Skip to comments.*NEW ROMNEY AD* "Actually Happened” (Being played in CO,NV,NH,IA,NC,VA, AND OIHO)
Posted on 10/02/2012 5:29:38 AM PDT by Perdogg
For those of us behind strict work firewalls, would you summarize? Thanks.
Great ad.....just presented the facts
FYI: This is an anti Obama ad from American Crossroads, not from the official Romney campaign.
So? does it not count?
It is a short ad saying that unemployment is more that what 0bama promise and pointed out the National debt has risen to $16 Trillion.
Blah blah blah.....Same ol' same ol'
First chart -- what Obama promised (unemployment rate 5.6%) and what he delivered (unemployment rate 8.1%) and what this means (-3.7 million jobs).
Second chart -- rising budget deficits. We are $5 Trillion further in debt.
We are further in debt and have fewer jobs than when Obama started.
I’d like to see an ad hit on the fact that so many have given up on finding a job, and that they aren’t being counted as unemployed any more, artificially lowering the “official” number.
Your ad is using facts and statistics.
There is no emotion, no feelings.
Your argument is invalid.
They got the wrong guy to do this ad. He’s way too nice. Should have someone breathing fire. This ad is pathetic.
I didn’t say anything about it counting or not, but your headline gives the impression the ad is from the Romney campaign, which it is not.
Why do they have it as a private link? It says at the top the video is unlisted and only those with a direct link can see it. Seems kind of strange for a political ad.
I gave you a direct link.
You know, I hate to say this, but it is seldom I see an AC ad that is worth a damn. Most of them have no emotional punch whatsoever. Just “blah, blah, blah” That particular meme has been done to death. Money down a rat-hole. Sorry, but that’s my honest opinion.
Interviews with actual out of work people would be way more effective. Maybe have one say “we can’t take four more years of this”.
Maybe Kidd Rock should have done the ad; Come out with guitars, fire, and monster trucks and then Kidd Rock looks in the camera and gives the facts.
You people who have never run a campaigns in your life can always do better, can’t you?
I’ve never made a motion picture, but I know if a movie is good or bad.
I’m aware of that. What I’m asking is why didn’t they make it public so it could be ‘searchable’, and show up randomly on the side bar for anyone caring to watch/search for political ads. Not that many people do THAT on youtube!
I’ve never made a motion picture, but I know if a movie is good or bad.
Any kind of advertizing works by emotion. This one is dull, and 99% of people will just tune it out.
U-tube refusing comments on this. Is everyone noticing how many web sites are refusing comments?
“They got the wrong guy to do this ad. Hes way too nice. Should have someone breathing fire. This ad is pathetic.”
R. Lee Ermey comes to mind.
What America needs to see is the “truth,” we only need a 30 second spot. The first 10 second is bozo telling the soviet leaders not to worry, he'll have flexibility after the election. The second is bozo telling us we didn't build it. The last 10 seconds is Romney making a plea to help start fixing this country. This doesn't have to be rocket science.
We won’t win with crappy ads like this. The people that are plugged in and paying attention on both sides have already decided who they will vote for so ads like this mean nothing.
If they want to pull wishy washy (I) and (D) people over to our side, they need to create more emotional ads that give weaker minded people something to grab onto. Take the Obama phone lady and put it into a 30 second commercial!
I would have cut off the chart on the debt and added to the chart the unemployment rate had the BLS used the same-sized job pool that we had at the end of the Bush administration (approx. 11 or 12%).
Then there’s only one message: Obama failed on unemployment.
This ad says “yes, he lied but it’s getting gradually better”. My revision says “yes he lied and it’s worse than the lie.”
54321 here come the bedwetters lol
I disagree. They need to show the cost of Obama's policies in human terms. If Obama was a Republican, the media would be running stories every day about poor out of work Americans, people who have been forclosed on, filed bankruptcies, homeless, etc. Notice you never see those stories anymore? Romney and the pacs need to bring those people into voters living rooms, with the overt message, "we can't take four more years of this", and the unspoken message "you could be next". As John in Wisconsin noted above, fear sells.
We need to hear about the future...not the past. It’s almost annoying to hear what Obama did in the past since they have convinced people that it was Bush’s fault and he needs 4 more years. I’ve been waiting for Romney to talk about what an Obama Presidency will mean for the next 4 years!!!! NO ONE GIVES A CRAP ABOUT THE PAST ANYMORE. He’s going to lose if he doesn’t get with the program.
An exponentially better ad, creative, clever, and on-point, also by American Crossroads: CLICK HERE.
Will we ever see this one on TV, or just on the internet?
“Obama promised x amount of jobs delivered Y”
Blah blah blah.....Same ol’ same ol’
To quote a former Messiah “Words? Just Words?”
Romney knows this.
When Romney ran against Kennedy for the Senate, Kennedy bussed in people (from OH, iirc) that lost their jobs, or had their wages and salaries cut in the Bain-engineered merger of two failing companies, Avery and Dennison.
How about an ad showing what happens when the Bush Tax Cuts expire? Millions added to the tax rolls (Those that don’t pay taxes now), a 50% increase in the rate paid by the lowest level of taxpayers (from 10% to 15%), and an average $3500 increase for families.
“Interviews with actual out of work people would be way more effective. Maybe have one say we cant take four more years of this.”
Agree 100%. The Zero ad/lie about the man who blamed Romney for his wife’s death had traction because it tugged at people’s heart strings. SURELY there are some non-union GM people who lost EVERYTHING who could be featured in a TRUE commercial.
It would work on Mrs. JimRed. A fire-breathing, passionate delivery (Rush when he's in that mode, or Mark Levin anytime) causes her to shut down because she "hates being screamed at". In fairness, she did stop watching Chrissy the Sissy and the Olber-moron long ago for the same reason. She just can't separate passion from hate...
Technically, this is Karl Rove’s anti-Obama ad. Not Romney’s.
If it’s playing here in VA, I haven’t seen it yet (I’m in the central part of the state).
for the debate
he needs to say
“how did your first plan work out??”
The other good ad I saw was the "Obama does not deserve a second term" and talks about the bad economy.
Add the issue of higher gas prices and this ad would hit the trifecta.
100% no BS: I was at the gym the other night when this ad came on. At my gym each elliptical trainer has its own TV. Most of the time people are watching the normal stations, so it is not uncommon for one of the bigger TVs to be playing the same thing as the little TVs on the elliptical trainer
When this ad came on, the young woman, early-20s, immediately became glued to this ad on the TV on the elliptical trainer. Two other women who did not have TVs on tredmills became glued to the bigger TV that was playing this ad. I am not sure how they will vote, but it is not going to be due to a lack of attention to this ad.
Apparently, this ad was good enough to hold their attention. In fact, if it can keep the young woman’s attention off me at the gym, it must be a good ad.
Decision YOU the viewer must make
“I’m Mitty Romney and I approve this message”
That’s encouraging. I think people have gotten to the point where they WANT to be convinced.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.