Skip to comments.Disabled daughter dies just hours after state takes her from mom
Posted on 12/06/2012 3:51:33 PM PST by NYer
Marie Freyre was born with cerebral palsy and fluid surrounding her brain. She suffered from life-threatening seizures.
Even after Marie Freyre died alone in a nursing home 250 miles from the family in North Tampa that loved her, Marie's mother had to fight to bring her home.
In March 2011, state child protection investigators took 14-year-old Marie from her mother, Doris Freyre, claiming Doris' own disabilities made it almost impossible for her to care for Marie, who suffered from seizures and severe cerebral palsy. But a Tampa judge signed an order that Marie be returned to her mother, with in-home nursing care around the clock.
Florida health care administrators refused to pay for it, although in-home care can be demonstrably cheaper than care in an institution. Child welfare workers ignored the order completely.
Two months later, Marie was strapped into an ambulance for a five-hour trip to a Miami Gardens nursing home, as her mother begged futilely to go with her.
Marie died 12 hours after she arrived.
"Since the state of Florida took custody of my daughter, I would like the state of Florida to bring me back my daughter," Freyre, 59, said at a May 9 court hearing, 12 days after her daughter died.
"They kidnapped my daughter. She was murdered," said Freyre. "And I want my daughter back."
The last days of Marie Freyre, chronicled in hundreds of pages of records reviewed by the Miami Herald, are a story of death by bureaucratic callousness and medical neglect. The episode sheds significant light on an ongoing dispute between Florida health care regulators and the U.S. Department of Justice. Though the state claims that the parents of severely disabled and medically fragile children have "choice" over where their children live and receive care, federal civil rights lawyers say Florida, by dint of a rigged funding system, has "systematically" force-fed sick children into nursing homes meant to care for adults — in violation of federal laws that prohibit discrimination against disabled people.
Civil rights lawyers are asking the state to allow a federal judge to oversee Florida's Medicaid program, which insures needy and disabled people. It pays as much as $506 a day to put a child like Marie in a nursing home, but refuses to cover lesser or similar amounts for in-home care.
Late Friday, state health regulators wrote their final letter to the Justice Department in response to a deadline. The state, they wrote, "is not in violation of any federal law" governing the medical care delivered to needy Floridians, and cannot "agree to the demand … that a federal court take over the management of Florida's Medicaid service-delivery system."
Without doubt, Marie Freyre was a fragile, sickly child. Born with cerebral palsy and fluid surrounding her brain, Marie had a shunt in her skull to drain the fluid and suffered from life-threatening seizures. One of her hips was permanently displaced, causing sometimes excruciating pain. Marie could smile, though she could not speak.
Doris Freyre — who worked at a family store in Puerto Rico before becoming disabled herself— cared for her daughter well for 14 years, and Marie had suffered no seizures in recent years, records show.
"Doris spent every day of 14 years of her life giving everything she had to Marie, guaranteeing that Marie lived as healthy and wonderful a life as God allowed her," said the family's Tampa lawyer, Peter Brudny.
But in March 2011, one of the family's in-home nurses reported several concerns about Doris Freyre's parenting of Marie to the Department of Children and Families, setting in motion a disastrous chain of events. Hillsborough Circuit Judge Vivian Corvo began a hearing on the case on March 30, 2011, by praising Freyre for her care of her daughter.
Corvo wanted to help Freyre — not punish her. The greatest challenge was Freyre's own health: Freyre suffers from six herniated discs, as well as carpal tunnel syndrome in her wrists.
"The doctor told me to do surgery," Freyre said in court. "I told him no, because I have to take care of my daughter."
Freyre had asked the Agency for Health Care Administration to provide her with 24-hour nursing aides. As it stood, Freyre had a gap between midnight and 7 a.m. where she needed help to reposition Marie and change her diapers. "It's not easy," Freyre told the judge. "I'm human."
But AHCA administrators refused to pay for the additional hours. Corvo wanted to know why. "This is a nonverbal child, with all of these issues," the judge said. "Why would this mother not qualify for 24-hour care?"
From the beginning, state child protection administrators wanted to send Marie to a nursing home. Freyre's attorney suggested such a move could kill her.
"With this type of child, when you institutionalize them," attorney Steve Zucker said, "they never do well. And I'm very concerned."
"Can the (state) do better than this?" he asked the judge.
