Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Can Any of These House Underdogs Survive?
Rothenberg Political Report ^ | 6/8/12 | Stuart Rothenberg

Posted on 06/08/2012 6:46:26 PM PDT by randita

Can Any of These House Underdogs Survive? Stuart Rothenberg June 8, 2012 · 1:48 PM EDT

Remember their names: Reps. Charles Bass (R-N.H.), John Barrow (D-Ga.), Bobby Schilling (R-Ill.), Jim Matheson (D-Utah) and Robert Dold (R-Ill.).

If any of these five House incumbents survive, it will surprise most dispassionate observers (including some in their own parties). But upsets happen, and each of these candidates has a scenario for victory.

Moments after Bass was declared the winner in November 2010, most political insiders figured he would be doomed in 2012. But considering his past electoral success, reports of his political demise could be premature.

Bass, the son of a former Congressman and the grandson of a governor, served a dozen years in Congress before losing by 7 points in 2006, a horrible year for Republicans nationally, to Paul Hodes, the same Democrat he had defeated by 20 points two years earlier.

Four years later, Hodes ran for Senate and Bass ran to reclaim his former seat. Democrats nominated attorney Ann McLane Kuster, whose father was mayor of Concord. Kuster’s grandfather served as governor and her mother served in the state Senate as a Republican. Her mother, Susan McLane, also ran unsuccessfully for the GOP nomination for Congress in 1980.

In a mild upset, Bass won by just 3,550 votes (fewer than 2 points) in a huge Republican year. His narrow victory is one reason why so many insiders predicted his second tour in Congress would be brief.

Kuster is running again, and she is a formidable challenger. She ended March with $1 million in the bank compared to Bass’ $790,000. Democrats (and some Republicans) already count this seat as a takeover, and a May survey by the Democratic firm Public Policy Polling showing Bass and Kuster tied at 42 percent was further evidence of the Republican’s problems.

But Bass’ mild, New England manner shouldn’t be confused with political naiveté. He has been a survivor in a district that is far from automatic for a Republican — Barack Obama won it with 56 percent in 2008, and both Al Gore and John Kerry carried it as well — and his record of fiscal conservatism and moderation on social and environmental issues is in sync with district voters.

Georgia’s Barrow allegedly is serving his last term after Republicans redrew his district from one that gave Obama 54 percent to one that would have given Obama only 44 percent.

Though he supported the economic stimulus in 2009 and opposed repealing Obama’s health care law in 2010, he has cast enough votes to allow him to stress his “independence” from the national Democratic agenda, including his votes against passage of the health care reform and cap-and-trade bills, his support for the extension of the Bush tax cuts and his refusal to support Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) for Speaker in 2011.

But Barrow’s ability to win re-election last time in the face of the Republican electoral tsunami shouldn’t give Democrats too much comfort. His opponent, Ray McKinney, raised little money and didn’t run a serious race. National Republicans never helped him. Barrow’s 57 percent victory was more a reflection of the challenger’s weakness than of anything else.

Republicans won’t pick a nominee until July or, more likely, a mid-August runoff. None of the four Republicans in the race looks like a political powerhouse who can automatically take advantage of the re-drawn district’s Republican bent.

In Illinois, Schilling wasn’t expected to win in 2010, so it’s probably no surprise that nobody expects him to survive after the Democratic-controlled state Legislature redrew his already difficult district to make it even more Democratic.

But Schilling, who owned a pizza restaurant before he was elected to Congress, has a down-to-earth, blue-collar appeal that allowed him to win this very Democratic district in the first place. A May Public Opinion Strategies poll for the Republican’s campaign had him leading East Moline Councilwoman Cheri Bustos (D) by double digits, 51 percent to 35 percent.

However, that poll could be deceiving. Bustos’ fundraising is credible — she showed $470,000 in the bank at the end of March — and her standing in the GOP poll is more a reflection of her weak name identification than anything else.

Like Schilling, she is personable. And while her comments in videos on her website are filled with nothing more than boilerplate Democratic rhetoric, that could be enough given the partisan makeup of this district and the presidential year.

Utah’s Matheson once again is an underdog. So what else is new? I’ve seen this movie before. But this time the ending may be different.

Matheson always outperforms other Democrats in his district, frustrating GOP strategists who believe the seat should be theirs. Four years ago, for example, he ran 23 points ahead of Obama in the district, and two years ago he was re-elected by more than 4 points when almost every other vulnerable House Democrat was going down to defeat.

Matheson has not put together a typical Democratic record. He supported extending the Bush tax cuts and opposed his party on health care reform and cap-and-trade.

