Skip to comments.Nationís children push back against Michelle Obama-backed school lunch regs
Posted on 09/23/2012 7:12:18 PM PDT by Tolerance Sucks Rocks
Children and parents across the country are fed up with the restrictive new school meal regulations implemented by the Department of Agriculture under the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010, which has long been touted by first lady Michelle Obama.
The standards which cap meal calories at 650 for students in kindergarten through fifth grade, at 700 calories for middle school students and 850 for high school students also dictate the number of breads, proteins, vegetables and fruits children are allowed per meal.
A spokeswoman for Iowa Republican Rep. Steve King, who earlier this month introduced legislation to roll back the new standards, told The Daily Caller that Kings office has heard more complaints about the issue during the past few weeks than any other.
This year, well be hungry by 2:00, one student, Zach Eck, told KAKETV in Kansas. We would eat our pencils at school if they had nutritional value.
Iowa mom Robin Wissink told TheDC that she now provides her autistic daughter Molly, a junior in high school, with a bag lunch because her schools new menu is so unappealing. Students at St. Marks in Colwich, Kan. have also been brown bagging their meals.
And some student-athletes in Wisconsin are arguing that the calorie caps hit them especially hard, given their intense workouts and scrimmages.
A lot of us are starting to get hungry even before the practice begins, Mukwonago High senior Nick Blohm told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Our metabolisms are all sped up.
The new lunch standards have led to the removal of some old food favorites, including a particularly popular item at one school in upstate New York: chicken nuggets.
Now theyre kind of forcing all the students to get the vegetables and fruit with their lunch, and they took out chicken nuggets this year, which Im not too happy about, Chris Cimino, a senior at Mohonasen High School in upstate New York, told the Associated Press, which gave the rules a mixed grade.
Students in the Plum Borough School District in Pennsylvania are protesting the new federal restrictions on Twitter.
everyone.. if you agree school lunches are expensive and small, RT this. we can fight the school! tweet #BrownBagginIt, @TornadoBoyTubbs tweeted, according to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
Administrators have scrambled to find creative ways to make the new menus appealing. A school district in Lake County, Fla., for example, is planning to conduct a survey to determine how to make vegetables more appealing to children, who often throw them out.
[The regulations do] limit the food that you can put on the plate, Alden Caldwell, the director of food services at a Brookline, Mass. school, told Wicked Local. In theory, its a good idea, but in practice were finding that there are issues with it.
Despite the outrage, some parents believe the ongoing obesity epidemic justifies the tight calorie standards.
I think its smart to be pre-emptive and proactive at getting more nutrition fed into the kids, Amos Johnson, a parent with students in the Lee Summit, Missouri school system, told the Lees Summit Journal. I see that more as a multi-beneficial supporter for health and academic performance. I think thats the thing I would look at. You should be healthier, and if youre nourishing the brain and getting the fuel right, academic outcomes should maintain or improve.
When the legislation was signed into law in 2010, it received bipartisan support, including a big endorsement from Michelle Obama.
As parents, we try to prepare decent meals, limit how much junk food our kids eat, and ensure they have a reasonably balanced diet, the first lady said in a statement at the unveiling of the new standards in January. And when were putting in all that effort the last thing we want is for our hard work to be undone each day in the school cafeteria. When we send our kids to school, we expect that they wont be eating the kind of fatty, salty, sugary foods that we try to keep them from eating at home. We want the food they get at school to be the same kind of food we would serve at our own kitchen tables.
Obama welcomed students back to school this year with a YouTube video explaining the importance of the new meal plans.
King and Kansas Republican Rep. Tim Huelskamp introduced the No Hungry Kids Act, which would repeal the USDA rule that resulted in the new standards, last week.
The goal of the school lunch program is supposed to be feeding children, not filling the trash cans with uneaten food, Huelskamp said in a statement. The USDAs new school lunch guidelines are a perfect example of what is wrong with government: misguided inputs, tremendous waste, and unaccomplished goals. Thanks to the Nutrition Nannies at the USDA, Americas children are going hungry at school.
Do any of these nanny statists remember how much stuff they ate when they were teenagers?
Nanny State PING!
A local radio host volunteered at the cafeteria of his daughter’s school. Chris talked about working the salad bar. Repeatedly kids would walk up and ask for just the grated cheese.
My daughter feeds her children what they will eat. She encourages them to eat certain items but she is not a food nazi.