At the end of the hearing, Corvo required child welfare administrators to do better. She wrote an order that Marie be returned to her mother, with additional nursing care through the night.
It was an order the state simply ignored.
Records show state child welfare workers disregarded Corvo's order that Hillsborough Kids, which was under contract with the DCF, pay for the extra nursing hours while caseworkers looked into additional dollars from Medicaid.
Two weeks later, the state Attorney General's Office and Hillsborough Kids appeared before a different judge, Emily Peacock. AHCA, which runs Medicaid, had refused again to pay for 24-hour care, a lawyer said. With no permanent solution in sight, the state said, a nursing home was the only option.
"The best placement for the child right now is a … nursing home where she can get that 24-hour supervision and care that she needs," said Angeline Attila, an assistant attorney general.
The new judge, who never asked why the state ignored a prior judge's order, agreed — though she granted Freyre the right to visit with her daughter all she wanted. But even that kindness proved meaningless.
A DCF review of Marie's death said the only nursing home willing to take her was Florida Club Care Center in Miami Gardens.
At first, the state Attorney General's Office, which was representing Hillsborough Kids, asked that the long trip be delayed so lawyers could seek permission from a judge to move Marie.
But they were under significant pressure to get Marie out of Tampa General Hospital, where she was placed after child protection workers took her into state care. Records show the hospital complained bitterly that it was losing money on her care. A hospital social worker, records say, "was adamant about the child leaving the hospital today."
So, at 11:30 a.m. April 25, 2011, workers at Tampa General Hospital loaded the teen onto a stretcher in a private ambulance — as her mother and grandfather begged them to stop. Even as caseworkers were packing Marie's belongings, her grandfather was frantically filing hand-written emergency motions in court to delay the trip, Brudny said.
Doris Freyre, case notes say, "stated that no one knows my child like me," and that Marie's dislocated hip would cause her great pain if she were strapped to a stretcher for hours. She added: "If something happens to my daughter I am holding all of you responsible for it."
Freyre had no car — and the private ambulance refused to allow her to join Marie — so Marie made the trip to Miami-Dade County alone.
Records show the two ambulance workers refused to take Marie's seizure drugs with them; under the company's policy, they were not allowed to administer medications in any case. According to a report detailing Tampa General Hospital's care of Marie, the hospital neglected to ensure she was properly hydrated before she left. During her five-hour ambulance ride, she was given no water or food.
A September 2011 investigation by AHCA of how Tampa General discharged Marie to the nursing home faulted the hospital for a number of violations, including failing to ensure the child had enough fluids and was properly medicated. The hospital's lack of "concern" for Marie, the report said, left her "in danger."
The U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services placed the hospital under the status of "Immediate Jeopardy" following the review, the highest penalty under federal health regulations, said an AHCA spokeswoman. The following October, the federal agency removed the designation after Tampa General implemented a corrective action plan. AHCA also is seeking to fine the hospital $5,000 in the case, and a hearing is scheduled for Jan. 14.
Marie arrived in Miami Gardens the way she left Tampa: screaming. AHCA records for the next 12 hours mention only four notations in the nursing home file, and two of them document Marie "screaming."
By 5:40 a.m. April 27, 2011, Marie was described as having "labored" breathing. Five minutes later, she was unresponsive. The AHCA investigation concluded she had been given none of her life-sustaining anti-seizure drugs, required three times each day.
Marie was pronounced dead at 6:54 a.m. Cause of death: heart attack.
Two weeks later, on May 9, 2011, Doris Freyre appeared one last time before a judge in Tampa — Peacock, who declared herself "terribly sorry" for Freyre's loss.
"I don't accept your excuse," the mother replied. Freyre said she was in court to get her daughter's body back from the Miami-Dade Medical Examiner's Office. With no trust left for state officials, Freyre was seeking a private autopsy.
"It's the mother's position that the (state) had the child removed without proper authorization," said her attorney, Laguerra Champagne. "She objected to the child being physically removed from Hillsborough County and transported to Miami. No court hearing was held and, unfortunately, we're here today, dealing with a dead child instead of a living child."
Attila, the prosecutor who, weeks earlier, had fought so hard to get Marie to the nursing home, no longer wanted to discuss the matter. She told Peacock that a child welfare judge had no "jurisdiction" over a dead child and prosecutors would file a court motion saying so.
"Not to seem insensitive; I understand the mother is quite frustrated and I understand that she's grieving," Attila said, "but the information that she's providing to the court is moot at this point in time."
