Skip to comments.Question of the Week: Has the European Fiscal Crisis Ended?
Posted on 01/13/2013 6:43:59 AM PST by Kaslin
Ive frequently commented on Europes fiscal mess and argued that excessive government spending is responsible for both the sovereign debt crisis and the economic stagnation that plagues the continent.
But it does seem that things have calmed down, so the readers who have submitted questions about whether the fiscal crisis has ended obviously are paying attention.
I have two responses.
But let me start with some good news. Most of the hard-hit European nations have finally begun the cut spending. And when I say cut spending, I mean they actually spent less in 2011 than they did in 2010 (unlike the fake version of spending cuts that you find in the U.S. and U.K., where spending simply grows at a slower pace).
We dont have data for 2012, but I wouldnt be surprised if many of the PIIGS nations also cut spending last year as well.
Now for some bad news. Unlike the Baltic nations, the PIIGS dragged their feet and didnt reduce the burden of government spending until they had no choice.
Moreover, they all imposed crippling tax hikes. Indeed, the tax increases in Greece were so severe that even the International Monetary Fund warned that the country might be past the Laffer Curve revenue-maximizing point.
So while long-overdue reductions in spending meant less money was being diverted from the economys productive sector, higher tax rates have discouraged entrepreneurs and investors from creating jobs and wealth.
So whats the net effect?
From an optimistic perspective, the fiscal situation should stabilize if governments keep spending under control. Some additional spending cuts would be very desirable since government spending consumes 45 percent-50 percent of GDP in these nations, which is at least double the growth-maximizing level.
But even if these nations merely abide by Mitchells Golden Rule and restrain spending so that it grows slower than the private sector, that would be progress.
The reason Im not optimistic, though, is that I dont sense any commitment to smaller government. I fear governments will let the spending genie out of the bottle at the first opportunity. And were talking about a scary genie, not Barbara Eden.
And to make matters worse, Europe faces a demographic nightmare. These charts, reproduced from a Bank for International Settlements study, show that even the supposedly responsible nations in Europe face a tsunami of spending and debt over the next 25-plus years.
So you can understand why I dont express a lot of optimism about European economic policy in this interview with Canadian TV.
The ostensible topic was European-wide financial regulation, but that topic is really a proxy for the fact that some nations want to bail out their financial sectors. But theyre in such lousy fiscal shape that they cant borrow the money that would be needed to prop up their dodgy banks.
So I pointed out that European-wide regulation wasnt the right answer. It wouldnt make banks safer (since it would be based upon the deeply flawed Basel regulations), but could become a vehicle for nations such as Germany to further subsidize countries such as Spain.
But I hope I got across my main point, which is that these nations are burdened with too much government and their problems wont be solved with more handouts, regulation, or bureaucracy.
In other words, theres no substitute for genuine spending cuts implemented by the nation states of Europe.
P.S. Just in case youre under the impression that only cranky libertarians think government is too big in Europe, I invite you to peruse this research from the European Central Bank, World Bank, and National Bank of Finland.
P.P.S. To close with some European-themed humor, we have three videos: 1) A romantic comedy involving Mr. Greece and Ms. Germany, 2) Hitler learning about the European downgrade, and 3) A Greek perspective on Germany.
P.P.P.S. Heck, I cant resisting sharing this cartoon, this Dave Barry mockery, and the non-PC map of Europe as well.
Who cares? Guns are the issue.