Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Destroying Gifted Education: A National Calamity on the Installment Plan
familysecuritymatters.org ^ | 28 March, 2013 | ROBERT WEISSBERG

Posted on 04/01/2013 10:15:01 AM PDT by marktwain

Imagine that the CIA uncovered a Chinese plot to attack the American economy by undermining our educational system, specifically by making sure that we no longer cultivated the smartest of the smart? The response would be outrage, and rightly so. Some might even call it an act of war, far worse than the usual cyber attack. Alas, what our foreign enemies dare not attempt, we inflict on ourselves. This is a war on gifted education, killing off the intellectually demanding programs targeting the top 3 or 5% of our national brainpower.

This war is a barely noticed guerilla war, one school district at a time but rest assured it will be lethal. Time to sound the alarm and explain how it works.

The latest installment of this nefarious stealth battle was reported in a March 4th in a Wall Street Journal articles-"Gifted Class Imbalance." The article told how New York City's classes for the smartest kids were disproportionately white and Asian. Specifically, while whites and Asians make up a third of all students K-5 they comprise 70% of all students in the city's 110 gifted programs.

The implication was that this imbalance is "unfair" and enrollments should reflect the city's overall demography (yes, this is the Wall Street Journal). The article reported that several educators were "disturbed" by the pattern and one professor from the prestigious Teachers College, Columbia University said that the standardized admission tests should be replaced by a more "balanced" approach that included teacher evaluation and student interviews so as to make enrollments more racially and ethnically representative. Elsewhere in the story this gap was blamed on economic inequality--rich parents can buy expensive books to give their children a leg up in the competition for slots.

It goes without saying that relaxing academic standards via demographic quotas would destroy gifted education. Imagine trying to teach pre-algebra to a class where half the class struggles with arithmetic? A teacher would quickly dumb down the lessons lest the less able students fail the class, a politically unacceptable outcome. Moreover, killing off gifted programs via dilution might well further undermine the city's public schools and therefore weaken the city's tax base. How many parents with intellectually talented offspring denied admission to free public gifted programs will stay put when the private school alternative costs $30,000 a year? Better to escape to the suburbs.

Why, then, do some people, including professors of education still demand filling gifted slots by quota despise the awaiting calamity? Let me suggest two reasons: the radical egalitarian faith and the public's misunderstanding of how education works.

The egalitarian faith is easy to spot. True believers, often in the prestige media (e.g., The New York Time) and the academy are obsessed with leveling differences. It's their passionate religion. They oppose glass ceilings, unequal pay, differences in college graduation rates and anything else that shows group-related gaps in accomplishment. That these unequal outcomes may be intractable hardly deters their boiling anger over supposed unfairness and the need for yet more heavy-handed government intervention.


TOPICS: Culture/Society; Government; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: education; equality; gifted; giftedprogram; publicschools
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-4041-50 next last
My daughter was in "magnet" charter school that took considerable effort and test scores to enter. She and the school did exceptionally well.

Soon after she graduated, they shut down the program because it was not "equal".

1 posted on 04/01/2013 10:15:01 AM PDT by marktwain
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: marktwain

I went to nerd high school and they’ve been fighting the same battle since before I got there (1982). Always not enough minorities, because Jews and orientals aren’t poor and therefore aren’t minorities no matter how few of them there are.


2 posted on 04/01/2013 10:17:35 AM PDT by discostu (Not just another moon faced assassin of joy.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

There’s a battle going on for the NYC science schools. Deplorable.

My own school was destroyed by jealous parents who first weakened it with quotas. Then when friends of the quota-system kids ran wild one weekend and vandalized the gym, they closed the school.

It’s really irrational. They wouldn’t try to close La Guardia High School or Performing Arts High School. Why should academic intelligence be different from any other talent?


3 posted on 04/01/2013 10:22:36 AM PDT by firebrand
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

Gifted kids SHOULD NOT be in school anyway.

Do we really want people with IQs of 140+ being brainwashed into sociopath doctrine and turning into Democrat advisers?!


4 posted on 04/01/2013 10:22:56 AM PDT by Wanderer99
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: discostu; All
“Jews and orientals aren’t poor and therefore aren’t minorities no matter how few of them there are.”

Exactly correct.

The same logic applies to white men. They are clearly a minority in the country, yet are discriminated against with impunity.

5 posted on 04/01/2013 10:23:02 AM PDT by marktwain (The MSM must die for the Republic to live. Long live the new media!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

One culprit is standardized testing. In order to get better test scores, huge efforts are made to reach the students at the bottom of the ability level, and salvage a couple. As a result, nothing is done for the upper level students.


6 posted on 04/01/2013 10:24:04 AM PDT by GenXteacher (You have chosen dishonor to avoid war; you shall have war also.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: firebrand
Why should academic intelligence be different from any other talent?

Academic intelligence is a threat to socialism. It must be snuffed out even if that means that civilization must subsequently collapse. Loyalty to 'the cause' is the only 'intelligence' anyone needs anyway...

The last thing any left wing teacher needs is a smart student calling him/her out on the non-factual bull**** ;P
7 posted on 04/01/2013 10:26:15 AM PDT by Wanderer99
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: Wanderer99; All
Gifted kids SHOULD NOT be in school government school anyway.
8 posted on 04/01/2013 10:30:34 AM PDT by marktwain (The MSM must die for the Republic to live. Long live the new media!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

UHS’ best defense has been other magnet schools in the district, they encourage and assist these other schools that cover UHS’ “weaknesses”. Thus we have magnets that draw heavily from the Mexican population, magnets that focus on the arts, stuff like that. So UHS can say “yeah we’re weak on that, BUT those kids are still getting opportunities”. Of course if TUSD wasn’t a ridiculously large district (far too large really) they wouldn’t be able to use that.