Despite Attila's protestations, Freyre had the last word.
"I had her for 14 years — cared (for) and loved her," Freyre said. "And you have her … in prison, in the hospital, without going out in the sun, without being with other people, in prison.
"Then, in (12) hours, you took her down to Miami and she died," Freyre added. "And I want the truth of this to come out. I want justice."
Marie's body remained in storage for nine months while the medical examiner's office completed its autopsy, and Freyre held a memorial with no body.
In the end, Marie's body was cremated in Tampa. Her ashes then were sent to Puerto Rico for a private family funeral.
the state didn’t just act on a whim. It was premeditated.
Is this murder 1 then?
what a sad atrocious story this has been. for so many reasons.
Between this, Trayvon Martin,and massive vote fraud, where the HELL is Governor Scott and Pam Bondi?
Is there something in the water in Florida?
Was nothing learned from Terri Schiavo in 2005?
The State knows what’s good for us!
The pre-meditated negligence of these state-sanctioned "kid cops" killed this young lady--outright.
Why is it that Florida has so much trouble with disabled children? There is a callus attitude towards the dignity of life that is a troubling characteristic of Florida.
obamacare, you ain’t seen nothin yet
The more and more control the state exerts, the more of these situations we’ll be seeing. Welcome to government control of medical treatment.
Don’t expect anybody in government to be held accountable for this. CPS typicaly have blanket immunity.
On the other hand, if you want to know why this is policy, follow the money. I’m sure it ends up with either a union or state sponsored facility which donates money to political causes that feed them.
I’ve got a great idea...let’s put folks like this in charge of every American’s healthcare.
I hear it’s working beautifully in the UK
Not to diminish this poor family’s plight but this is the kind of “care” the most vulnerable of us can expect when we are on the state’s dime. Unfortunately federal and state interference in the medical system is intended to push us all into a position of needing government to fund our care.
I don’t know what it would be like to have the federal and state government get out of the healthcare business. I don’t how much cheaper things would be or if care would be cheap enough for this mom to pay for it. I don’t know if it would have helped this girl if the US was the country it once was and people had to rely on private charity instead of medicaid. I don’t know if private charities could provide better care for more people if the government didn’t usurp so much money and responsibility. I suspect life would have been better for this family were healthcare left to the market but I do not know for sure. What I do know, without a shadow of a doubt, is that without the government’s intrusion into healthcare this girl would never have been ripped away from her family to die alone.
Tampa. Right near where Terri Schiavo died and home to the most powerful Scientology nest in the country. They are very pro-death and control all of the state offices in that area, either because the office holders are actual Scientologists or because the Scientologists have paid their way into office.
Nobody in the state seems to have the courage to take them on. Jeb Bush tried, but even he had to back down when they got the entire judiciary and legislature to go against him.
I don’t know if there’s any personal connection in this case, but what does exist is the influence of Scientology in shaping a harsh, unforgiving bureaucracy that is entirely on the side of the state and death and believes that it is enforcing some ideal when it “lets” (forces) people to die.
The State knows what's good for it!
The Obama Pathway
I will never forget standing in protest outside terrys “nursing home” where they refused terry water. she died a week and a half later. whoever said u can only go 3 days without water.... terry died a horrific death of dehydration at the hands of her ex and a florida judge and a warped evil attorney. God rest her soul.
I have a cousin who has lupus, and one of her kids has some serious medical issues. She’s swilling the kool-aid and is vehemantly in support of both Obamacare and that UN “Disabled Bill of Rights”. Nothing will make her see that the things she supports will be used against her and her children. I’m quite sure that even if it comes to boxcars and gas chambers, she’ll still be spouting the party line.
It’s a sad thing to watch.
it’s Florida ~ the Schiavo case should have taught everybody what it means to be severely handicapped in a fascist country.
Florida sure knows how to deal with those pesky costs for the disabled don’t they?
The "State" didn't do anything; an overpaid, megalomaniacal "social worker" ignored the judges' order and as such, should be held criminally responsible for this little angel's death.
... what was the penalty for defying the court?
If nothing, does this mean we can all defy Obamacare without penalty?
The very definition of the word "coward".
No, not at all. I was there that day in front of the hospital. Jeb Bush got NO public support and there were more press than people at the vigil. It was humiliating. If you live here, you should have been there, but I bet you weren’t.