But Republican legislators redrew his 2nd district to give him new voters who don’t know him, and he is now running in the 4th district. Matheson has never faced a Republican opponent quite like Mia Love, the mayor of Saratoga Springs and the daughter of Haitian immigrants.

Love is black, Mormon, conservative and personable, an obvious change from the generic white state legislators that Matheson has usually faced and dispatched. National Republicans are likely to rally for Love’s candidacy, giving her the cash and notoriety that Matheson’s recent challengers have not had.

Finally, back in Illinois, Dold’s already difficult district was made even more inhospitable for him by redistricting.

GOP operatives were hoping Ilya Sheyman would be the Democratic challenger, but he lost the primary to businessman Brad Schneider, a mainstream Democrat. The Jewish community is not unimportant in this district, and Dold is widely seen as a reliable supporter of Israel. But Schneider, a mainstream Democrat who contributed in the past to the district’s previous Congressman, now-Sen. Mark Kirk (R), has been active on pro-Israel issues as well.

While the numbers are tough for Dold, he has the right profile for the district, and Obama’s appeal may be less than it was two years ago, even in this upscale North Shore district. Still, the Republican looks to be a clear underdog.

TOPICS: Government; News/Current Events; Politics/Elections; US: California; US: Georgia; US: Illinois; US: New Hampshire; US: Utah
KEYWORDS: 2012election; algore; annmclanekuster; bobbyschilling; bradschneider; bushtaxcuts; california; charlesbass; cheribustos; georgia; haiti; illinois; ilyasheyman; jimmatheson; johnbarrow; johnkerry; markkirk; mialove; mormons; nancypelosi; newhampshire; paulhodes; raymckinney; robertdold; saratogasprings; susanmclane; underdogs; ushouse; utah
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-27 next last

1 posted on 06/08/2012 6:46:35 PM PDT by randita
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Clintonfatigued; Impy; AuH2ORepublican; fieldmarshaldj; no dems; Kaslin; perfect_rovian_storm; ...

Of the seats mentioned, the one I hope most turns GOP is Matheson’s. Mia Love would be a great addition to the House GOP contingent.

2 posted on 06/08/2012 6:49:33 PM PDT by randita
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: randita

Dold is a sissy. It wouldnt matter much

3 posted on 06/08/2012 6:54:17 PM PDT by lookout88 (.combat officer's dad)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: lookout88

I am in Dold’s distict. I will be skipping the vote in that race. “Bipartisan Bob” is the waste of a perfectly good “R”.

4 posted on 06/08/2012 7:16:49 PM PDT by concordgrape
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: concordgrape

Me too, Arlington Heights. I can’t stand the guy. What a jellyfish

5 posted on 06/08/2012 7:45:57 PM PDT by lookout88 (.combat officer's dad)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: randita

Would be great to see a black conservative woman in the House.

I don’t know much about Rep Bass from NH but if NH has gone so far to the left that they elect another Dem to the House then I don’t see how Romney is going to carry the state, or how it can ever turn back to its Republican roots.

6 posted on 06/08/2012 7:51:13 PM PDT by TNCMAXQ
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: AdmSmith; AnonymousConservative; Berosus; bigheadfred; Bockscar; ColdOne; Convert from ECUSA; ...

Thanks randita.

7 posted on 06/08/2012 7:57:17 PM PDT by SunkenCiv (
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: randita; fieldmarshaldj; BillyBoy; AuH2ORepublican; GOPsterinMA; Clintonfatigued; NeoCaveman; ...

Barrow and Dold are meat. Some freepers in Dold-land on this thread saying they’re not voting for him. I would but I don’t think he can win that seat.

Schilling has a shot but not a great one. (burn in hell Pat Quinn and Mike Madigan and Scott Cohen) The rat candidate underwhelms me (as does the one for the Dold seat, he won the primary cause he had the most normal name) though she’s okay looking for a Stalinist witch.

I think Love will beat Matheson but he could win, Mormon Romney on the top of the ticket helps.

Bass is not an “underdog”, that race is a tossup.

Not mentioned here is another IL Republican, Joe Walsh. His district is better than any of the other vulnerable gerrymandered IL seats but he’s weak and most people think he has no chance.

8 posted on 06/08/2012 9:31:25 PM PDT by Impy (Don't call me red.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: TNCMAXQ; AuH2ORepublican

Bass had nothing to do with Romney. The state will be close (unless Romney pulls ahead). Romney will probably carry the first district and Obama the second.

As to the Republican roots, the state leg is a GOP supermajority again after 2010 and I think we will take back the Governorship.

NH is a swing state, not a rat state.