Look people. The government doesn’t care if 100% of us hate it, it’ll be a “mixed grade” and nothing will happen to change it back.
Sorry, but I’ve seen the eating Moo does “on the road” WITH her kids, Goose and Gander stuff. Don’t tell US what to eat when you’re eating out all the time.
If my children were in elementary school, they would not be having their lunch bags examined, nor having their food or drink I packed tossed.
The lunches provided by schools are probably the worst nutrition-wise a child could eat. It’s all processed crap.
Having a kid that plays high school football, I know the school lunches don’t begin to cover the calories burned working out daily.
I was underweight as a child because of severe asthma.
Does this idiot Michelle realize there are other kids that may have different dietary needs?
I hypothesize that there is, in fact, a rebound effect in which children who are deprived of the food they want to eat at school and are forced to eat nothing but “healthy” food then go home and overeat to make up for the feelings of deprivation they experienced at school.
It looks like a fairly easy hypothesis to test.
That's not going to work for the 6'7" 270 lb defensive end. He will take what he needs.
My kids are among the brown-bag rebel brigade. I have been packing more lunches this year than I can ever remember.
It’s going to be a hoot to see how New Yawkers respond to Little Mikey Bloomer’s and his Big Gulp Nazis’ ban on soft drinks.
Recently we were invited to school to have lunch with our grandson. When we met up with him and ask what was for lunch, he told us all he would get was the milk because the rest of the food was “garbage”..(his words)..We decided to give the food a try....he was correct - it was garbage. We threw ours away, he drank his milk and I’m sure he is starving by the time he gets home.
This is a starvation diet..plain and simple.
They interviewed a high school athlete who purchases school lunch the other day.
His meal is capped at 850 calories, but his chemistry teacher calculated that he burns about 3000 calories in school between class, weight-lifting, and football practice ...
He states that his energy level has gone way down since these new regulations have been put in place ...
Nice goin’, Michelle ...
--food vendors are 'wasting' MILLIONS because of this dictated menu reformulationinfo provided by three districts consisting of 3 HS, 7 Middle schools, 16 elementary schools.
--students are THROWING away these new offerings
--nutrition is adversely affected
--schools ARE losing money (many self supported) as school lunches are WAY DOWN
--the purported 'free' breakfest/lunch programs are a sham as nutrition is not adequately provided
My six year old granddaughter,all 38 pounds of her,is starving when she gets home from school.
This is how it works when we all become a “collective”
The kindergartener and the high school senior are given the same treatment - same portions -same calories.
You have a problem with that?
I guess you don’t want that nice federal aid do ya?
I support the wookie in this whole thing.
Make those school lunches so lousy that the parents (many of whom we give food stamps, WIC, and a litany of other stipends for food) start getting their a&&es out of bed to make breakfast and pack a lunch for their kids.
I don’t know about other places but my kids can take to school whatever I give them, my son loves MREs and the pouches I vacuum seal of dehydrated bananas, peaches and pears I make in my food dehydrator, plus is the 30 gram protein bars.
I read an article the other day that talked about schools serving hummus and black bean salad. What? I wouldn’t eat that crap and personally don’t know one kid that would touch it.
The athletic young men I coach can easily put away several “quad” cheeseburgers at one sitting - plus fires.
Not one of them is obese.
I had one fellow who could not make it through practice without eating a burrito during water break. He is now a starting linebacker for a Division 1 college football team.
These new meal rules seem to be designed to starve athletes into submission.
Well tht turned out nicely ‘)
My daughter’s 17, and weighs 100# after a good eating weekend. Her pant size is 00.
Thankfully, she has never gotten all weird about diet and exercise. She eats when she wants, and quits when she’s full. Years of gymnastics and dancing have given her joy, but she doesn’t go out of her way to shape her body.
My concern is that in forcing young kids to focus on calories, portion size and exercise to stay slim, a lot of girls are going to go on extreme diets. Those who are prone to anorexia don’t need any encouragement.
This ‘brown bag it’ resistance is really taking off in the red counties in Minnesota.
I told my son he’s on the leading edge. In eleven years, I’ve made him about 2,000 lunches. I know what goes into it, he likes it and doesn’t mind, as a sophomore, that he brings his lunch. Nobody razzes him about it and they’re jealous of his homemade chocolate chip brownies.
We could hardly wait to get home when we were kids because we could eat a horse. Back then we usually took a lunch or at least I did b/c I didn’t like the cafeteria food.
