Skip to comments.NM governor's grandfather not an illegal immigrant, became a US citizen in 1942
Posted on 04/28/2012 12:46:28 PM PDT by Red Steel
(AP) Ever since taking office last year as the nation's first Hispanic female governor, New Mexico's Susana Martinez found her family tree scrutinized over whether her grandfather was an illegal immigrant.
Documents obtained by AP, however, show that he was lawfully admitted to the U.S. as a permanent resident in 1918 and became a citizen in 1942, something not even Martinez knew and a discovery that removes a potential trouble spot for someone talked about as an attractive Republican vice presidential prospect for Mitt Romney.
Martinez was surprised at the news, ...
The first-term governor insists she's not interested in and wouldn't accept a spot on the ticket. But resolving the questions lifts a "hot potato off her plate," said Larry Sabato, director of the University of Virginia's Center for Politics.
"It's been a controversy and it's always mentioned when her name comes up in connection with the vice presidency," he said. "Does it help her? Sure, if Romney has any interest in her and if she has any interest in accepting, if offered."
News accounts about a 1930 census initially fueled the idea that Martinez's paternal grandparents had illegally entered the country. The census used an "AL" to designate that her grandparents were "aliens."
she initially accepted media accounts and acknowledged that it appeared her grandparents had come to the U.S. without immigration documents.
The AP obtained a "certificate of naturalization," dated April 6, 1942, from the National Archives Southwest Region center in Fort Worth, Texas.
Sabato said questions about a candidate or elected official's family history are fair game in politics, and doubts that she would suffer much damage even if her family had entered the country illegally.
"Maybe it would be more fair if everybody were subjected to the same scrutiny," he said.
(Excerpt) Read more at newser.com ...
You mean Obama. Too many people with their heads in the sand to go there.
Now that Rubio has excluded himself from the VP by getting a stiff FEC fine, Martinez is next up on the pile.
They used the whole illegal alien grandfather against her when she was trying to keep illegals from getting driver’s licenses.
This matter of eligibility is clearly simmering on the back burner of the liberal mindset. Believe me, Sabato is no conservative.
Martinez for Veepee!
Earned square and honestly like most people back then were committed to do.
And he still had to wait years to become a full citizen!
They scourer “Dreams of My Father” when it comes to Oblamer.
They scourer “Dreams from My Father” when it comes to Oblamer.
Thanks for posting this.
“New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez threw cold water on speculation that she could be the running mate for the Republican presidential nominee, telling the Albuquerque Journal Sunday that family concerns would keep her in New Mexico.”
And I agree. Thanks for posting this.
Help me out here.... why would anyone possibly care if her grandparents came here legally or not???
Martinez is NBC. Rubio is not. Therein lies the catch. Wish I could explain it better, but others here are much more qualified and knowledgeable.
In light of the Palin precedent, she should say, “no thanks,” and run on her own merits in 2016.
I had no idea you were the final authority on who is NBC.
So pray tell us, is Obama NBC? His father was never a US citizen. Would you please rule on his NBC status so we can depose him? Or are you going to leave it to the US congress who has no problem with it obviously, and SCOTUS is not interested in taking on the case.
18 Supreme Court justices agreed. Obama is NOT an NBC.
Not really sure why you want to pick a fight with me. Can you explain? Martinez is a NBC, Rubio is not. NBC is required to be POTUS. I am not the final authority. The Constitution is.
Not meaning to pick a fight with you. I am just tired of conservatives attacking their own. Have you ever seen a liberal or a democrat attack Obama’s NBC status? Only conservatives display this self-destructive trait of eating their own.
Here we have Obama, with a fake birth certificate parading around as POTUS for 3.5 years. Obviously the powers that be are giving him NBC status. Your thinking otherwise and mine certain he is not NBC does not address reality on the ground. Obama has been obviously accepted as NBC by congress and courts. If that is so, I will give a pass to any good republican who has an authentic birth certificate proving he/she was born on US soil. That includes Rubio & Jindal, both good republicans and 1000 times better than Obama, Reid or Pelosi as leaders.
Then I’ll ask again. If she’s NBC, who cares if her grandfather was here legally or not?
There’s a difference between “attacking their own” and standing up for the Constitution. And second, nobody has given Obama NBC status. The powers that be are ignoring and/or trampling on the Constitution.
One could say that they wanted to confer eligibility on Zero, however. At the very least, the timing of their legislative hijinks is highly suspect.
Reply to number 18.
If you give Rubio and Jindal a pass because Obama is ineligible, where does it end? Whats next? Anchor babies? Al Queda kids? How bout all those Palestinians moving to the US via Obama.
It ends by defeating Obama, Reid majority leadership & keeping the house. I am most worried about my college age kid’s economic future than any other issue. If no jobs, then anchor babies won’t matter. Mexico grew faster than US recently. There is a NEGATIVE flow of illegals back to Mexico.
I only deal with reality as it exists on the ground. Not my wishful thinking. You and I do not get to decide what is constitutional. It is the congress and SCOTUS. The sooner we get it, the better we will be. That does not mean you can not vote your conscience. But it is time to NOT waste time on issues which are settled. Such as Obama’s presidential qualifications. Let us spend our energy on denying him 2nd term instead of pontificating on NBC status of Rubio or Jindal. Keeping proper priorities front and center is the smarter move.
PS: You all know as much as I on this point. I’m no expert. I just find myself reading whatever I can find on the subject of NBC.
Our previous governor, Bill Richardson made sure that illegals could get driver’s licenses legally and Governor Martinez tried to change that. The liberals tried to shame her because they told her that her grandfather was an illegal too. If she had known this at that time she could have shut them up.
Another reason, is that she has been mentioned as a vice presidential pick and unlike Obama whose citizenship and past is ignored, the news media bought into what the liberal NMexicans brought up for a gotcha and found that, low and behold, her grandfather actually came here legally and then became a citizen.
I’m just surprised that they didn’t just drop it when they found out.
Well, this isn't technically true. This is why the first amendment preserves the right for a redress of grievances, and why the amendment process is voted on and/or ratified by the states.
But it is time to NOT waste time on issues which are settled. Such as Obamas presidential qualifications.
Obama's presidential qualifications are NOT settled, except for being ineligible for office. As I said, the powers that be are ignoring the Constitution on this issue. Just because they are doing this is not a reason for us to ignore it too. If we don't fight for what's right, then more Constitutional rights will be taken away.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.