More Interesting Question: Did Muhammad Exist?: An Inquiry into Islam's Obscure Origins
Also be sure to check out the customer reviews.
Posted on 09/02/2012 6:57:06 PM PDT by dynachrome
Channel 4 has become embroiled in controversy after viewers claimed that a programme distorted the history of Islam.
The broadcaster and regulator Ofcom and received nearly 550 complaints after Islam: The Untold Story was screened last week.
The show’s presenter, Tom Holland, was subjected to a wave of criticism for his investigation into the origins of the religion and its early texts.
He said there was little written contemporary evidence about the life of the Prophet Muhammad, and claimed that the Koran makes little or no reference to Islam’s holy city of Mecca.
Holland, an award-winning writer and historian, received abusive tweets questioning his views on the religion.
(Excerpt) Read more at dailymail.co.uk ...
I hope this guy is current on his life insurance payments.
“received nearly 550 complaints”
Amateur.
It WAS made up in the 600’s. MoHo took some from Judaism and some from Christianity and came up with islam. Even muslims recognized part of his writings as crazy and deemed those “The Satanic Verses”. Hitlers rise to power was also the perfect storm.
Sounds very accurate.
If 15,000 complained about a hit on Christians, it wouldn’t be noticed.
Robert Spencer has explored this theme in great detail in his book “Did Muhammed Exist?” (His answer: probably not).
That’s nuffin.
Somehow FR remains well enough guarded. Mad Mo and his following have gotten flouted from pole to pole here. Yet Fresno hasn’t been suicide bombed. Yet.
Christian missionaries to Muslims generally don’t dispute that Mo existed. They view him as a genuine, if crazy person. It seems to make more sense than trying to explain the Koran as some sort of composite book.
I guess Briton can expect a series of unexpected Bombings in the near future.
If they put this on PBS I may actually watch the hated network again.
The Koran was written by a rabbi or Jewish scribe.
TV historian triggers storm after calling Islam a ‘made-up’ religion (UK)
Sing it now:
Give me that made-up religion
give me that made-up religion
Give me that made-up religion
It’s good enough for me
Makes me hate everybody
Makes me hate everybody
Makes me hate everybody
It’s good enough for me
Give me that made-up religion
give me that made-up religion
Give me that made-up religion
It’s good enough for me
It`s good for Hamas children suicide bombers
it`s good for Hamas children suicide bombers
It`s good for Hamas children suicide bombers
And it’s good enough for me
Give me that made-up religion
give me that made-up religion
Give me that made-up religion
It’s good enough for me
It was tried on 9-11
It was tried on 9-11
It was tried on 9-11
It’s good enough for me
Give me that made-up religion
give me that made-up religion
Give me that made-up religion
It’s good enough for me
It won`t do me any good when I’m dying
It won`t do me any good when I’m dying
It won`t do me any good when I’m dying
It’s good enough for me
Give me that made-up religion
give me that made-up religion
Give me that made-up religion
It’s good enough for me
It can take all us muslims to hell
It can take all us muslims to hell
It can take all us muslims to hell
It’s good enough for me
Give me that made-up religion
give me that made-up religion
Give me that made-up religion
It’s good enough for me
More Interesting Question: Did Muhammad Exist?: An Inquiry into Islam's Obscure Origins
Also be sure to check out the customer reviews.
That’s tactical. But while the Enlightenment crowd disputed the existence of Jesus, there is far more direct and circumstantial evidence of that outside the New Testament than the existence of Mohammed. Apart from that, the history of the rise of Islam may be wrong. The Arabs may have been allies of the Persians who took over the Persian Empire after their combined forces overran the Byzantine Empire. In other words, it was the last phase of the war between the Persians and the Byzantines which left the great cities of that Greek Empire in ruins.
O.M.G... LOL!!!
The Koran does look like the work of a mad man, who pops into and out of his rages without warning. A little more or less level headed if questionably coherent philosophizing, then bam, it’s kill ‘em all. Over and over. If it’s not Mo, then how it got to be known as Mo needs explanation.
The only contemporaneous bit of information about Mohammad that I am aware of is that his horse was named Barack
Holland is saying it was made up in the 700’s.
He’s right.
Holland is saying it was made up in the 700’s.
He’s right.
A spoof from the Dark Ages? If so, it backfired. It would be like writings from the Onion getting enshrined as history by the Smithsonian Institution. The Christian missionary to the Muslims that I knew, believes that some Jews fed gobbledygook to Mad Mo as a prank, but did not themselves write his book (he couldn’t have written it anyhow being illiterate — others took it as dictation from him).
Made up religion? Demon inspired religion? Definitely no real link to Judism and Christianity other than a few comments and denigration.
"Thou shall not kill," unless they're unbelievers
"Thou shall not lie," unless it's to unbelievers
"Homosexuality is an abomination," but you will be given young boys as round and fine as pearls in heaven
“A made up religion”....you mean like Mormonism?
Only the Bible says what happens thousands of years before it happens with accuracy & specificity. This is the signature of God.
The Koran / Quran does not do this.
Not a spoof as far as I know.
Not a horse, he rode an ass.
A detailed discussion of the lack of evidence for the historical existence of the real Mohammed is available in the audio book at Prophet of Doom, http://prophetofdoom.net/Prophet_of_Doom_Audio.Islam
If I remember correctly, the most relevant portions are in the chapter, “Islam’s Dark Past Source Material Appendix” of the audio book.
It is completely made-up, a rationale for robbery and looting on a grand scale.
Prior to Mad Mo the Middle East was Christian and Jewish with the Arabs confined to the deserts. Mo wielded together marauders and thieves from those deserts to destroy most of the People of the Book.
>> It is completely made-up, a rationale for robbery and looting on a grand scale.
A war plan.
Truth and islamic tradition are like oil and water.
Does anybody have a link to watch the program? I tried the Channel 4 website but it said it was unavailable for viewing in the USA.
Truth gets them all the time, now I will get violent to make you believe it is a true religion. The moon god mohammed is upset.
” have a link to watch the program”
Nope. My guess is they yanked it. Can’t offend Moe-ham-head, ya know.
He can have a rifle or a shotgun.
Britain banned assault rifles (1988) and handguns (1997), not all guns.
Thanks for the ping. It doesn’t really matter if Mohammad existed; the Koran continues to motivate Muslims to pursue world domination.
Hi:
You can find it on PirateBay. I did a quick search and here is an url.
http://thepiratebay.se/search/Islam:%20The%20Untold%20Story/0/99/200
It looks like it is popular.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.