9 posted on 04/01/2013 10:32:20 AM PDT by discostu (Not just another moon faced assassin of joy.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

I gots my Obamafone.

Wot U talkin?

Anudda white boy project.

Racist!


10 posted on 04/01/2013 10:32:51 AM PDT by Da Coyote
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: marktwain
Let me suggest two reasons: the radical egalitarian faith and the public's misunderstanding of how education works.

Let me suggest a third reason: the desire of elites to eliminate competition for their own kids (expensively educated at private school) from smart middle-class kids for the best college slots and work slots.

11 posted on 04/01/2013 10:35:34 AM PDT by PapaBear3625 (You don't notice it's a police state until the police come for you.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Da Coyote

They did the same with mine.


12 posted on 04/01/2013 10:36:11 AM PDT by JCBreckenridge (Texas is a state of mind - Steinbeck)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

The policy of “inclusion,” aiming for the lowest common denominator.


13 posted on 04/01/2013 10:37:58 AM PDT by NonValueAdded (If you can keep your head when all about you are losing theirs, you've likely misread the situation.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

Ha!
This has been going on for over 35 years!

The solution has been obvious and avoided for just as long.

Cut out the crap courses to ensure all students have a worthwhile foundation.

Cut the administration staff in half.

Fire the Unions who perpetuate such waste.

Then you will have plenty of money, with existing income, to provide a substantial and meaningful mainstream track, as well as gifted and learning disadvantaged programs.


14 posted on 04/01/2013 10:41:58 AM PDT by G Larry (Which of Obama's policies do you think I'd support if he were white?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Wanderer99

Warning! Blog within a blog... The tyranny of “equality” it’s the BIG THING! Most are for it (who could oppose)… but what is “equality” and who gets to define it? One equality… that of before the law (that used to govern us) and where wealth and social standing are of no benefit is foundational to our Constitution. But a more sinister form of “equality” (a pathogen IMHO), is among us. Wearing a mask of benevolence… it is ANYTHING but… in fact, it is malevolent! The equality of outcome, regardless of effort or talent applied by the individual. This “equality” is the ENEMY of excellence and must be enforced (top-down) by a very unequal oligarchy of academics, government officials and media “enforcers”. Most evident in the public educational system where more and more we see the de-emphasis of honors programs (Valedictorian/Salutatorian)… the outstanding are diminished and even marginalized… less some less accomplished have their all-important feelings hurt.

So the outstanding are NOT to be recognized and thus often discouraged from their pursuit of excellence. This trend is gaining as people (especially minorities) are basically told by their leaders and authorities, government and academic, to STAY PUT in whatever societal position they currently occupy. Our “safety net” is often not a “hammock” but a PRISON from which there is little chance of escape! This idea of “equality” has more in common with the equality of slaves, than of free people. As again… this version of “equality” must enforced (root word FORCE)… as those who seek excellence are told they need not apply, less they become unequal (the 21st Century “original sin”). Such “equality” is tyranny and chains! Are we observing the sad evidence of a once great nation now in decline? God save us from “equality”!


15 posted on 04/01/2013 10:46:28 AM PDT by FiddlePig
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: marktwain
I was in one of the first 'gifted' classes in elementary school. Two years later, the schools were redistricted, and I was the only one left at my school. This was when I was in 6th grade.

They didn't know what to do with me, so they just sent me to the library every day. I helped the librarian, and she came up with projects for me to do.

That's how I got involved with model rocketry, and also when Mensa invited me to join.

I declined Mensa's invitation. This was late 70s.

16 posted on 04/01/2013 10:48:53 AM PDT by real saxophonist ("Always Progressing and Not Fitting Neatly in a Box" - Tosin Abasi)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: FiddlePig

Nice blog. You should start your own.


17 posted on 04/01/2013 10:50:41 AM PDT by marktwain (The MSM must die for the Republic to live. Long live the new media!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 15 | View Replies]

To: real saxophonist; All

It is clear most freepers are in the top 10%.


18 posted on 04/01/2013 10:51:43 AM PDT by marktwain (The MSM must die for the Republic to live. Long live the new media!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

My poor granddaughter was in the gifted program because she excelled in her school work. Then they decided that they had to have a certain IQ and they sent her for testing. She pretty much flunked the IQ test, LOL.

They kept her in the class because she was smart and was a good motivater but they didn’t get any extra money.

We knew that the IQ test was wrong and as time went on we found out that she stresses so badly that she almost seizes.

She was in a race in HS was beating everyone and stopped at the last hurdle and stared at it do seconds like she didn’t know what it was then her head cleared and she backed up and jumped it and went for the finish line.

After she took the ACT she broke out in fever blisters and canker sores. She only scored a 22 and was going to take it again but her parents told her not to, she had a good enough scholastic record that she could get scholarships and she did.

She is in college and doing great, she is a cheerleader which takes at least 3 hours a day, she works 20 hours a week.


19 posted on 04/01/2013 10:57:42 AM PDT by tiki
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: marktwain

I served in the U.S.Navy for six years as a crypto-linguist.

There were very few blacks at language school, and none were in my Chinese language course.

When I arrived at my duty station overseas, there were no black sailors serving as a crypo-linguist. There were morse key operators, administration and technical equipment personnel who were black, but they were few in number.

Signals intelligence tested extensively for the specific requirements to each rating. It wasn’t the linguistic tests that kept blacks or hispanics out; it was the tests for cryptanalysis.


20 posted on 04/01/2013 10:59:24 AM PDT by SatinDoll (NATURAL BORN CITZEN: BORN IN THE USA OF CITIZEN PARENTS.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-4041-50 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson