Skip to comments.The Amnesty Fantasy
Posted on 11/18/2012 5:41:49 AM PST by Altura Ct.
The networks had barely called the election for President Barack Obama before GOP elites rushed to embrace an amnesty for illegal immigrants.
Getting killed almost three-to-one among Latino voters understandably concentrates the mind, but its no reason to lose it. The post-election Republican reaction has been built on equal parts panic, wishful thinking, and ethnic pandering.
Its one thing to argue that amnesty is the right policy on the merits. Its another to depict it as the magic key to unlocking the Latino vote. John McCain nearly immolated himself within the Republican party with his support for amnesty and did all of four points better among Latino voters in 2008 than Mitt Romney did in 2012, according to exit polls.
What is the common thread uniting McCain, the advocate of comprehensive immigration reform, and Romney, the advocate of self-deportation? They are both Republicans supporting conservative economic policies. Surely that had more to do with their showing among Latinos than anything they did or didnt say about immigration.
According to Census Bureau data, among native-born Hispanics, 50 percent of all households with children are headed by unmarried mothers. About 40 percent of all households receive benefits from a major welfare program. This doesnt mean that the GOP shouldnt try to appeal to persons in these households. It does mean that they arent natural Republican voters.
Latinos tend to have liberal attitudes toward government. Take health care. An ImpreMedia/Latino Decisions poll of Latinos conducted on the eve of the election found that 61 percent of Latinos supported leaving Obamacare in place. Sixty-six percent believed government should ensure access to health insurance. This might have something to do with the fact that 32 percent of non-elderly Latinos lack health insurance, about twice the national average.
In California, as Heather Mac Donald of the Manhattan Institute noted in the aftermath of the election, Hispanics will prove to be even more decisive in the victory of Governor Jerry Browns Proposition 30, which raised upper-income taxes and the sales tax, than in the Obama election.
These are facts that never intrude upon Wall Street Journal editorials scolding Republicans for supposedly turning their backs on budding new recruits. In the Journals telling, if it werent for Republican intransigence on immigration, Latino voters would be eagerly joining the fight for lower marginal tax rates and the block-granting of Medicaid.
A recent editorial invoked the welcoming attitude of Ronald Reagan. How much of the Latino vote did Reagan get? In his landslide of 1980, 35 percent. In his landslide of 1984, 37 percent. Thats better than Romney, but still a wipeout. Reagan signed the amnesty of 1986. What did it do for the partys standing among Latinos? George H.W. Bush got only 30 percent of the Latino vote in his own landslide of 1988.
Republican donors with a disproportionate influence in the party would be perfectly happy to jettison the cause of immigration enforcement. They are fine with a flood of low-skilled immigrants competing with low-skilled American workers. And why shouldnt they be? These immigrants dont suppress their wages; they care for their children and clean their pools.
Whenever it is pointed out that illegal immigration tends to harm low-skill workers already here, the comeback is the scurrilous canard that there are some jobs that no Americans will do. But most hotel maids, construction workers, coal miners, and workers in meatpacking all tough, thankless jobs are U.S.-born. If it is hard to entice legal workers into such positions, here is a radical concept: Pay them more.
None of this is to deny that the GOP has a tonal problem on immigration, or that Latino voters care deeply about the issue. Absent a greater economic appeal to all working-class voters, though, its hard to see how a rapid, obviously opportunistic turnabout on immigration will help the party much. Amnesty isnt a quick fix for the GOPs problems. Would that it were.
All good points....
The easiest way to debunk the “Illegal Alien Amnesty brings in Hispanic Voters” Myth is:
1. John McCain won 31% of the Hispanic Vote in 2008, after a year earlier authoring the largest Illegal Alien Amnesty bill ever passed. Compared to Romney’s 2012 Hispanic vote pct (27%)...amnesty is not a winner with Hispanics. No evidence whatsoever
2. Arizona, a state with a large pct of Hispanics, has overwhelmingly passed bills to deal with Illegal Aliens. And, GOP candidates still do well in elections there...GOP candidates are at risk to only Amnesty-Liberal GOP candidates who get Liberal and Liberal RINO GOPe backing
Electing Big Government Amnesty Liberals are not going to win elections on a wide or nationwide level
On #1...that should read “ever voted on”...not “ever passed”. Good Gravy...almost made the Amnesty Liberals jump for joy
The Latino demographic bomb will eventually kill the republican party. We have already passed the tipping point. Sustained democrat conntrol will eventually kill the country.
Amnesty would bring this about sooner rather than later.
Politicians talking about it is one thing, the moment a bill is placed on the docket is another.
When is the treatment of American citizens in Mexico and their rights vs US treatment of Mexicans going to be an issue when we discuss amnesty ?
Ever hear of reciprocal aggrements ? These are arranged to protect the rights of American citizens working or living in other countries.
Why is it when it comes to citizens of other countries we are required to offer them the same privledges as we do to US citizens? But when it comes to US citizens who get in trouble or attempt to do business in other countries they do not get the same treatment their citizens get.
Americans cant own coast land in Mexico. And get no title to it elsewhere. If they run out of cash theyll get unceremoniously sent back or put in jail untill some relative comes up with the fresh. Thats just for starters as for granting them voting privledges yea lets give Mexican citizens that right when American citizens vote in their elections .