Skip to comments.Lawsuit Says 77-Year-Old Veteran Died After Police Tased Him
Posted on 05/29/2013 10:38:48 AM PDT by redreno
After wandering away from the Montana Veterans Home in Columbia Falls last June, a 77-year-old Korean War veteran suffering from severe Alzheimers disease was tased by police, fell face-first to the pavement where he struck his head and died later due to injuries from the fall, according to a lawsuit filed last month by a family member representing his estate.
Tamara Downen of Columbia Falls filed the lawsuit on April 5 in Helenas Lewis and Clark County District Court, claiming that her grandfather, Stanley Downen, died as a result of negligence by the Montana Veterans Home, Columbia Falls Police Department and Montana Department of Public Health and Human Services.
The lawsuit states that on May 31, 2012, Stanley Downen was admitted as a resident to the veterans home, described as a nursing facility that includes a 15-bed Alzheimers unit. Downen had a history of behavioral issues and advanced dementia resulting from severe progressive Alzheimers disease.
(Excerpt) Read more at flatheadbeacon.com ...
Stop using tasers for compliance. That is not why they were designed. They replace deadly force; that’s it.
My son was just telling me that Ft. Worth shot a 72 yr man in his garage that had heard his neighbor’s alarm go off, grabbed his pistol, going to help his neighbor. Cops shot him and never went to the right house. Nice neighborhood too.
Not all LEO’s are there to “Serve and Protect”..
Some just want a badge to slake their control issues..
Oh!.. and a snappy uniform.. as a mask..
Sometimes “they” are in charge..
What kind of pig would tase an Alzheimer’s victim?
THE MAN WAS SHOT ON HIS OWN PROPERTY!
With Downen resisting efforts to direct him back to the home, the suit asserts, staff members called 911 to request police assistance. Officers made verbal attempts to persuade Downen to move to a grassy area, but when he refused to cooperate they tased him, according to the familys complaint.
So the LEOs KNEW he was an Alzheimer's patient and STILL tased him! Niiiice.
Keystone Kops strike again.
Who on Earth are they hiring these days????
“He served in the U.S. Navy during the Korean War and received a National Defense Service medal in honor of serving his country.”
With thanks from a grateful nation.
The cops who did this should be executed.
I agree this should not have happened and that the police over-reacted. But if this guy has a history of acting violent (which some Alzheimers patients do), I can understand how this could happen. Its not the job of the police to accept getting hit or being subjected to the physical outbursts of a violent person, even if that person has Alzheimers. So some overreaction is acceptable to avoid having police get hurt. But if this old man wasn’t hurting anyone and was standing in a field, I suspect there could have been other ways to deal with this. This wasn’t just a little overreaction, it was extreme overreaction.
Police standards have dropped significantly over the last 2 decades. Used to you would even get a call back if you had used any drugs, now they overlook misdemeanor amounts and other things as well.
That’s murder. So when is the guilty officer going to be arrested?
He wouldn’t obey, so they tazed him.
The reality here is that the police have only two modes of action: boredom or attack. Nothing in between. Nothing in their little minds that says “hey, this is an old guy obviously confused. He’s no threat to us”
If this angers you, good. That was my intention.
Yes, the Columbine Response. Idiotic procedure instead of common sense. I have yet to see anyone being held accountable. Never call the police.
Exactly how much damage is a 77 year old unarmed Alzheimer patient going to inflict?? There was no excuse for this, imo.
Yes, if it is also murder if a big hulk of a guy hopped up on drugs dies as the result of being tased. But based on what I typically see posted on FR (not saying it is posted by you), there's a double standard on that issue.
Alzheimer's patients can get pretty violent. Don't know if this guy was or not, but there's a lot of other things we don't know as well.
I remember a story a few yrs back of an older woman tazed because her caregiver was having a hard time giving her insulin as she was going into diabetic shock. The cops knew what was going on but tazed her anyway, sending her to hospital. I don’t remember if she survived the attack.
I’d call that manslaughter. The man with the taser needs to do time.
Candy striper, gift wrapper, "would you like fries with that?", or my personal favourite for the cowardly in uniform:
Too late. The motto for police has changed from “To Protect And Serve” to “To Tase Until Compliant”.
“Its not the job of the police to accept getting hit or being subjected to the physical outbursts of a violent person”
Yes, it sure as phuck is. If someone is slinging fists they are supposed to respond accordingly, not murder 77-year-old men.