9 posted on 06/08/2012 9:40:37 PM PDT by Impy (Don't call me red.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: randita
In THIS cycle in New Hampshire talk about a Democrat defeating any sitting Republican is sophistry designed to fill up white space.Stuie doesn't want to acknowledge that Obama is on his way to pulling the whole Democrat party down at every level in almost every state.
10 posted on 06/09/2012 4:24:35 AM PDT by jmaroneps37 (Conservatism is truth. Liberalism is lies.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Impy; BillyBoy

I live in Rep. Dold’s new district, and I think that he’ll barely win, with about 50.5% of the vote. In his new district, the majority of the state legislators and county commissioners are Republicans.

Rep. Walsh will easily win. All of the voters, of the new 8th Dist., have a republican congressman, now, Walsh, Dold, Hultgren, or Roskam. The majority of those voters have a republican state senator, Murphy, Pankau, or Dillard.

11 posted on 06/09/2012 4:46:40 AM PDT by PhilCollins
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: Impy; All
Slight correction: Charlie Bass is a toss-off.
12 posted on 06/09/2012 7:37:49 AM PDT by GOPsterinMA (The Glove don't fit.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: Impy; fieldmarshaldj; Clintonfatigued; randita; NeoCaveman; BillyBoy; GOPsterinMA; unkus; ...

I don’t see how the RAT Barrow can survive in the redrawn GA-12. Democrats are delusional if they think that the liberal-to-moderate Barrow can get enough conservative votes to make it close.

As for the IL races, I would rank the endangered Republican incumbents, in order of most likely to least likely to survive, as follows:


I’d place Biggert’s odds of winning at 55%, Dold’s at 45%, Schilling’s at 40% and Walsh’s at 10%. Walsh’s CD is the least Dem of the four, but he was a fluke winner in 2010 in a GOP district and is a terrible fit for the new district.

As for Charlie Bass, I agree that reports of his demise are exaggerated. Yes, the district leans a bit Dem, and he is facing an extremely well funded challenger, but Romney could feasibly carry the district and Bass has at least even odds of holding on.

13 posted on 06/09/2012 9:40:04 AM PDT by AuH2ORepublican (If a politician won't protect innocent babies, what makes you think that he'll protect your rights?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: Impy

BTW, the RAT candidate with the most “normal” name won in IL-10, while the RAT candidate with the sexiest name (Cheri Bustos) won in IL-17—Bustos means “breasts” in Spanish.

14 posted on 06/09/2012 12:08:40 PM PDT by AuH2ORepublican (If a politician won't protect innocent babies, what makes you think that he'll protect your rights?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: randita
Getting rid of Matheson will make the Dems easier to despise across the board. If he were a Republican, I don't think I would even call him a RINO. Oh well.

He stayed with his father's party and it will probably cost him.

15 posted on 06/09/2012 12:23:46 PM PDT by R W Reactionairy ("Everyone is entitled to their own opinion ... but not to their own facts" Daniel Patrick Moynihan)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: AuH2ORepublican

I heard of people with the surname “Foot” and “Head” and “Hand” but that’s odd.

Doesn’t quite live up to her name, it is a married name after all. ;D

16 posted on 06/09/2012 11:22:48 PM PDT by Impy (Don't call me red.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: PhilCollins; AuH2ORepublican

I don’t think anyone else on the planet thinks he will “easily” win.

The district is worse but it’s still okay, I’d bet Bush still carried in 2004. But he is weak, Only the size of the wave in 2010 pulled him across, and if anything he is in a weaker position this time.

We should be thinking of who can win it back in 2014.

Would love to be wrong.

17 posted on 06/09/2012 11:30:05 PM PDT by Impy (Don't call me red.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Impy

You’re right, Bustos is her married name. Her maiden name is Callahan (which, as far as I know, is not an Irish Gaelic term for “rack” : ), and she comes from a very politically connected family of liberal Democrats (with close ties to Paul Simon and Dick Durbin):

18 posted on 06/10/2012 8:29:08 AM PDT by AuH2ORepublican (If a politician won't protect innocent babies, what makes you think that he'll protect your rights?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: randita

Bass is the instructional video for GOPe. I will be delighted if he loses.

19 posted on 06/10/2012 8:32:36 AM PDT by Jim Noble
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Impy

In 2010, Walsh won because of the Green Party candidate. Walsh beat Bean by about 300 votes, and the Green Party candidate got about 3000 votes.

However, his new district has a higher percentage of Republicans. Why do you think that Walsh might lose? His new district has few democrat elected officials.

20 posted on 06/10/2012 11:07:43 AM PDT by PhilCollins
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-27 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson