Skip to comments.Cops Rough Up and Handcuff 15-Year-Old Girl for Using Her Student MetroCard
Posted on 08/04/2012 3:52:23 PM PDT by nickcarraway
The NYPD is investigating an incident involving the roughing up and handcuffing of a 15-year-old girl for using a student MetroCard officers believed was not hers. (Spoiler: They were wrong.) On July 26, summer-schooler Alexis Sumpter was waiting for the A train at 125th Street when two plainclothes officers who had apparently seen a turnstile light indicating a student card had been swiped approached her and demanded to know her age.
When Sumpter could not produce an ID, the cops called her a liar and summoned a third officer, who "[pressed] her face against the wall while the two others cuffed her" while saying they "didn't owe an explanation" for the harsh treatment. They then called Sumpter's father, who vouched for her age, but the girl was only uncuffed and released when her mother brought a copy of her birth certificate to the station. There, officers finally explained their reasoning, which was that her daughter "looked like an adult." Take note, teens: There are some disadvantages to looking older than your age especially when you live in a city with a very, very aggressive police force.
Obviously TSA rejects hired by the PD.
Very good thing she didn’t have her dog with her.
Ve must have your papers!
Just imagine what they would have done if she was holding a big gulp soda.
You need ID to prove who you are to get on the subway or 3 cops are on your case but illegals have freedom of movement at all times.
On July 26, African American John Smith was waiting in line to vote at the 21st Precinct when two plainclothes officers approached him and demanded to know his voter registration information.
When Smith could not produce an ID, the cops called him a liar and summoned a third officer, who "[pressed] his face against the wall while the two others cuffed him" while saying they "didn't owe an explanation" for the harsh treatment. They then called Smith's father, who vouched for his identity, but the man was only uncuffed and released when his father brought a copy of his birth certificate to the station. There, officers finally explained their reasoning, which was that his son "looked like a minority Democrat voter."
You do realize this is her side of the story and only her side. Of course, it’s possible everything she said was true. Or, more likely, there’s more to the story.
Imagine if she was a memember of some group like Islam or LGBT or black or an illegal?
Thank GOD I live in the country, and my 14 yr old daughter is a crack shot(thank you 4-H).
Another article here: http://gothamist.com/2012/08/04/teen_claims_she_was_handcuffed_by_a.php
Video here of her describing her encounter with the police thugs (she even looks like a student): http://landing.newsinc.com/shared/video.html?freewheel=69016&sitesection=nydailynews&VID=23760703
“...brought a copy of her birth certificate to the station.”
Hmmm - now how to we lure Barry to take the subway?
She must have been drinking a Big Gulp to receive that harsh of treatment. Lucky she wasn’t also eating popcorn.
When they say swiped, they don’t mean reported stolen either.
Keep in mind that this is the same gummit that says if you look to be less than 40 years old, you got to show ID to buy booze or tobacco.
If they are so worried about misuse of these cards by non students, how about putting a picture of the user upon them. The technology to do this costs mere pennies today. And in the meantime if she told them who she was, why can’t they call up her state ID/driver’s license picture or sumfin based on how she identified herself, and look at it.
Remember the poor guy who was pulling his wallet out of his pocket at their command and they shot him 41 times (See: Amadou Bailo Diallo)
Nah, this seems highly likely as told. She looked older. It’s more common than you think. This is why they say at many places that sell alcohol or smokes, you got to show ID if you don’t look to be older than 40. And she might not have had other ID with her, not being intent on anything that needed it, and maybe she even smarted off to the cop a bit about her alleged American rights... but there’s very likely no cause to have pushed her face into a wall.
That is SO friggin rich.