That’s just one more reason that women should never be allowed to play-pretend at police officer.
“THE MAN WAS SHOT ON HIS OWN PROPERTY!”
Betcha a hunnerd bucks it was a woman who shot him.
He was 77 years old!!! How much of a physical threat could he pose to couple of cops?
PS....I spent several years as a primary caregiver
The police also shot a guy responding to his neighbor’s burglar alarm (on drudge report.) The police are tazer and trigger happy. I don’t want to call them for any reason. Their new culture of “everyone’s a terrorist” is murdering innocent people. Thank u, Big Sis and all the lesbian police chiefs all over the country for following her lead.
This is getting ridiculous. Pls see my last post. NEW POLICE DIRECTIVE: Everyone is a Terrorist.
The new Gestapo, America’s police departments. They do these things because no one holds them accountable.
Good Friday, 2001 I had to call an ambulance to help get Mom to the hospital.... Alzheimer's. She was refusing to take medication and getting increasingly aggitated and was going to hurt herself. (She broke her hand before they got there, but it didn't slow her down any) Cops came too. Evidently they had to accompany the EMTs on "disturbed person" calls.
Calling the police these days, is a bad idea.
Especially if you have dogs....
Cops quit being your friend about the time the Hippies nicknamed em pigs and wasted no time in earning the tag.
Unfortunately, I have been to people who died after being tazed over the years. It was not the tazer that was the primary cause of death nor injuries from the fall. The deaths were the result of being handcuffed and left face down in a way that restricted the person’s airway.
They asked him to go to the grass area, because they fully intended to taser him more safely, IMHO.
So how do us normal people join Internal Affairs and help get rid of these dregs?
LEOs should stick to their real job:
What's so difficult about dealing with a 77 year old Alzheimer's patient? If a Cop can't deal with a 77 year old unarmed man, they should be booted off the force immediately.
I hope the police lose this lawsuit big-time so it sends a clear message. Yes, it'll hurt the taxpayers, but it's better sooner rather then later before the cops tase their grandpa to death...
Who they are hiring are a bunch of kids from GDE level education who’ve been in the military. The very same we stupidly call “heroes”, when all they’ve done is join an increasingly mendacious military service branch.
These kids are the breading ground for Rambo wannabees who wear aviator sunglasses and shoot our dogs. The USA, after defeating two mighty foes in 3.5 years in the forties, cannot call itself a military superpower in the first decade of the 21st century while dithering our resources in Afganastan and Iraq for the past 10 years. We’ve bred these high tech warriors to do exactly what they’re doing...dropping out of high school, joining the military, being trained to kill with extreme prejudice, not allowing them to fight legitimate wars, and then hiring them in disproportionate numbers into local law enforcement organizations, where they trample on the rights of the public that they are sworn to serve, but have no knowledge of the rights that the public has.
“Thank you for serving your country”, my ass.
The HELL IT's not! It IS their job to use appropriate measures to protect the public. If they can't handle a 77 year old patient, they need to find another job. How do you think health care workers handle these situations? They don't tase old people. This paramilitary crap needs to end.
No it isn't. There is no situation in which overreaction by the police is acceptable. Overreaction results from panic (or possibly evil). Panic is a sign of either poor training or cowardice.
Most police departments also require a bachelor’s degree, preferably in a related field (e.g., criminal justice). But I’m sure they’d be fine with a degree in women’s studies, social work or psychology.
“The deaths were the result of being handcuffed and left face down in a way that restricted the persons airway.”
We’ve known about that problem for a long time now. You’d think the cops would catch on.
The vast majority of new hire policemen are from the military.
This is just a fact. It wasn’t always that way as most returning veterans were drafted and wanted to get on with their lives as they envisioned them prior to being called up. We’ve turned a dangerous corner lately though, and recently returned veterans who’ve been discharged find their friendly local police organization the best place for a job.
The problem is that the police have become a quasi military organization, including the titular nomenclature.
I built a police academy in south Georgia and I am certain of what I am saying. Just north of Brunswick GA is the FLETCH of which I was the architect and general contractor.
LEO’s hire ex military in far disproportionate numbers as they are the easiest to train for the current purposes.
Can you even imagine the LEO’s doing a face down take down on the 50s, what’s going on is preposterous, and there’s no excuse. Give me another Irish immigration, where patrolman O’Malley gave us the hand on the shoulder.
I’m sorry but my wife just added that they are all shaved headed, Darth Vader dressed, Nazi pinheads.
She’s damed accurate.