Skip to comments.Not worth the debt (The ugly truth about student college loans)
Posted on 05/29/2012 5:19:29 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
Ive been writing for years about a bubble in higher education: too much demand, causing sky-high prices all because of cheap government money, much like the housing bubble. Now those warnings have become conventional wisdom so conventional that theyve reached The New York Times and even 60 Minutes.
Pretty much everyone agrees that the increases in tuition (which have vastly outpaced consumer prices and family incomes) and the growth in student-loan debt (which now exceeds credit-card or auto-loan debt) are unsustainable. As economist Herb Stein famously said, something that cant go on forever, wont. So, how should we respond?
For students, piece of advice No. 1 is: Dont go into debt. When I went to law school, back in the 80s, I turned down free rides at a couple of excellent schools to go to Yale Law School, even though it meant taking on a lot of student-loan debt. Im not sure Id advise anyone to do the same thing today, even to go to Yale Law, the undisputed king of the law-school rankings and Im positive I wouldnt make a similar tradeoff for many other places, even Harvard Law.
Debt is what gets people into trouble in bubbles: They borrow heavily because they think the value of what theyre buying, whether its a house or a tulip, will go up. When it stops going up, theyre sunk.
Today, the value of an education isnt going up, but the price is. Thats a bad combination. So dont borrow heavily.
Thats good advice for schools, too. Those that borrow money based on the expectation that tuition revenue will continue to increase will have problems, and, in fact, some already are. Instead, schools should be looking to cut costs and increase value
(Excerpt) Read more at nypost.com ...
In a way the bubble has started to burst. A growing trend is for students to graduate early by accumulating credits in high school and community college during the summer. WSJ reported graduation in 3 to 3 1/2 years. My son will graduate in three years which means a 25% revenue loss for the school. If one attends community college for 2 years then finishes at a four year school, that is a 50% loss in revenue.
If a kid is not a scholar, a junior college for 2 years, then the state university is the way to go.
I owe 0.00 on college debt. I went for 2 years during high school, the high school paid the bill (thank you John Q tax payer)..
I do nothing in the field I went to school for now. I am doing much better in my first year in my new field than I did in my best year during my 15 years in the field I went to college for.
I have friends with 4 year degrees who can’t find work. Me, I have them begging me. Being book smart does not mean you can do the job. Proving you can to the right people gets your name out there and the phone does the rest of the work for you.
That’s been going on for years. Trouble is, the four-year schools won’t always accept outside transfer credits (as I learned the hard way).
He said in EVERY men's room he used were facilities for muslims to wash their feet for their five times/day prayers.
F islam. FUBO.
I have a nephew who keeps harping on “Student debt forgiveness.”
I keep asking him “what was the caliber of the gun they held to your head when you promised to repay that which you borrowed?”
He, being a liberal (AKA “those with no money of their own”) keeps saying “we should support education.”
When I press him, he gives up (since he can’t win).
The idea that loans are sacred obligations that must be repaid is lost on this generation (and, from some FR responses lost on my generation as well).
I am pretty sure the official motto of the USA is “boo hoo, poor me! I chose badly! FIX MY BOO BOO!!”
>>He said in EVERY men’s room he used were facilities for muslims to wash their feet for their five times/day prayers.<<
I would have pissed in them.
And the scools spend every dime. They have bloated the administrations while the cost of scooling increases to the rate of inflation by double or triple. and over a decade...or two, the cost of school is waaaaaaay overpricved , so the students incur far more debt then should normally be had.
Second: I work in Afghanistan and I have a bird's eye view of life here. Most don't pray, or pray very little. Most don't wash religiously.
Third: Muslims demand these hyper-religious accomadations in the US just to be annoying.
It's one thing to go into debt when you have awesome prospects, like 2 of my cousins, one of whom has law firms fighting over her once she finishes law school, and her brother, who had to decide which of 9 med schools to attend, after having graduated with degrees in biology and microbiology from Stanford with a 3.98GPA.
They're way smarter than I am.
