Posted on 10/06/2012 6:51:03 AM PDT by Kaslin
I'm saying cut the legs under them so we can ban all abortions --- first start by saying ok, concessions for the murders they talk about. THEN, we instantly save 656,000 babies in that year itself
If we don't fight the battle in parts we lose all the babies permanently.
Truly privatize the behavior ~ de-interpose the state in any aspect of it.
But, I don't see how " de-interpose the state in any aspect of it." -- or I may not be understanding you correctly. We want the state to criminalize babykilling, right?
Now, if you reverse the situation and pull out the state, and just leave the practitioners and customers on their own, you get a different outcome.
That's pretty much Conservative philosophy on the place of government ~ that if you put the government in you get an outcome, and if you take the government out you get another outcome.
The 10th amendment pretty well covers that ~ the government need not be involved in all aspects of society, social organization or behavior.
It seems to me the government need not be involved in picking the winners and the losers in the abortion business ~ that can be left entirely up to private individuals and it will take care of itself.
There's an existing counterpart to this in the liquor store business. The courts treat a liquor store robbery as not being all that different from stealing quarters from a newspaper vending machine ~ as a sort of nuisance. Folks who run liquor stores are expected to deal with their own 'in-store' problems ~ and they do so with an armed guard, frequently on a small mezzanine overlooking the main working area ~ or by arming all the employees.
They do not get FBI protection!
Even if your store is burned out ~ as a friend of mine's was ~ you don't get FBI help, even in DC ~ and he was in DC. Unless someone comes along and confesses burning it down you'll get little sympathy in the courts, even if you are a lawyer, which he was.
The insurance companies won't bother paying off until you get that confession and get the perpetrator tried and convicted.
That's a practical application of the 10th amendment.
Tossing the abortion industry into the same environment of freedom enjoyed by the liquor industry might bring about some interesting developments ~ like (1) Being priced out of the market, (2) Finding few new entrants to take over existing practices, (3) .........
I'm sure you can think of more developments.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.