This is America, damn it! I can say Mohammed was a child-molesting, sadistic, genocidal pig if I want to. So there.
According to the judge's line of reasoning, you should have been OK (accept for the pig part) if you had done so. He slammed the atheist because he had called Mohammad a Zombie, and the judge objected because their koran never showed Mohammad walking around dead.
But had you said, 'child-molesting', you could have said 'check', and leafed to the right page;
'sadistic' - check. You can also find that in the koran.
'genocidal' - check.
'pig' -- he would have gotten you on that one (also you were being a bit unfair to our porcine friends who provide us with wonderful bacon). Just a man. A man subject to satanic influences (also referenced in the koran -- as Salamon Rushdie once pointed out)...