Skip to comments.Bankerís Insulting Waitress Tip Incites Class Warfare Between the 1% and the 99%
Posted on 02/27/2012 12:04:08 PM PST by Repeat Offender
click here to read article
Ancient American custom.
My favorite aunt was a hair stylist when I was a boy, and she would frequently favor me with a large handful of the coins she received as tips. I've been conditioned to think well of tipping :)
In Costa Rica, they just refused to accept it. Like I said, when I tried to leave it, the girl chased me down to give it back. There’s a 10% service charge (by law) on all restaurant food their though, so it’s possible that people don’t try to tip often, and like I said, it’s now becoming more common. Back when I first lived there, there weren’t many tourists like today, lol. Oh the stories I could tell.
... or an Australian!
Awful convenient story coming from a bunch of people known for lying and exaggerating....
My biggest concern is that a higher-up in the banking industry couldn’t figure out he should have rounded up to $1.34.
that pic is telling...ant ‘banker worth his salary wouldve been educated in ‘rounding’ and wouldve tipped 1.34, therefore i believe this story to be an ows prop...
Lots of people. Good waitstaff and barstaff make good money in tips.
Then you add on the fact that not only are they taxed on the $2.13 an hour (I was paid $2.33 my last waitress job) they are also taxed on their "sales." The last I knew the IRS considered that most wait staff would make 8% in tips on total sales and thus their weekly paychecks not only reflect the tax with held on the hourly wage, but also on 8% of their "sales."
I RARELY tip 20%, and only then if the service is OUTSTANDING. (A real rarity, anymore)
I grew up being told that 10% was “Customary”. Where did this 20% BS come from?
This reminds me of the best tipping story I have ever heard:
A reasonably well-off woman was traveling alone, and was staying for a week at a posh hotel with a fine restaurant where she planned to dine most evenings. On the first night, she was treated shoddily — seated near the kitchen door, provided inattentive service (there is or was a perception among service personnel that women traveling alone are poor tippers) — nonetheless, she left a lavish tip on the order of 25% of the sizable bill.
The next night, she returned, was seated at the best small table in the restaurant, had the staff attending instantly to her every whim. At the end of the meal, she asked that the head waiter be sent to her table. She opened her purse, and, handing him a penny, said “The tip last night was for the service I got tonight. This is for last night.”
I’m going to correct these two big, old, fat whoppers of a lie, right now.
“You do realize that their pay is ratcheted down so that if they get the tip level the social mavens insist upon they will then achieve minimum wage?”
“Because their minimum wage per hour is $2.13.”
In states that don’t have minimum wage equal to or greater than the Federal Minimum wages, there are sometimes special exceptions to the WAY a minimum wage is met. I have worked in this industry for many years, in mmultiple states. Saying that the minimum wages for Waiters and Waitresses is a BIG FAT LIE, and waiters and waitresses don’t make minumum wages for long.
The way it works is that the employer must from an amount of $2 (and change), towards the hourly wage. Then the tips get factored in and credited towards the minumum wage. If those surpass the $7.25/hour, then the employer pays no more. However, if that does not reach the FEDERALLY required $7.25/hour the EMPLOYER MUST pay more wages until it gets to the $7.25/hour. Now, in my years of food service, AND restaurant management., I have never, ever, ever, once even HEARD of someone not breaking minumum wage with tips added. If they didn’t they wouldn’t have a job long, because they’d have been fired anywa, and replaced by management for someone who could get the minimum through tips.
The average tipped restaurant employee makes between $30,000 and $50,000/year PART TIME. This argument about tipping is not about meeting minimum wage, it’s about getting $15 /hour, rather than $10 (if you are terrible at the job), or about getting $25/hour, rather than $20.
Don’t believe the liars, and the bleeding hearts that claim that service people don’t get paid enough. They can always find a job with technical expertise and training if they don’t like working with people. But the fact is, that the minimum wage is NO different for people who are waiters/waitresses, than for the rest of us. If they don’t work well enough to get tips, then the employer still pays the difference, by law. So let’s end that lie, here and now.
Waiters and waitresses work for tips. It’s part of our economy and culture. Europeans do it differently, but we’re in the USA. It is understood and agreed between the govt (that exempts restaurants/bars from paying the standard minimum wage) and the restaurants/bars that the bulk of a waiter/waitresses income will be from tips.
The alternative, for a restaurant to afford to pay a waiter/waitress in lieu of tips, is to raise prices of food and beverages to incorporate higher waiting labor costs. Your $100 tab would be $120-130, quality of service notwithstanding. As it is, you might leave a $20 tip on a $100 tab. Or you could leave a $10 or $50 tip. Customer’s option. Our current system is voluntary; waiters/waitresses take their chances that by providing good service they will be appropriately rewarded. Or not.