You can’t do what we did on 2000 calories a day. Nobody could.
When we did football and weights we ate just about anything and everything that was in the house. I was 6’ 2” and weighted 180# back then. Nobody but Mom got in our way when we wanted something to eat. And she seldom refused us.
2nd grade mobs, that’s funny.
I have a grandson in the 2nd grade, he buys two lunches, because he said they are so small, he is starving by the time school gets out.
My 4th grade granddaughter, wont eat the lunches, she says they are are horrible. The kids buy snacks so she just get stuff like apples and yogurt.
Oh, at their school they are not allowed to bring lunches from home (eye roll) because heaven forbid someone might bring something that someone is allergic to.
As reported in Wa Po, this is what Michelle likes to pound down her throat when she goes out with her gal pals to the Shake Shack ...
Oh - I forgot, she DOES order a diet soda with this ...
Oh my gosh!
The original picture with the prairie dog was taken with my neighbors across the street in 2009. They were on a camping trip.
So weird to see it again in that fashion. LOL! The wife is quite liberal, the guy very laid back.
I don’t think I’ll mention this one to them, though I had a good chuckle.
It passed in the Senate by unanimous consent, so every Republican Senator can be blamed. The House vote was:
FINAL VOTE RESULTS FOR ROLL CALL 603
The 17 House Republicans were: Bachus, Cao, Capito, Castle, Dent, Djou, Ehlers, Emerson, Fortenberry, Gerlach, Jones, Latham, LaTourette, Tim Murphy, Platts, Reichert and Young (AK)
Just getting them ready for when the Food Stamp President crashes the economy!
which cap meal calories at 650 for students in kindergarten through fifth grade, at 700 calories for middle school students and 850 for high school students
what a bunch of morons!
When I was a teenager I ate 2000 calories per meal and ate 4 meals per day. AND I WAS SKINNY! You can’t force a teen to eat ONLY 2500 calories per day! What kind of an idiot dreamed this up??
“The athletic young men I coach can easily put away several quad cheeseburgers at one sitting - plus fires.”
“plus fires”? Dont know what you coach, but I’m AFRAID of them.
The same kind of idiots that just took over our entire health care system
And so the party that once accused republicans of “wanting” to starve children by messing with the school lunches is actually implementing a child-starvation plan by messing with the school lunches. They’re even doing this just 2 months before a presidential election.
And, again the commie MSM is letting them get away with it.
Even if she were thin as a rail....she is not an elected official.
Republican First Ladies always find a good cause to represent - but you don’t see them trying to seize power that normally belongs to elected representatives.
Hillary tried to seize the health care industry - and here we see Michelle acting like an empress....usurping the authority of parents, school boards, and school staffs.
If the people don’t want to play by her rules, their school suffers a crippling reduction in aid.
She doesn’t have the authority to do this! My head is exploding.
I swear I thought this was an onion article. I think my daughter will be taking her lunch from now on. I’m not going to subject her to this communist crap. If it’s a further issue, I’ll pull her out of school and home school her.
A recent study showed that overweight teens actually eat LESS than their normal weight peers. There is more to weight than just calories. Activity levels and genetics are very important contributors to weight. These so-called experts are depriving kids of what they need, and ironically, setting them up for later weight gain by putting them on restricted feeding.
What I really don’t understand is why parents put up with all this nonsense. Why do people still send their kids to government schools?
and people have forgotten about the whole BMI garbage going on too.
They are collecting data on the BMI’s of the kids and the school nurses are supposed to be gathering the info.
Evil is, as evil does. And this is evil.
It looks like they are trying to convert the children to vegetarianism. Hitler would be happy if he were around today since he practiced it.
My friends sister is a lunch lady at the local high school, and she was ready to tar and feather Moochelle.
The first thing they did was take out the salad bar.
The second thing they did was take out the potato bar.
They are no longer allowed to use salt and pepper.... only approved by the government spices..... which hadnt arrived by the start of school. So they were serving naked ugly veggies.
The kids can get a prepackaged salad if they want..... with 1 (count them.... 1) extra veggie. So, they can have lettuce and carrots, or lettuce and cucumber, or lettuce with tomato.... not lettuce with all three. And the cooks are absolutely forbidden to add cheese to the salad. The kids beg them, and they cannot. So the kids are taking their prepackaged salads and dumping them in the trash at the end of the service line. They arent even pretending they will eat them.
Tell me how this is an improvement.
If true, it figures...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.