Skip to comments.Viewing child pornography online not a crime: New York court ruling
Posted on 05/09/2012 1:34:50 PM PDT by little jeremiah
In a controversial decision that is already sparking debate around the country, the New York Court of Appeals ruled on Tuesday that viewing child pornography online is not a crime.
"The purposeful viewing of child pornography on the internet is now legal in New York," Senior Judge Carmen Beauchamp Ciparick wrote in a majority decision for the court.
The decision came after Marist College professor James D. Kent was sentenced to prison in August 2009 after more than 100 images of child pornography were found on his computer's cache.
< snip >
(Excerpt) Read more at news.yahoo.com ...
Because “seeing” a crime and doing nothing to stop/prevent it, or even worse, “enjoying” it, is being an accessory after the fact.
No non-evil person could see child pornography and not want to alert authorities about it. If any one were to “see” child porn on a regular basis, they are assisting the production of it by being a user, whether they pay money or not or download or not.
That's precisely the point LJ. The cache is just part of your software's internal workings. If you visit a webpage, it caches all the pictures on that page. The cache means absolutely nothing unless there are thousands of pictures in it. You could easily load 50 to 100 just by visiting the wrong web page, following a malicious link, or a dozen other ways.
No one here on FR supports child porn. I'm certain of that. However, the more technically inclined understand this ruling, and why it's a good one. The image cache is simply not a reliable method to see if you were intentionally seeking child porn.
Now, I will grant you freely, the majority of unintentional child porn is apt to be acquired in the pursuit of legal porn, but as distasteful as that may be to some FReepers, seeking pictures of naked adult women isn't criminal.
Wise. We've been down that road before. Several states made kidnapping a capital offense after Lindbergh, and lo and behold, kidnappers no longer risked anything by killing their captives. It was repealed almost universally, and the odds of kidnap victims flipped from an odds on death to having the odds in their favor that they would survive. Capital punishment for any crime short of murder just provides and incentive to escalate that crime to murder.
Indeed, biblically odd comments.
If there were some anonymous way to rat out a locating of online kiddie porn... I believe every single soul here would be all ears, no matter what they thought about the legalities of this present situation.
When in hell will the every day working American have his rights and his family protected?...You know...the ones who’s taxes pay for all this bullshit!!!
I am all for public flogging for these perverts.
I really can’t believe we have sunk this low.
Another sickening display of adults and politicians using children for whatever purpose suits them.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.