Several thoughts and observations:
- colleges and universities MUST stop the “grievance McStudies” degrees.......Black Trangendered Studies is political propaganda and sin....not scholarship
- the trend has already begun to charge STEM majors (science, technology, engineering, mathematics) more tuition than for your crap like Wimins Studies. It should be the opposite.......charge the productive degrees that require tons of work the lower price
- slash the living hell out of budgets........get rid of every “Diversity Chair” and associated crappola. Fire all of them
Education spending is nothing more than a slush fund for liberalism.
Unlimited subsidized loans to students
Allows grossly overpriced tuition
Allows huge salaries for liberal profs and admins
Who make significant donations to Democrats
Great comments from someone who is on the scene. Thanks!
If student loans were to be “forgiven” by the government, and the banks were to issuing institutions, why would any taxpayer approve of future loan guarantees by government, since, it will be a one way street and the loser is always the taxpayer.
If banks are the lending institutions for those student loans, and students are then forgiven those loans, why would any bank ever again make any loans to students?
Why would any business ever want to hire any graduate who started out his professional career wanting and getting his student loans erased from “personal responsibility”?
That's NOT the problem. It's liberal elites feeling they can work 8 hours a week and be paid $200,000 a year.
That's not the only way they rip off students and their parents ...
Colleges and the rip-off professors and administration put out textbooks that change frequently so students can't buy 'used' books.
Had a friend years back that used to write some of them - the publishers told him to make a few changes, they would change the cover and voila - college students would be screwed again by those 'oh so compassionate' liberals.
Headline should be:
“College Students Learn Government Debt Ruins Their Lives.”
Yes, students ARE learning something useful in college...
Truth is, you really don’t want to shake their hands.....for cleanliness reasons.
Long term, I think we have to get the government completely out of the student loan business and encourage colleges to set up their own sets of private lenders.
Hillsdale College in Michigan does exactly that. They don't even allow their students to take out government loans.
There are a handful of other conservative colleges working on similar arrangements. In Hillsdale's case, their lenders actually offer better rates than government loans in some cases because their kids actually graduate with useful, marketable skills and the default rate is very low.
Still, there will be many headaches in liquidating the government loans. Some can be sold on the open market.
Others would have to be written off. As a condition for the write-offs, some of the students should be able to fill public service jobs which are otherwise hard to fill such as medical services in an rural or inner city area.
The colleges who made such loans should also be compelled to eat a portion of them. Many of them have rich endowments which could be assessed to help pay them back. Signing up students to give you an income stream and not providing an education which has a reasonable chance of allowing them pay it back should not be cost free.
They need to be cleaned off the books one way or the other. For many kids (and their parents), the debt is simply not sustainable.
Perusing the classified section this last weekend, jobs advertised included truck drivers (CDL), nurses, automotive technicians, electricians, plumbers, etc. All could be obtained thru technical schools, community colleges and apprenticeships.
But, these are the kind of jobs where you actually have to show up regularly and work .... you know, work.
First, people have to figure out their reasons for going to college in the first place. Many don’t have a clue. They have been told to go to college in order to get a good job. College has been so dumbed down that a degree doesn’t mean that much any more, and many kids go just to party and watch sports for several years.
The entire university system is going to disappear. When one can take courses from MIT online, why spend thousands of dollars to go to Podunk U. for a degree in communications? If people want a liberal arts education, the world is already at their fingertips online. This isn’t the Middle Ages any more where books and information are rare. People can educate themselves in a myriad of ways and find their calling in life without wasting years sitting in classrooms. As usual, government is getting in the way of progress. Government schools are to education what government solar companies are to energy production.
Schools like U of Florida are starting to cut STEM classes. To expensive, and lets be honest, not PC.
Hang in there. Be safe. Come home.....our nation has TONS of crummy citizens and problems (not to mention terrible political leadership) - BUT - you will still love coming home to a nation that is a far cry from where you are working and living now. Blessings.
Land of the Brave...........
“Schools like U of Florida are starting to cut STEM classes.”
Is it because of less demand?
Cost reasons. It cost a lot to have the labs and equipment to train an engineer. A liberal arts student only need the class room and teacher.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.