In this case, it could have been poor service; it could have been a cheapskate, who really knows? But a 1% tip is offensive, which may well have been the point. Or, it could just be a manufactured story.
People stiff waiters all the time. This is national news?
How about a study on tipping based on racial demographics? That’d actually be worth a read.
Regardless of the circumstances, nobody is entitled to a tip, period.
I have left 15-20% tips at times when service was less than sterling but that is my decision. I had a waitress follow me out of a restaurant complaining that the 20% tip that was left was not enough because she had to wait on my then pre-school grandkids who left a small mess (most of which we had already cleaned up). I worked for 4 years in a restaurant and I understand tips and service and ran her snotty rear back into the restaurant when I told her to get her manager so that we could discuss the matter. They lost our business for over 4 years as a result.
To me, the service is almost as important as the food. 20% is for outstanding service. 0% is for anything less. Actually, I’ll tip 10%+/- sometimes. Depends.
When I was a bartender we always had a little special surprise for stiffs when they showed their face again,and they always did since stiffs are self-absorbed morons.Also I worked at a fancy restaurant on the Jersey Shore that got alot of wealthy patrons and they always took care of the help.The biggest stiffs were always kids or big mouth libs.
As in "Blazing Saddles" it's twu, it's twu.
White males 35-55 are the best tippers followed by females in the same age group. Younger early 20 something males and older males 65+ are low tippers...unless they were in food service.
I did plenty of food service when I was younger.
It left no doubt how many truly pathetic a-holes there are in the world.
As for people who say it's not "real work" -- you wouldn't last a week.
I agree 100%. Pay thee real wages, and fire them if they don’t do the job.
You're right, I remember seeing that somewhere. It still doesn't sound right. I would guess it's either some kind of twisted prank between the "employer" and the "employee" or that it is now an ex-employee, because someone who's that big of an asshole wouldn't tolerate a snitch working for him (or her).
Just in case you’re curious, the IRS doesn’t always tax you based on sales. What they do, is that they have a certain percent that they know is customary for the industry, say most tipped employees get %8 (to use your figure) of their total sales, in tips. So they know people don’t pay on the cash, all the time. So what they do is if you’re reporting below that 8% average, they charge you on top, to stop the people who are hiding the cash tips. Not saying it’s right, or that you were, but that’s the reason why. It’s not meant to be an “extra” tax (on top of what you pay), but an alternative minimum, per se, way to catch the skaters.
The one time I can remember NOT leaving a tip was when the waiter was a sloppy looking mouthbreather with stringy, greasy hair wearing an obama hope and change button.
Lunch entrees there average about $12. So it was either a large party or they were drinking heavily.
I wonder if folks know that bartenders and servers don’t really get a salary at all.That measley little 2.13 an hour vanishes after you claim your tips every week for the IRS.When I worked behind the bar I got a paycheck for ZERO dollars every single week.The only income you make at all comes from the tip.On the other hand you do get to mess with alot of snotty libs
I agree 100%.
And as you mentioned, the wait staff REMEMBERS. They have minds like elephants when it comes to this. All the people that say they don't tip and visit the same restaurant over and over...well that extra seasoning may be "special". I'm not saying it is right but it happens.
Besides working in food services everyone needs to watch the movie "Waiting"
Me too. But then again, 99% of the time I'm eating at local Mom and Pop joints where the servers are, more often than not, their kids. Or friends of their kids.
Funny, in the small town I live in, there have been a number of chain restaurants (or higher-end chain-type restaurants) that have opened and closed in the past few years. Usually in the same locations. People shake their heads and sadly say that the area just won't support dining out. But the local Mom and Pops....who provide good food and service at an affordable price .... just keep on motoring along.
IMHO, I'd rather eat at a BBQ joint, run by a guy who's been perfecting his art for the past 20 years (and who likely learned it from his Dad, who learned it from his, and so on) than some Olive Garden or Applebee's. Or a ripoff lookalike of them. And, judging by the local economy, I'm not the only one who thinks that way.
They would not last a slammed Friday or Saturday night. You know what I mean.
I could never figure that out.
Particularly since the "employee" had the time to take a picture of the credit card slip supposedly written by his boss. Not something most people do when they are out to lunch with their boss.
"To add insult to injury the word "tip" was circled on the receipt, and the banker wrote "get a real job" on the bill. The picture of the receipt was taken and uploaded to the blog Future Ex-Banker by a person who was dining with the anonymous banker. As expected, the blog received a lot of attention and has now been taken down."
Also, since the person who took the photo ate lunch and got served by the same waitperson they could and should have tipped the waitperson themselves if they felt the waitperson was getting mistreated. But they didn't.
They felt it was better to have the story than to tip the waitperson. So much for their integrity. They pretend to care about the waitperson, but really don't either. Or the paltry tip was justified in their mind too.
I have two close friends who bartend. The hourly wage is $2.50 an hour, tips are expected to make up the difference between that and minimum wage. One, a very good bartender makes over 3K a month.
If I get good service I tip. Down at my favorite watering hole I walk in and my beer is waiting for me at my favorite bar stool. I pay $2 for the beer and leave a $5 tip.
"If you are being paid $2.13 an hour, get a new job or go on unemployment... your better off on welfare-money wise.Wow! You're on a conservative forum and that's your response? What a class act you are.
Who would take a job that paid that?"
Because with tips you can make a lot more.
I read the first few comments and no one seemed to think that she gave bad service but that was the first thing that came to my mind. If the banker was just an a...hole he would have just left the $1.33 tip and left. He would not have written the suggestions on the bill. She did something or failed to do something for him to respond this way.
“IMHO, I’d rather eat at a BBQ joint, run by a guy who’s been perfecting his art for the past 20 years (and who likely learned it from his Dad, who learned it from his, and so on) than some Olive Garden or Applebee’s. Or a ripoff lookalike of them.”
We refer to these “clone” restaurants as “O’Chilibee’s Roadhouse.” Their menus are all the same and the processed food is all the same, as it is delivered by Sysco Food Services. It’s kind of like the old multi-purpose stadiums of the 1970’s; if you went to a game in Riverfront Stadium, you might as well say you had also been to Busch, Three Rivers & the Vet. They were the same bland stadiums, they now are the same bland restaurants.
I used to work for an absolute clod who tipped poorly when the service was fantastic, and didn't tip at all for anything less than exemplary. Unfortunately, I traveled and ate out with him often. And, since he was the boss, he'd get the check.
Many was the time I picked up the tip. Occasionally he'd catch me and chew on me for it. I said, "screw him", no need to punish the server for my boss' shortcomings.
Same guy used to look forward to my reviews (I'm in a position where I rarely get any feedback, I'll go years with just getting raises and a 'keep up the good work'). Where most managers would look at a review as a formality, or a give and take session....this clown looked at it as an opportunity to discuss my shortcomings - both real and perceived - in exquisite detail. In fact, where most companies do them yearly (if ever) this clown saw fit to review his staff on a quarterly basis.
My theory is the waitress was running off at the lip about “The 1%,” spewing talking points, so the guy just decided to show her what 1% means.
“In 2010, the 1 percent income level was $380,354 and up. Its entirely possible the banker is in the top 1 percent.”
Ah, so. I thought America was wealthier than that.
Not exactly - tipping didn’t get into vogue until just after the Civil War. At a time during the Depression there were signs in some establishments that stated: “No Tipping. Keep Your Change” - my feelings are if someone has a classy restaurant that makes big bucks, drive their Beemers, they can jolly well pay their waitstaff a decent wage. Why expect the public to make up what the employers won’t pay? Just saying.
Looks like the behavior of a gay Bank of America executive.
Well actually it's only the high end restaurants where tipping is done. You go to places like Sizzler or California Cafe, or Johnny Rockets you don't tip.
Indeed. Perhaps the greatest irony is a bunch of people sitting around on their bosses' time, day after day, posting on FR, then saying food service is not "real work".
I can see that and I have no problem with tipping. My contention is these high priced Fern and Fan places where the owner is making a killing that won’t pay a decent wage and depends on the public basically paying his staff.
Thanks for the details, I very much appreciate them.
I myself tip quite, well, liberally, usually 20% unless the service is poor. I’ve worked as a waiter and know what it’s like. I would assume you have been in that position also and know what it’s like.
You do realize that their pay is ratcheted down so that if they get the tip level the social mavens insist upon they will then achieve minimum wage?
Take it a step further. If they don’t get tips, the employer is required to make up the difference to meet the federal minimum wage standard. It is in the best interest of the establishment to have employees that receive tips that result in their income meeting or exceeding the minimum wage. When it exceeds it, the employer is only required to pay the $2.13 per hour.
You can be charged for assault in many jurisdictions if you adulterate the product. I don't think exceptions are made if the vic is a moron or deserves it.
Nothing will be bad. Nothing will be good, either.
I eat at a lot of those kind of places with work. Where you have 5 normal people, 4 women on diets, 3 people that grill their waiter about every last detail of their food preparation (you know the type, I always want to yell "RELAX! IT'S JUST A @#$%@ SANDWICH!!" at them), 2 people that talk nonstop about their food allergies, and one fruitcake who says she's "A Vegan, but will eat fish. Sometimes pork. And hamburgers occasionally" ..... And all of them will find something to order on the menu.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.