Skip to comments.Marine Corps officer files whistle-blower complaint with DOD
Posted on 03/10/2012 7:01:43 AM PST by DJ Taylor
A Marine Corps officer has filed a whistle-blower complaint with the Department of Defense alleging that he was retaliated against for voicing concerns about a commander who put U.S. troops in danger in Afghanistan.
Maj. Fred C. Galvin of the 3rd Marine Expeditionary Force, currently stationed in Okinawa, Japan, filed the complaint earlier this week through a former Fayetteville lawyer.
Galvin, a 24-year Marine Corps veteran, had been facing the potential end of his military career until Thursday.
That's when he went before a Marine Corps Board of Inquiry at Camp Butler, Japan.
The board was charged with determining if Galvin should be separated for "failing to demonstrate acceptable qualities of leadership ... failing to achieve or maintain acceptable standards of proficiency" and having a "record of marginal service."
Galvin's civilian lawyer, Mark Waple of Wilmington, said the three-person board unanimously ruled that the allegations were not substantiated.
Galvin is asking the Department of Defense's inspector general for a full investigation into events that occurred in Afghanistan in June. He alleges that Marines were needlessly put at risk one day that month by close supporting fire during a firefight.
(Excerpt) Read more at tfp.org ...
Chesty Puller is alive and well in our current USMC.
What happened to the Charge of the Light Brigade?
24 years and only a Major? Hmmm...
He may be a Mustang
24 years and only a Major? Hmmm...
Even so, with downsizing etal, he probably is on a ‘passed over list’, which would put his ‘career’ in jeopardy.
My guess is he's a "Mustang" with at least 10 years service as an NCO before OCS. He just doesn't look "Prissy" enough to be a "college boy" officer and that would explain his deep concern for his Marine's lives.
24 and Major ALREADY?
Has the PC idiocy infiltrated the military this bad?
Am I missing something?
First you have to ba a 2nd Lt., then Lt., then Captain, THEN Major.
If the media is embracing this individual I am guessing he is a PC liberal over-promoted and now whining.
[disclaimer: I did not read the story- I wanted to see how close I could get, with YEARS of experience watching libtard media handling of the military]
How’d I do?
Good article. Sounds like a hearts and minds COIN enthusiast commander is screwing a good officer. The commander dithered for 50 minutes, asking about civilians in the area, etc. Then dropped the 500 pounder in lieu of precision hellfires that were available. Then the fight went in for for more hours with no more fire support for recon.
The remark about sacrificing marines for the greater good was made to the major the next day. And it was when he was explaining why he was so overly hesitant to approve fire support. That he was willing to kill marines to save a few Afghan civilians.
Just a guess, but hellfire helos probably had to depart for fuel while he dithers for 50 min. By the time he decided to actually support the men, a 500 pounder was probably his only option. So yes, the commander did needlessly endanger them.
The Major is in his 40’s.
Uh, not very well. Maybe you should read the article before posting stupidity?
From the article: Galvin, a 24-year Marine Corps veteran...
This means he has 24 years of service. Everyone else who has posted understood what this means...except you of course.
24 year Marine Corps veteran. Possibly a mustang ... (former enlisted).
wow - i totally misread that
*sigh* [...heads for more coffee]
bite me jerk face
I specifically STATED what I was doing
Have a nice day and as we always say to idiots...
Thank you for your interest in military affairs.
I know for a fact that Maj. Galvin is a Mustang, because I served with him from 95-96.
You forgot your /sarc tag. Be careful of that because you end up looking like a moron.
I know what you mean, but I thought "mustangs" went the WO route?
By prissy college boy, I guess you mean this guy
This prissy college boy was Maj. Doug Zembiec. He was also known by his Marines as the Lion of Fallujah. He was an All American Wrestler as the U.S. Naval Academy and served in Kosovo, Afghanistan, and Iraq. He earned a Silver Star, Bronze Star and two Purple Hearts. He was killed in combat in Iraq.
What the hell is that stupid friggin' statement supposed to mean? If you go to college and then lead men, you don't care about their lives? Grow up.
Your instincts are good but you're way off on this one.
The major is the good guy here. Marine Corps command is going right down the freaking toilet. What they did to the Hadithas Marines, for example, was a disgrace and an obscenity.
"I'm going to win the Medal of Honor, even if I have to fill a damned seabag with dogtags to do it" -- Chesty Puller
LH, you forgot the "Moron" tag.
Your comments are pretty “prissy”. Better to keep such comments to yourself.
From Private to Major
And yes, also a ‘college boy’.
I know- I misread it as a 24 year-old marine
The media usually does not cover a story where a Marine is the good guy.
I understand you meant ..doesn't look Gunny enough
But our battlefields from Saratoga to Franklin to the Marne and Belleau Wood to Normandy or Okinawa to the A Shau Valley and now to the middle east and near Asia prissy college boys wearing uniforms have died on your behalf
the OSS was almost entirely college boys
and the German WWII officer korps..except politial officers was almost 100 percent highly educated and even worse...aristocrats...but yet few would argue their skills at battle command
prissy college boys with the right soldiers under them can be an issue
Patton was a prissy college boy and Thomas J Jackson was a college boy and egads...a prissy college professor too
many 2nd lts start out green yes...but not all remain prissy
Didn’t I CLEARLY say I had not read the article? Your comment would have been useful AND constructive until you called me stupid.
The name calling was where you stepped over the line, for calling me stupid for doing exactly what I said I was doing.
I was trying to make a point that the MEDIA usually does not cover stories where a Marine is the GOOD GUY.