Bush was undermined time and again by Jim King, from Jacksonville, the pro-death GOP leader of the FL State Senate.
The very last day, Bush was in discussions with the State Police, because the local Tampa St Pete area sheriff’s department and the local police were prepared to shoot if anyone tried to enter the hospital to rescue her. He decided that going in with the state police would not only result in other deaths and injuries, but would cause a constitutional crisis in the state of Florida (because he had exhausted all the legal remedies).
So before you call people “cowards,” examine yourself. How many times have you been arrested or spat upon and kicked at pro-life vigils? I have, and almost everybody in that little band (of Catholics and Evangelicals) out there with me in front of the hospital had had that same experience. But the worst thing of all was ridicule, and the fact that there were so few of us made us completely powerless and ridiculous. Where were you, and where were all the other scornful, venom-spewing Freepers, many of them in Florida, that day?
I have done so and I am not and if you defend him you are.
I hope you feel better after spewing that crap.
Coward is as coward does.
Results are all that count.
Bush let her be murdered because he is a coward.
The indifference of the larger community to Terri’s situation struck me, as well. It was as if we were in a little bubble at the hospice, enveloped in that spiritual battle. It seems one must be in the situation to understand. It was sad and perplexing.
Were you there too? You’re the first Freeper I have met who was there!
Sad and perplexing definitely describes it. I think a lot of that had to do with the hostile attitude of the Bishop of St Petersburg, Bp Lynch. He basically forbade his clergy to give any assistance to Terri or her family. If I had been a priest in that diocese, I simply would have said “the heck with it” and gone in, and I’m sure any priest who did that would have been supported by the Vatican. But the clergy had been suppressed and the laypeople of that diocese and in fact in all of Florida had never been called out and it was clear that in the opinion of the Florida bishops, whatever the state did was fine.
The only thing I can think of as an excuse is that many of the events in the few last days of Terri’s life occurred while JPII was dying, and probably there was some distraction because of that.
However, since that time almost all of the Florida bishops have been replaced (except, ironically, Lynch, although he’s become a lot more orthodox) and this would never happen again. But there’s a long way to go because the laity is so badly formed. My bishop had an overnight vigil to pray about the elections (he’s a well known opponent of Obama and statism) - while some of the leading lights of the parish were driving around with Obama stickers on their cars.
We’ve got a lot of work to do. I don’t know whether you’re Catholic or Evangelical (the only two groups who seem to have showed up), but one of the big problems is that the majority of both groups have somehow fallen into believing that the law of the state basically defines the moral law. It’s only a minority of Catholics or Evangelicals who really understand the issues.
Looks like they took the Nazi’s T-4 facility at Hadamar and moved it to Florida.
I was out in front of that hospice many, many times.
Along with several other FReepers.
Nobody spat at any of us while we were there, and I didn't see any arrests.
I did see several “activists” who frankly had their own agendas,muddied up the situation, and didn't care much about Terri and her plight at all.
The judge, many politicians, the media, and every loser with an agenda kept trying to make Terri Schiavo out to be a symbol of “ the right to death with dignity”.
The problem was, Terri wasn't dying, except for the times (plural) when the court ordered her to be forcibly starved and dehydrated.
And yes, Gov. Jeb Bush could have stopped her execution.
Make no mistake, Terri Schiavo was executed by the State of Florida.
Jeb Bush had plenty of public and elected official support. He also had opposition.
But he failed as a leader, and yes, I consider him a coward.
It appears this poor child was murdered by rogue government employees, as opposed to officially executed, under State sanction.
That being said, I sincerely doubt those individuals directly culpable in her murder will even be investigated, much less punished.
After all, one would have to actively prove malicious intent in a court of law...mere incompetence and dereliction of duty won't suffice.
Yes, several times. I’m sorry our paths didn’t cross!
floriduh voter was there most of the time, and very dedicated, also Eternal Vigilence. I know other freepers were there as well, but unfortunately I didn’t knowingly meet them. One freeper no longer active went down before all got dire and I got to meet her on her way back to Texas - she drove from that far away, to pray at the hospice! that dedicated!
Part I came out yesterday: Never Let Go
. . .
Interestingly, here's an article she wrote: From ordinary girl to international icon
Thanks for the updated information and links. I truly appreciate those. And thank you for the comment on the maternal cells thread. Seems we share a common interest in supplemental information via links. :-)
I guess she lived up to her name.
This is a tragic story.