Skip to comments.Arizona Birther Bill Faces Obstacles
Posted on 03/31/2012 5:31:07 PM PDT by Kukai
The Arizona legislature is currently considering the Candidate Certification Bill, a so-called "birther" measure which directly calls into question Barack Obamas eligibility to serve as President. If successful, the legislation would determine if the President's name may be placed on the Grand Canyon State's ballot in November.
HB 2480 would require any candidate on the ballot to sign an affidavit confirming their eligibility determination, and imposes a penalty of perjury if the candidate is later found to be ineligible. Introduced by State Representative Carl Seel (left), the bill passed the Senate Government Reform Committee, but is now sitting in a senate committee. It would still need to pass the full House and Senate before being sent to Gov. Jan Brewer.
Our ballot, no matter what office someone is running for, should have the highest level of validity, asserted Seel. That couldnt be more American, and it couldnt be more nonpartisan.
The bill has the support of a number of members of the state legislature, as well as Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, who assembled a group of investigators six months ago to gather evidence on the authenticity of President Obamas birth certificate after the certificate was released last year and posted on the White House website in a PDF.
"It's very controversial, but something has to be done," Arpaio told The Arizona Republic. "It's very important to at least have some law that you have to show that you were born in the United States."
In fact, it was the concerns raised by Arpaio that compelled Rep. Seel to draft the eligibility bill. Arpaio's lead investigator, Mike Zullo, has concluded thus far that the Obama birth certificate appears to be a forgery as well as a fraud, and that the documentation is "constructed and presented for a purpose. That purpose was to deceive."
Arpaios investigation is continuing to examine the validity of Obamas birth certificate as well as his Selective Service Registration card, which Arpaio believes is also fraudulent. This investigation is not going away," he maintained. "It is an ongoing investigation.
According to Seel, "[HB 2480] gives the average citizen the capacity to challenge any candidate appearing on the Arizona ballot, whether they are properly qualified to be on the said ballot and the capacity to preserve, defend and protect their Constitution.
The bill also requires that national party chairmen sign on behalf of their candidates, and if that candidate is later found to be ineligible, both the candidate and the party chair would be charged with perjury.
But while the bill has the support of members of both the state Senate and House, it is being held up by Senate President Steve Pierce, who claims that he will not clear the way for the measure to come to the Senate floor until Senator Nancy Barto chair of the Healthcare and Medical Liability Reform Committee where the bill is currently being stalled allows its passage.
Seel contends that the bill is being stalled because Senator Barto has solicited from Seel a laundry list of names of all the Arizona Senators who have committed to vote for the bill. Critics assert that Bartos demands are unorthodox, as most legislatures will function on an honor system of sorts where lawmakers give their verbal commitment to support a bill. Some suspect that the list of names may be used in an attempt sway each of the lawmakers on the list before the vote reaches the floor. If the bill were to be voted down, it would virtually prohibit any chance for revival.
Last year, Governor Brewer vetoed a similar bill because she was concerned that it gave too much power to Arizona's Secretary of State to judge the qualifications of all candidates who file to run for office, not simply the President. Rep. Seel says the new bill addresses the Governor's previous concerns.
The Huffington Post explains:
Brewer vetoed the legislation, which would have made Arizona the first state to pass a proof-of-citizenship requirement for candidates. The governor specifically opposed an amendment that would have required candidates who could not provide a birth certificate to instead provide "baptismal or circumcision certificates, hospital birth records and other documents" in order to get on the state's ballot.
Brewer said the legislation went "a bridge too far."
"I never imagined being presented with a bill that could require candidates for president of the greatest and most powerful nation on earth to submit their 'early baptismal or circumcision certificates,'" she said. "This measure creates significant new problems while failing to do anything constructive for Arizona."
According to World Net Daily (WND), a number of other states are considering similar legislation. In fact, 11 states have already drafted bills that would force presidential candidates to prove their citizenship before being permitted on the ballot. WND reports, There exists virtually no mechanism in the U.S. for investigating whether or not a presidential candidate meets the Constitutions Article 2, Section 1, natural born citizen requirement.
In Georgia, for example, HB 401 introduced by Rep. Mark Hartfield, would have required candidates for President to submit long-form birth certificates showing their birth parents residence addresses as well as other information. The provision required every candidate for federal office who is certified by the state executive committee of a political party or who files a notice of candidacy shall meet the constitutional and statutory qualifications for holding the office being sought.
