Skip to comments.St. Louis area mom killed herself, 2 kids, police say
Posted on 08/04/2012 8:19:22 AM PDT by Dallas59
GLENDALE, Mo. A suburban St. Louis woman with a history of depression bought a gun two days before she killed her two children and herself while her husband was in another part of the house, authorities said Friday.
Mitchell Murch II called police Monday to report that he heard shots. Police who responded found 42-year-old Catherine Murch in the kitchen, 10-year-old Mitchell Murch III elsewhere on the first floor and 8-year-old Mary Claire Murch on the second floor of the house the well-to-do suburb of Glendale.
Police questioned Mitchell Murch II but said they believed the case was a murder-suicide. Still, nearly two dozen investigators with the St. Louis Area Major Case Squad were assigned to the case.
(Excerpt) Read more at foxnews.com ...
Special room in hell for this monster.
Such a permanent solution to such a temporary problem.
I do wish she’d shot herself before she shot the kids.
while her husband was in another part of the house, authorities said Friday.
Somethings not right here! What did they own...a 10,000 sq. ft. house? The girl was on the second floor, the boy somewhere on the first, and the mother in the kitchen. The father wasn’t concerned after hearing the first shot?
I’m going to wait for more info before chopping the mother to shreds.
I will say God bless the poor children. Very sad.
This stinks. If she wanted to kill herself and kids in the same house as her husband she would get herself and the kids together in the same room.
Oh boy” Here we go again. Gun control, gun control. Make it stop!
“Somethings not right here!”
I thought that this case seemed odd when I read it. The husband is in the house and she is able to kill two kids (in different locations) and then herself? I am not saying that women don’t do this type of insanity but I also hope the police check out if the husband has a mistress and a large life insurance policy on his late wife. Prayers for the children... whatever the police find out.. they were totally innocent and victims of pure evil. IMHO.
Maybe the husband did it
I agree with ‘not passing the smell test’ - you’d think she’d start with the husband, or wait until he was out of the house. Wandering from floor to floor and room to room while he’s in another part of the house?
I had read another story that said the Police were looking more closely at the husband. I suppose its possible she used a pillow or something to muffle the shot to the girl upstairs. That same article said the Husband heard the first shot and thought it came from outside so he was investigating that when he heard the other two shots. The truth always seems to come out eventually.
If the husband was reading (like he said), he had to hear the first shot (the little girl). The wife then had to go up a flight of stairs and then the husband heard several more shots. Was he reading the entire time? I am on my first floor right now. If I heard anything that sounded like a gun shot, my tushy would be up and running to see what happened. Sounds fishy to me. IMHO
I’m so tired of “Depression” and “mental illness” being thrown around by default whenever someone commits murder.
If she has a “history of depression”, then she probably has a history of ingesting antidepressant drugs.
Those drugs and suicide go hand in hand.
Then it seems like the husband had a built-in excuse. I’ll kill them all and blame my severly depressed nut of a wife.
Her depression couldn’t have been post partum, kids were older. So, what caused her depression, a cheating husband? Why didn’t she kill him too? Time will tell.
No way hubby was reading the whole time she was going up and down stairs and shooting the boy several times. Sounds like the boy tried to escape meaning there was more time in there. Maybe the cops are trying to play hubby by making him believe they’re going with suicide. Whatever, it doesn’t pass the smell test.
I read the story originally in the UK Daily Mail and it showed that it was very large house, two story. Seems that the husband is wealthy. So it is possible that he didn't hear the gun shots.
I agree that this sounds off. Had I heard a gunshot somewhere in the house while my spouse and children were there, I’d have investigated BEFORE calling the police. I would not have called first. No way.
“and a large life insurance policy on his late wife.”
Whether it is still true or not I do not know but it used to be that insurance policies didn’t pay off for suicide.
Even if the husband did it he still would not collect a dime.
“Im so tired of Depression and mental illness being thrown around by default whenever someone commits murder.”
Where would you place “blamd” if not “depression” and “mental illness”.
A completely sane person who is not depressed commits suicide?
He was supposedly reading in another room. He was the biggest threat to her carrying out her deed. He’s still alive and they are dead.
Women don’t normally use a gun to commit suicide and they don’t normally kill their children. This is a big stretch to rule it murder/suicide.
“He was supposedly reading in another room. He was the biggest threat to her carrying out her deed. Hes still alive and they are dead.”
Regardless, had I heard a gunshot, knowing that my spouse and children were in the house, I would have checked on their security first rather than called the police first. Had I feared for their safety, a logical fear, I’d have gone to help or at least to make sure that they were safe rather than call the cops at the sound of gunshots. Now, had he immediately dialed 911 WHILE racing to see what had happened or was going on, then yeah, that might work, but it sounds a bit off to me as written.
I would say their own evil, desperation, and foolishness.
Dreadful. Poor kids. RIP.
Sounds off to me from the beginning too.
I could be very, very wrong. I realize that women do horrible things as well. But, this case just sounds “weird” to me. I guess time will tell....
For certain people.
I’m bipolar and I would be lost without the antidepressant and mood stabilizer.
I'm inclined to agree with your skepticism. But if the husband was outside, or in the garage, and only heard the last shots, I could understand his not getting to her before she killed the second child and herself.
Most insurance companies have a time limit on the suicide thing. If you buy the insurance and then don't commit suicide over a specified length of time then you are free and clear on the suicide thing. Example: Most policies have a one or two year limit on suicide, if you commit suicide after that, they pay off anyway.
“Most policies have a one or two year limit on suicide, if you commit suicide after that, they pay off anyway.”
That is information that I did not know. Learn something new every day. Thank you.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.