Skip to comments.Arpaio's office guilty of profiling, judge rules
Posted on 05/25/2013 6:13:03 AM PDT by SandRat
PHOENIX - Self-professed "toughest sheriff in America" Joe Arpaio and the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office were guilty of racial profiling, a federal judge found Friday, before ordering a permanent halt to the practice.
In a 140-page ruling, Judge Murray Snow said Arpaio's department, under his direction, was detaining individuals believed to be in this country illegally without some other reason to arrest them for violating any state laws.
Snow said that continued to occur even after the Department of Homeland Security revoked the department's authority to identify and detain those not in the country legally.
The judge also said department policy and practice allow officers to consider the ethnicity of a vehicle's occupants in determining whether they have reasonable suspicion to investigate them for violation of state immigration laws.
"In some instances these policies result in prolonging the traffic stop beyond the time necessary to resolve the issue that initially justified the stop," Snow wrote. Absent some reasonable suspicion of criminal activity, holding people longer than necessary violates their constitutional rights against unreasonable search and seizure, he said.
Snow said that entitled Hispanic individuals who sued to an injunction permanently barring the Arpaio's department from using Hispanic ancestry or race to determine whether to stop a vehicle. It also prohibits deputies from detaining or arresting Latino occupants of a vehicle on a belief that they are in this country illegally if race is the only factor they have.
The order also bars the agency from detaining Latino occupants of vehicles stopped for traffic violations any longer than necessary to process the citation unless officers have "reasonable suspicion" that any are committing a federal or state crime.
Arpaio said he does not believe his agency engages in racial profiling. "That's why we're going to appeal it," he said.
But Dan Pochoda, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Arizona, said the ruling confirms allegations Latinos have been "terrorized" by Arpaio's deputies and "forced to endure years of racial harassment and abuse." In a prepared statement, Pochoda said all that can be laid at the feet of "Arpaio's proven willingness to seek political gain at the expense of public safety and constitutional guarantees."
Friday's ruling has no financial implications, as the plaintiffs in the civil case did not seek damages, but only an injunction to require the agency to changes its practices.
At least on paper, the instructions to deputies were that vehicles were not to be stopped based on the race of those in a vehicle, Snow said. But he said evidence painted a different picture.
"While officers were prohibited from using race as the only basis to undertake a law enforcement investigation, they were allowed as a matter of policy and instruction to consider race as one factor among others in making law enforcement decisions in the context of immigration enforcement," the judge wrote.
Snow reached his ruling after reviewing years of crime prevention "saturation patrols" by the department. He said these were far from neutral.
The department "almost always scheduled its day-labor and small-scale saturation patrols where Latino day laborers congregated," he said. "The same is true for a considerable number of its large-scale saturation patrols."
And Snow said it is clear the purpose of these patrols was to enforce immigration laws, citing the news releases issued by the agency's public relations officers.
"These news releases either emphasized that the patrols' purpose was immigration enforcement, or prominently featured the number of unauthorized aliens arrested during such operations," Snow said. "Most of the time, the reports ignored any other arrests that took place."
Snow also said the saturation operations were just a pretext to stop vehicles with people who may be in this country illegally.
"During saturation patrols, participating deputies conducted many stops for minor violations of the traffic code, including minor equipment violations," the judge said.
And Snow said that, generally speaking, deputies "had no difficulty in finding a basis to stop any vehicle they wished for a traffic infraction."
Arrest them for being in the State illegally
Profiling is efficient use of resources. It beats doing body cavity searches on old folks and infants at the airports.
Everybody’s guilty of ‘profiling’ - it’s how the species survives. Even Jesse Jackson once said that though he was embarrassed to admit it, if he saw a group of young, black males walking down the street he would move to the other side.
God bless and keep Sheriff Joe.
Prayer for his worthy success.
Yeah, but it doesn't intimidate citizens. That is what they want.
They are relentless in their persecution of this good man.
Prayers up for him & his family.
Irony would be this judge run down by an unlicenced
illegal alien who could have been stopped.
The corrupt Eric Holder again.
We must faithfully pray our hearts out for Sheriff Joe.
He is guilty of being a good cop.
Coming soon to a city near you.
I love your thinking....
This *judge* should be impeached on this basis alone.
Since when do illegal aliens, not citizens of the USA, have "constitutional rights"...?
No wonder our country is so f$%#ed up....
Great minds ,etc.
I guess no more BOLO alerts from here out too.
Let me see, we have a huge pattern of illegal activity by a group that looks a certain way but we cannot look for them by group because that is profiling? What about when the G was knocking out the Mafia and did a dragnet of all guys named Salvatore, Vito and Nino or when WWII broke out and they said lets round up all the Japs and put them in concentration camps, that was not profiling? Profiling is a great tool, it cuts the wheat from the chaff.
The thing that aggravates me to no end is when all these utopian ideas come to fruition and we are left broke with some third world status, we will not be able to seek retribution from those who put us there.
If I were Sheriff Joe, I would have teams of deputies following this scumbag Judge, And every time he did something wrong pull him over and issue a citation, follow him to Dinner and throw him in Jail for DUI after he has that glass of Wine with Dinner. Make it impossible for this piece of shit to live his life.
Hispanic is a race?
And in other news, they were guilty of carrying sidearms.
The only law enforcement tool more effective than their guns is profiling. Racial, sexual, age, apparent income level, culture. You name it. It is important and highly valuable.
Plenty of judges are now just as ideologically corrupt and politically driven as the IRS and DOJ officials.
When in retail sales back in the 70’s I was very good at what I did. And I overtly knew that “profiling” was one of my most effective tools.
Judge Snow, a Bush appointee, I might have known.
I’m thinking the ACLU will sue Joe next.
Isn’t Murray that faggot judge that ruled in favor of faggots ?
Arpaio for President!
No, Arpaio for Secretary of Homeland Security.
So now we have come to the point where we only enforce some laws and not others. How obamaesque.
Sheriff Arpaio is already the Secretary of Homeland Security for Maricopa County. We need to abolish the federal DHS. It’s an abomination.
Correction: Make that an Obamanation, and thanks again, George Bush.
We used to call this law enforcement. Now it is called unconstitutional for non citizens.
Weird times. You can stop the free speech of American citizens but you can’t arrest non-citizens who sneak into the country.
If you are looking for illegal Mexicans, you would stop.... MEXICANS
Uh....yeah....and so what?
That is standard police procedure. There was a guy in New York who was stopped for the his license plate light being out which ended in his being arrested because his CCW held 9 rather then 7 bullets.
How a bulb being burned out lead to "let me examine your lawfully carried weapon" is something I don't get but the no one seems to be getting huffy over that.
He should go to one of them and hang around all day long. Wear a good suit too. Flash money.
Sheriff Joe, ya need to be stopping and body searching grannies, veterans, mastectomy survivors, and sticking your hands down the underwear of little kids, just to prove you are not “profiling”
“Judge Murray Snow”......and to what political party does the judge belong?
Sheriff Arpaio refuses to let the commie lib ‘RATS and their La Raza boys intimidate him. He still puts the safety of Arizonans ahead of surrendering to the Mexican invaders.
Just one more reason for the fedgov to oppose it. If local and state governments start using resources efficiently, people might start to expect the feds to do the same, and that is something they can not abide.
I doubt if the judge is dancing with the one that brought him to the party ....
I think that's what he's been doing. Holding/arresting for being here illegally, regardless of race.
You cannot be found “guilty” in a civil case...if this judge actually said this....he should be removed for judicial misconduct
Illegal Alien is not a race. If Illegal Aliens tend to be Hispanic....then Hispanics are obviously going to be arrested for being Illegal Alien
All Arpaio and MCSD has to do is pull over more whites to meet the “racial quota”
Yeh because we all know the Swedes are the prevalent ethnic group sneaking in here illegally by the millions.
At some point the American people are going to take things into their own hands. I wonder if you shoot them as they come across the border if this judge would consider it profiling?
Sheriff Joe another Pet Project of Obama and Holder . They keep throwing things at you to bankrupt you make you quit ,been done to many republicans
Right. I’m on Face Book with Sheriff Joe. He’s not giving in at all. Sheriff Joe will have the last laugh on corrupt Eric Holder.
God bless Sheriff Joe.
If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it’s probably a duck.
Then why isn't the FBI guilty of racial profiling when they profile white serial killers and child pornographers?
It’s not profiling. It’s math.
Murray Snow is a Mormon whose father was an LDS bishop. Snow did his 2 years In Mexico and speaks fluent Spanish. The LDS are relentlessly pushing for illegal Alien Amnesty. Snow should have been challenged from the beginning.
In a prepared statement, were the TRUTH to have been said, the quote should have been; "Arpaio's proven willingness to seek public safety at the expense of political gain and misinterpreted constitutional guarantees is what resulted in a liberal-biased judgement against him."