
Tebow should have shut these jokers up with his performance against Pittsburgh. His positive, hard-working, and cheerful attitude have produced a body which is strong and athletic and a mind which inspires his teammates. You can teach passing, but you can’t turn a Matt Leinart into a hulk like Tebow.
This same squad of geniuses all said that Drew Brees (while he was with the Chargers) lacked the skill set to be an NFL quarterback.
While watching the game on Sunday, I actually turned to Mrs. kevkrom at one point and said, “you know, except for the designed running plays, this guy reminds me a lot of Ben Rothlesburger during his rookie season”. There are a lot of difference, for sure, but both of them just carried this supreme confidence and drive despite a lack of pro experience or perfected skills, and more importantly, both were capable of extending plays long enough to find open receivers.
Great winning streak?
NFL level quarterback skills?
I still can’t see them.
Field of dreams: Young Tebow fan from Loveland huddles with Broncos QB at playoff game
yet he plays on
that was NOTHING next to Praeter's opening kick hitting the crossbar and landing EXACTLY on the 20 yard line...
all with some freaky smoke "halo" over the stadium...
The Book of Revelations indicates that it will be handled by Someone Else.
Did you see the halo about Mile High? Look it up. Amazing. Not saying T is Jesus reincarnated but just to many signs that someone is looking out for Tim..Go Tim and God bless the Broncos..
Tebow is the face of the company’s “staycool” underwear collection. Jockey spokesman Mo Moorman said Tuesday that the line is the fastest-selling collection in the company’s 135-year-old history.
Some of the Tebow-bashing is because he is a Christian, but certainly not all. I don’t know if you’re a football fan... but on occasions he can be horrifically bad. Almost painful to watch. That’s the genesis for the bulk of criticism from sportswriters IMHO. They expect every NFL quarterback to fall in a specific mold, and will tear down anyone who plays the game differently.
But.... sometimes... he’s fantastic. Especially in the clutch. If the Broncos somehow manage to upend the Patriots, prepare for heads exploding like you’ve never seen.
Yet there are a bunch of QB’s with NFL level skills who won’t be taking the field this weekend.
Joe Kapp is a fighter:
Never was much of a football fan. Guess I need to change and start supporting this guy.
People of faith need to stick together.
Some QBs come out of college and immediately master the pro game, like Dan Marino. Others, like John Elway, did not look that great in his early years.
Christ and His people vs everything and everyone else.
Those are the only two sides in the grand scheme of things.
Now, I do think the pro-life ad was what engendered the most hatred, because it reminds people of their murderous tendencies. Those that are “pro-choice” know, deep down inside, that it’s killing a baby human, and they know it’s wrong, and they HATE any reminders of that.
LOL. Tebow already plays better than Hoge ever did. Hey Merrill, in 8 years how many playoff games did you win as starting QB?
Like a guy that consistently hits the 1,000 yd bull, but just isn't a very good shot, right?
TT might keep up this lucky streak for 10 years or so, but eventually he's certain to show everyone that he just doesn't have what it takes. They really ought to cut him right now, before more wins just confuse the issue. Because once he wins a few Super Bowls its going to be really tough to make a new transition to a 'real' NFL QB.
Those pesky coincidences...
Plus he was 10 of 21 passing, so he had 31.6 yards per completion, and the TV rating was 31.6.
Leaving his religion aside, Tebow is clearly not a horrible QB. He is also not a pro-bowl caliber QB.
This is what happens to reporters when they accept the conventional wisdom instead of thinking for themselves. Tebow doesn’t suck, he’s just different. Tebow might not be the prototypical QB, but neither was Kenny Stabler, Doug Flutie, or Michael Vick. They all won, though.
Thank your son for me for his service. May God keep him free from harm. I have a nephew serving in the Navy based in Afganistan with Navy Seal support.
Regarding pro athletes committing criminal acts: I remember Michael Irvin as a Dallas Cowboy being involved with cocaine and associated bad behavior. Some Cowboy fans cared not what he did off the field as long as he performed well on the field. There is a different standard for Tebow. Some people will not applaud his ability to help his team win because he is a Christian on and off the field.
What is the biblical signifcance of a ball landing on the 20?
Tebow, at this stage in his career, reminds me of Steve Young, who developed into a top-notch quarterback. Barring a serious injury, and finding the right system, Tebow has that potential.
But--sure gotta love Tebow "leading the offense" (and often NOT intentionally!) down here on this "playing field".
Interesting article by a sports writer who finally caves in and declares, “It’s Tebow Time”
I have not heard so much talk about a white Bronco since the OJ trial....
LOL. You’re right. I thought Joe spelled his last name Capp. Yeah, he may be better with a cane than he was with a football.
Very interesting observation.
Am I wrong? Did it not take Elway several season to get the Broncos to the playoffs?
I don’t think it’s biblical. But one has to wonder if there was some type of disturbance in the space-time continuum.
Beat me by two post..
Once he gets in rythem with his receivers as he did at Florida. Look out folks. Time is on his side. Each day makes him better.
In his day, Joe Kapp was at one time the highest paid player in the NFL...plus, he was hilarious in “The Longest Yard”...
Religion aside Tebow is clearly a winner. He brings a positive attitude and can do spirit that filters down to the entire team. THAT’S what a quarterback is supposed to be.
I have written here before about the movie “Oh God Book 2” with George Burns and the little girl who he talks to as god. She is tasked with getting people to realize god is real and she gets nothing but grief. And in the end she gets the last laugh as the DRs who are trying to put her away as being delusional are proven wrong by God. I feel the same way with Tim. In the end the Haters will be the ones that are wrong. Go Tebow and Go Broncos..
I don't think you can definitely judge a first year starting QB one way or the other. But you didn't see any skills in the playoff game? He made some genuinely nice passes. It remains to be seen whether that will continute, but some great quarterbacks started off pretty poorly. Heck, Elway had 7 TDs and 14 picks, with a 47% completion % his first year. He turned out to be a good quarteback, despite that.
John Elway first season:
47.5 % completion rate
54% QB rating
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.