Skip to comments.A General Lesson: Why did he risk everything on an affair?
Posted on 11/10/2012 4:03:39 PM PST by billorites
Among those who have long known Gen. David Petraeus, those who served under his command in wartime, sat with him in the White House Situation Room, or helped him rewrite Army doctrine at Fort Leavenworth, the most gnawing question about the scandalous affair that led to his resignation and doomed his career on Friday is this: How could hethis acclaimed leader and figure of rectitudeallow such a thing to happen?
Seen in context, the mystery, while shocking, is not so unfathomable.
Paula Broadwell, the woman with whom he had this affair, writes in her fawning biography of Petraeus that they first met when she was in graduate school at Harvard and he came to give a talk about counterinsurgency strategy. She approached him afterward and expressed interest in the subject; they exchanged cards. Soon, she decided to write a Ph.D. dissertation on his leadership style and, when he took command in Afghanistan, asked if she could come observe him in action. He agreed.
The key to this initial attraction was probably not sexual but rather biographical. Broadwell had once been a West Point cadet, like Petraeus. Upon graduating, shed joined the light infantry officers corps as a paratrooper, as had Petraeus in his youth. She was obsessed with physical fitness, especially running, as was Petraeus. In short, regardless of gender, Broadwell was exactly the sort of aspiring officer-intellectual that Petraeus was keen to mentor.
The impulse was not unique to Petraeus. It grew out of the ethos of West Points social science department, where Petraeus had taught in the mid-1980s. The department, known as Sosh, was founded just after World War II by a visionary ex-cadet and Rhodes Scholar named George A. Abe Lincoln. Toward the end of the war, as the senior planning aide to Army Chief of Staff
(Excerpt) Read more at slate.com ...
We sin because we are sinners.
The little head won.
He worked for a Democrat administration. It was simply expected of him to prove he could fit in.
Ah, come on! The Russians have used women to get at our military men for many, many decades for one reason: because it works.
So General Petraeus is only human. This just underlines the fact that working in the Obama Administration is dangerous.
I think he “risked everything” because he was pretty depressed at that point under the Obama command and probably felt he just had to do what he had to do, but she made him feel positive about it.
It seems like there might have been another woman, too, because apparently the FBI was surveilling him because some other woman (not his wife) had complained that Petraeus’ sweetie was harrassing her.
This sounds to me like somebody on a suicide course. Or else he’s just a total idiot having a midlife crisis.
I think people sense that they are about at the end of their career. I think sometimes people sense age coming on and get caught up in the fantasy of the woman who seduces him.
Might have never happened if she wasn’t offered up on a plate.
I feel bad for his wife.
We are also blessed with will power and can resist these situations.He could have been a good man and husband and walked away from her.
Well look at his wife
Women are commonly used to compromise men of high security a tactic perfected by the communist.
SO WHY IS ANYBODY SUPRISED WITH THIS COMMUNIST REGIME FROM ALL LEVELS WITHIN THIS GOVERNMENT!
There is no sarcasm in what I just said
She was cute when young.
It's the forth one that got him in trouble
Wow, you shallow can you be?
A stiff penis has no conscience.
I think you’re too conspiratorial here as far as him being intentionally set up. Petraeus wouldn’t be the first smart person to do dumb things.
Obviously, however, this informationw as known to the FBI for a while. On one hand, its logical that it was sat on until after the election was over. On the other hand, I wonder if it was released to torpedo Petraeus as a possible contender for 2016.
His wife was very cute indeed.
I just think that she's one of those women who enjoy the notches.
Her husband is letting her go to Afghanistan FOR A LONG STRETCH why??
It just might be that Broad and hubby have an open marriage....just like Bill and Hillary.
Why should his wife’s looks matter? Some of us out here still think for better or worse, sickness and health matters. Just sayin’
We sin because we choose to.
People are going to want to label her with vile comments, but she is an extraordinary creature who has learned that she has to apply her tremendous energy to various outlets.
Around powerful men, for them, she is intoxicating.
A lot of such women destroy themselves by their sexual activity leading into drugs.
She has, what plagued Marilyn Monroe.
Pray for her.
ummm he is no prize himself.
I hope u are not married!!!!
She's 39. Her kids are 4 & 6.
Why does ANY man risk it all for an affair?
Any answers, male freepers?
Maybe his marriage wasn’t so hot. Spending 2 years away from your wife in Afghanistan probably didn’t inspire much closeness between him and his wife.
Mebbe she was worth it, huh?!
I feel bad for the troops he commanded over there. They served faithfully, liable to get their asses blown off any second, and some actually did. THEY were horny as a billy goat, but toughed it out. After all, the Middle East is not THE place to make out with women.
And now they find out that while they were enduring all that, HE was getting hummers under the desk! I would think it makes a lot of other officers over there automatically suspect, in the dogfaces’ eyes. JMO
U men 41’ wasn’t tempted?
Yes she was. Google Holly Knowlton. Plus, David Petraeus looks like a toad with a horrible comb-over. Yuck!
Some people honor their vows while others use them as a matter of convenience. I've been married to my wife for 45 years, the last 31 of which she has suffered a progressive debilitating disease. A man's word and promises should mean something.
But really, it’s one thing to do it - the truly stupid part is keeping the emails. I mean, why?
I wonder if the wives of the soldiers who came back, burned and missing limbs think the same thing about their husbands?
A man’s word and promises should mean something.
Truer words were never spoken.
If he was unhappy with his wife he should have divorced her. His wife is the reason his career was so amazing...I imagine he married her for her contacts in the military and what she could do for his career. His career flourished and by all accounts his wife was a great Army wife, adding another necessary positive to his career. This is how he repays his wife?
Never place your faith in men (women included), they will disappoint you every time.
From men, trust only what you can corroborate.
LOL! Yeah, the little head does most of the thinking for sure! Also, the guy has a PHD, proving tat there is not a direct correlation between intelligence and wisdom.
Bin their, dun that, so eye can c wear u r coming from.
Broadwell wanted the notch. That’s all it’s about. Bet she stalked “The Best” at West Point and Harvard, too.
That is so refreshing to read. (Especially amidst all the shallow comments being made today.)
The immediate denial of knowlege from this regime of the FBIs investigation duly noted also your comment of my conspiracy theorys. Always. Always discredit eveything right?
Oh by the way 0bamas dna sure looks like frank marshal davis , his daddy has the same age spots on his face.
“only human” bothers me a great deal. It is as if we are so lowly that the primacy G-d bestowed upon man has been rendered meaningless and ‘human’ has become an excuse for all wrongdoing in the world when it SHOULD BE the exact opposite. Human as an excuse is actually SUBhuman because HUMAN aspires to be MORE, not less; BETTER, not worse. In G-d’s Image. It means something.
The whole thing is bogus, and quite frankly I think there is some really hard ball being played by the islamofascist commie to save himself from GITMO. I put nothing past him, or this woman in an exchange of the big $bucks.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.