Several individuals challenged President Obamas candidacy in Georgia this year, holding a two-hour hearing before an administrative law judge. Judge Michael Malihi threw away the evidence and ruled in favor of President Obama. That ruling is currently pending before the state Supreme Court, which has not yet heard arguments in the case.
Still, Georgias birther bill failed to receive a critical vote to move it to Georgias Senate.
New Hampshire has been the only state to sign on to a bill that clarifies eligibility requirements. Its HB 1245, signed by Democratic Governor John Lynch, requires a statement under penalty of perjury that a candidate meets qualification requirements of the U.S. Constitution.
Political analyst David Johnson contends that the birther movement is gaining a bit of traction among voters: "A third of independent voters right now have a question about Barack Obama's citizenship. They don't believe he was born in the US. This has grown dramatically, even more than among Republican voters. And the independents are going to decide the 2012 elections."
Despite the numerous efforts against the Presidents eligibility, Obama seems to take the birther movement as a joke. At his St. Patricks Day reception, visiting Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny presented the President with an official certificate of Irish heritage, noting, These are very rare. As rare as the man himself. The President quipped, This will have a special place of honor alongside my birth certificate, drawing a big laugh from the crowd.
Gov. Jan Brewer has already signaled that she will sell us out.
“Gov. Jan Brewer has already signaled that she will sell us out.”
She just endorsed mittens. I guess that could be construed as a signal she will see out AGAIN.
Gov. Jan Brewer has already signaled that she will sell us out.
Well, nothing new I' afraid.
Brewer didn’t even want to sign SB1070.....she waited until the last minute. She has plans for higher office, methinks.
In a RAT administration?
I am about convinced that even with 100 percent proof that Obumbo is nor what he claims, the country will just say ho-hum and let it pass.
We are in the end days for the USA.
LOL...no. I’m thinking VP, or something national.
Janet gone RINO....
Nevertheless, 0b0z0 needs protection from Sheriff Arpaio’s posse, rainbow jumpsuits and no underwear.
I thought Brewer would be good for another layer, er of protection, that is!
Maybe she should go to Waco?
No, we're in the end days of 0b0z0's African communist regime.
“Brewer didnt even want to sign SB1070.....she waited until the last minute. She has plans for higher office, methinks.”
If Brewer thinks she’s a candidate for higher office, she’s delusional. The proof of birth bill is, at its very worst, ONLY common sense. She is demonstrating that she has no moral courage. If she had 1/10th of the courage that Sheriff Arpaio has, she’d be a superstar.
Jan was SOS when b0z0 ran and doesn't want to be held responsible or accountable for certifying him. I emailed and called her office back then to ask what the qualifications were to place him on the ballot. Don't even ask me what the answer was. You know.
Oh, crap. Wasn’t supposed to be all italics. Of course it’s not MY fault.
You got your point across.
Seems like a good idea ping!
B U M P
So, Brewer wants to keep SOME illegals out, just not all.
Jan is simply inviting a range war down in Southern Arizona as the Obama sponsored Mexican Drug cartels occupy federal park lands there. Then there will be martial law declared by Obama, to prevent citizens from protecting themselves and their property from the Obama Brown shirts who are armed with military ordnance in Arizona, thanks in part to “Gun Runner” by the BATF. Obama wants to destabilize every red state he can.
Jan has accepted the RINO position that Obama is a “democrat..” This is untrue.
Obama is no democrat, he is a liberal fascist black power nationalist, revenge against white America through destruction redistribution specialist traitor.
The Jan Brewers and Mitt Romneys are not prepared to handle a fascist wrecking machine.They are about to find out that they already have been over run. All it takes to scare the RINOs is a little twitch by Obama , a Trayvon Martin, and the lies published as truth by the MSM. All of a sudden Mitt Romnety gets all the endorsements? Buahahahahahahaa!
I am beginning to think , hey, let Obama win. The RINOs need further convincing of who Obama is ( a fascist), and if that takes 4 more years of Obama, why the hell should I care as a conservative , one who is again abandoned by the GOP and their little cowed running dogs like Brewer and Romney.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.