Skip to comments.Justices meet Friday to vote on health care case
Posted on 03/29/2012 5:26:14 PM PDT by Outlaw Woman
WASHINGTON (AP) -- While the rest of us have to wait until June, the justices of the Supreme Court will know the likely outcome of the historic health care case by the time they go home this weekend.
After months of anticipation, thousands of pages of briefs and more than six hours of arguments, the justices will vote on the fate of President Barack Obama's health care overhaul in under an hour Friday morning. They will meet in...
(Excerpt) Read more at hosted.ap.org ...
According to this, Kennedy has changed his mind on other decisions at the very last minute. And any of them can change their mind at any point.
Is this a very fast vote? History tells us that if a jury returns with a verdict quickly it usually means guilty. Maybe the dems are guilty of unconstitutionality.
Wonder how long before their decision is leaked?
Any hope we get a leaky tweet from an “anonymous source at the Court ???
Hello there Outlaw woman!! Where have you been! BTW.....Did they read the thousands of pages in the health care? Likely not....nobody has.
No...not fast...but their opinions etc they will write and present will take long hours.
They meet alone in a conference room. Seated at the table according to seniority. They speak in a traditional order with John Roberts speaking first. But you knew that because you read the article ... right? :)
This is the ‘straw’ vote.
And don’t forget this is from the AP.
History tells us that if a jury returns with a verdict quickly it usually means guilty.
Wonder how long before their decision is leaked?
2 cell phones will be on or the place is bugged ,seconds or minutes
These High Priests work on Fridays?
According to the article, leaks have happened only a couple of times.
Kagen will leak to Obama , bet on it.
It's even worse - not nine but one - Kennedy (revenge of the Kennedys!)
The Founders didn’t structure all of this to make it easy for tyrants to pull shite like nobamacare. These nine often have revelations or maybe visits from the Founders on Turning Point cases in spite of their political feelings and actually do what’s good for America and her key concept - FREEDOM. When the crux is YOU, your place in history is hard to ignore.
But, this time, there are 2 bona fide Obamaphiles that shouldnt even be there, sitting in on the judgement.
Kagan will be hot-linked to the White House.
Well, the big picture has it... 60 'Rat sinators, 0 repubs, 219 'Rat congresscritters, 0 repubs, and.... Justice Kennedy will decide the fate of a nation.
I don’t recall the supremes ever leaking, but this could be a first.
From what I understand from the article, this is the vote on which the opinions will be written and exchanged and minds possibly changed. The only lib I see as a possible change is Sotomeyer. Kennedy is a loose cannon imo but ‘sounded’ fair & concerned during the snippets I heard.
You betcha. And if it's good news for them...they won't be able to contain themselves. I'm not so sure they can keep their mouths shut either way...their libs after all.
Meanwhile, Aunt Ruthie will just leak.
Yep. Bet she has a hotline directly to the Marxist.
SCOTUS always conferences on the Friday after arguments to take a tentative vote. The reason for the tentative vote is to decide who will write the majority opinion: if the Chief Justice is in the majority, he assigns the justice who will write the opinion for the Court; if the Chief Justice is not in the majority, the senior justice in the majority assigns the opinion. (Any justice can also write their own concurring or dissenting opinion.) Votes can (and very often do) change once the draft opinions are circulated.
Hello there Caww!
Regarding reading: Ha..I think not. It is not their job to read the bill although that is what the government solic. atty was trying to convince them to do.
Obama may have dirty info on Kennedy or some of the other Justices and will use that information to intimidate.
You really believe that? I wish it were true... but I know it is not.
One thing the article does not mention is that the court may desire for a number of reasons to announce this decision as soon as they can get the opinions written. Some of those reasons are:
1. The further away from the elections they can make it the less political impact it may have. I think Justice Roberts is trying to keep the court out of politics as much as possible.
2. Every day that goes by, the more this law is implemented. If it is to be overturned, sooner is better than later.
3. Congress may need to act if the entire law is overturned and the sooner before the election, the more likely Congress will be able to summon the political will to act.
From what I read they always vote on Fridays on case heard that week as a matter of practice. Rush was related info from a lawyer friend about this too. I don’t if they will make a decision Friday but they will vote on it.
We'll know by the incredible avalanche of weeks of media hysteria over radical conservative judges who might ignore the will of the people. Rats will go nuts on the floor of the House and Senate about possible judicial overreach and the tradition of stare-decisis. Let the show begin.
Kagen not recusing herself when she was so intimately involved in the advocacy for ObamaCare should be an impeachable offense. As Michele Bachmann said tonight on Mark Levin show, the four activist liberal judges showed their favoritism during the oral hearings by asking questions supporting the government case. They solidly support Obama care and will not change their minds. It comes down to Justice Kennedy and though he asked tough questions of the solicitor general, his last statement that maybe this issue deserves support gave Bachmann and others pause.
Sadly, I fear you will be right.
Just curious as to what rates as Front Page News here at FR and why this article was pulled. Do you not feel that the vote on this marxist plan is newsworthy?
Just very interested so that I can be a good little FReeper and fall in line with this particular mods whims
Does Scalia have a favorite watering hole he likes to go to at the end of a week?
This is going to be a lulu. While most of the conservative justices will likely go for the meat-and-potatoes constitutional issues, it is also likely that Justice Thomas is going to surprise everyone with a masterful opinion that will send all the other justices back to their offices to review the history books.
That is, the other conservatives might want to kill Obamacare, but Thomas may go way beyond that to undermine a whole lot of 20th Century unconstitutional progressivism.
Two of the most important “liberalism out of control” clauses abused in the constitution are the “interstate commerce” clause that previous courts had even extended to to put intra-state commerce under federal management; and the “general welfare” clause, which is the fundamental basis of the welfare state.
If Thomas can be persuasive enough to convince the other conservative justices to agree with him against these, it could rattle the unconstitutional parts of the federal government to the bones.
It wouldn’t just wipe out Obamacare. It could take an axe to half the federal government.
I’m very suspicious of the Regime in that it pretty much allowed a fast track hearing of their prized legislation. They may have calculated that a June “unconstitutional” vote will provide the spark to a summer of race riots and civil disobedience. Obama would use this to initiate Marshall law.
I hope you’re right actually. But the article indicated that June is still the time frame to announce. Have they ever announced decisions earlier than scheduled? Do you know? I’ve never really paid too much attention to the time frames.
” Can you believe Nine Citizens are deciding the fate of a Nation?”
Beats the hell out of ONE!!
You may beleive, but only Kreskin KNOWS the future.
I also don’t know for sure what the Supremes will do, but I beleive they will do the right thing because in our history through many trials and tribulations, many worse than we now face, America has always come out on top.
She is optimistic that the whole law will get broomed.
It'll give them a reason to talk about his white wife again. And her activism against AHA.
But, in the tense racial climate right now, they will definitely emphasize the "white".
To think that our nation hangs in the balance with these black robbed jokers.
It should have NEVER even gotten this far!
No matter which way it goes the country will be divided even further. Thanks to the current pResident in office.
How is it that the SC can keep that information from leaking, yet the Congress and WH leak like a sieve.
Oh, I forgot about the OJ trial. Thanks for the information about the court. Oh, well, I sure was hoping for a quick, gavel down, smack down for Nobama.
Here’s my prediction ,,,,,
The vote will be four to four until one side decides to set Anthony Kennedy up with a Las Vegas hooker , buys them both a surf and turf dinner , tickets to see Wayne Newton and a weekend in the finest Penthouse suite in town .
Now you know the outcome .