Skip to comments.Michigan Court of Appeals rules pension issue unconstitutional
Posted on 08/15/2013 4:42:54 PM PDT by Oldeconomybuyer
LANSING -- The Michigan Court of Appeals has ruled a law requiring state employees to contribute four-percent of their pay to the pension system is unconstitutional.
An Ingham County Judge said the entire law known as Public Act 264 violated the constitution, but the Appeals Court disagreed sent the issue back to the lower court. They asked the judge to define what parts of the law were valid.
The Appeals Court did agree with the lower court over payment to the pension system saying the state's Civil Service Commission makes those decisions and not the legislature. The law passed in 2011 applied to nearly 18,000 state workers hired before 1997.
What is unconstitutional about asking people to pay for their own stuff?
I say...stop hiring them....lets go to all volunteer police and firemen......
I wonder if I could make the case that its constitutional to force the people of Michigan to set aside money for my retirement?
I’m not greedy or anything, I’ll be more than happy with 1/100 of every penny earned in Michigan. I don’t think its unreasonable.
yup. It is insane.
Unfortunately MCOLES (Michigan Commission on Law Enforcement Standards) requires police officers to receive at least minimum wage in order to retain their police powers. This prevents exactly what you suggest.
Understand that Ingham county is the Lansing area, very liberal. Almost all rulings against common sense laws come from one or two judges in Ingham county. The appeals court also ruled to day to support other sensible fiscal matters.
Lots of laws requiring law enforcement.
My little town could get rid of our local police department but only if we contracted with the county to patrol. It was supposed to save us money but the cost of the county patrols has nearly reached the same cost as paying our own guys. We’re virtually crime free here as it is.
I did grow up in a town with a part time Constable.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.