Skip to comments.Conservatives to Cruz: 'Run, Ted, run'
Posted on 09/02/2013 8:48:13 AM PDT by SoConPubbie
click here to read article
I don’t know. Does Senator Cruz have a Canadian passport or not? It does seem rather unlikely that he currently has a Canadian passport. He might have had one when he moved here at four.
I’m pretty sure he just recently renounced (or is renouncing) Canadian citizenship. He was a dual citizen at birth. The laws on that vary by country, but I’m not claiming Senator Cruz isn’t an American. He’s certainly American, but is he “natural born?”
“Why are you even a FReeper?”
I’m a Freeper because I am a conservative and I believe that FR stands up for principled conservativism.
I disagree with you here, JR. I think you’re making a mistake. I understand your desire for Ted as President. All too well. I think he’s a fantastic man, but I think that the principle is larger than any one man.
I remember some of what Washington himself said about the office - where some were saying that Washington should serve as long as he was alive. Then Washington himself stepped in and said - “the office is greater than any one man”. We must not and can not afford to set aside the principles of the constitution even for one man, no matter how great the man might be.
“If you dont like what we stand for”
What happens when those principles change? Am I supposed to bail or fight for the same principles that FR has always stood behind? What would you do if you sincerely believed that FR was leaving behind what they stood for? Would you stand and fight for these principles, or would you go?
“IF Cruz runs and IF hes the strongest conservative running (which no doubt he will be, look up his record) he will have my support 100%!!”
My disagreement has nothing to do with the man or his policies. He’s my Senator. I think he’s a fantastic senator. It has everything to do with the office of the presidency and the principles behind it. I believe Americans should be represented by someone who is born in America.
“And Im not going to allow the crap that happened during the last two presidential cycles to happen again. RINO supporters can go straight to hell as far as Im concerned along with any conservative who supports amnesty.”
Would you label someone who agreed with the principle that the office of the presidency ought to be reserved for someone born in America a RINO?
“See if you can find the Founders remedy for despotic government.”
I do. One of the checks is requiring the president to be born here. Not elsewhere. There are good reasons for this.
Jim Robinson: “His mother was an American citizen. Cruz is an American citizen by birth. A natural born American citizen!!”
To tell the truth, I haven’t thought a lot about the “natural born” provision one way or the other. So you’re saying the natural born provision only bans people who are naturalized citizens?
“He was a dual citizen at birth.”
Cruz had to reside in America in order to keep his American citizenship. This is not true of natural born citizens. He is a Canadian citizen as well as an American citizen. He would be eligible for Cuban citizenship (through his father), at the time of his birth.
Canadian citizens are eligible for a Canadian passport. Cruz is, and has always been a Canadian citizen. This is different from a natural born citizen - born in America who would not be considered a dual citizen.
I’m sorry that facts are considered to be lies. These are all factual statements. I agree that Cruz is a fantastic senator. I want him to stay in the senate and help us take the senate over.
Have no idea. But the argument is stupid and self-defeating. Millions of natural born Americans hold Canadian passports. So what? Doesn’t make them any less a citizen.
A little birdie is telling me that the birthers who insist on hijacking every Cruz thread with this nonsense are going to start falling by the wayside. If FR is not their cup of tea they should start looking for a new home.
What drugs am I on again?
Nothing you say can be trusted.
Wouldn’t accusing another Freeper of being on drugs be considered a ‘malicious lie’?
America needs Cruz Control.
What drugs am I on again? You said I was on drugs!
Asking a question isn't an accusation.
“Millions of natural born Americans hold Canadian passports. So what?”
What difference does it make???
The CATO Institute seems to think so. Mark Levin agrees. The Heritage Foundation loves him as does the Federalist Society. These people are all constitutional scholars with experience at the Supreme Court level. I’ll take their word on it over a passel of internet sea lawyers any day of the week, even the lawyer Orly Tate who has scored exactly zero in the slam dunk case against Obama.
CATO Institute: Yes, Ted Cruz Can be President:
By the way, you may wish to do a little research into Cruz’s winning record as Texas Solicitor General. The man knows the constitution and he is a constitutional conservative and he is a winner.
...I said with all due respect......what else do you want?
DITTOS!!!!!! Conservative Needed! Join TP and ramp up the music and make the heads spin!
There are fifty states ... and most hold presidential primaries.
ZERO of the fifty have this “NBC birther” requirement to gain ballot access. And there is NO case law ... no state statutes in ANY of the fifty states.
It doesn’t exist in current law anywhere. So can you see why most everybody considers it to be a fringe novelty subculture political concept? How many states even require a birth certificate for ballot access?
If he were a liberal, he’d probably violate the split loyalty thing.....so that would be totally different. However, your Canadian passport argument is simply pathetic, absurd, and insulting.
“As to his eligibility, I think the questions you raise—which are legitimate concerns—will be settled soon enough, if they have not been already. Lots of folks are saying he is eligible, and it sounds like a strong case can be made for that.”
Cruz is fully qualified.
Of course, I also noticed you could not answer the question, just complain about my approach. Why don’t you grow up, ditch the whiny emotion, and deal with a question you have proven unable to deal with up to this point......
Concerned people are showing their concern.
Concern trolls about the most conservative candidate we have can bite me.
Well, I disgree sir. I think the office is larger than any one man, be it Cruz or Washington. I love the man and I understand very well why you want him as President.
I am sorry, but I cannot, in good conscience, support Cruz as president. There are many fine patriots in this nation who would qualify and would be eligible.
I think you are making a mistake. We are a year out of the midterms and two years out from 2016. Why announce this now? Why push your chips in for something that may never happen and if it does, won’t really be relevant for 2 years?
I confess, I don’t understand it, JR. Why this, why now?
I’m with you, Jim. It’s disheartening to look at the Cruz threads and seeing just about every last one of them becoming a birther thread.
But obviously you know this.
You've proved that by lying and saying he has a Canadian passport. Why should you be believed about ANYTHING?
“If he were a liberal, hed probably violate the split loyalty thing.....so that would be totally different. However, your Canadian passport argument is simply pathetic, absurd, and insulting.”
What’s pathetic or absurd about the argument that the American president ought to be born in America?
And no, I’m not of the opinion that ‘only liberals’ can have divided loyalties. Is that really the standard now, “being a conservative” is enough? That is a very broad, and open to all kinds of abuse.
Do you always label those whom disagree with you as, “being on drugs?”
Ok, please take your disagreement, your good conscience, your concern and your attitude to a site that may appreciate it. We don’t.
You’ll have to scan back and read my latest posts to find the answers as to why. Not going to waste any more time on you.
Live free or die.
4 years ago, this was seen as a problem. Now it’s an opportunity. For team us? Really?!
Catherineofaragon: “This Ted Cruz birther stuff would continue even if an angel came down and affirmed his eligibility.”
If conservatives cannot even discuss these sorts of issues amongst ourselves, what are we going to do when the leftist media gets involved? We need to present a strong case.
For the record, I like Senator Cruz quite a bit. I do agree with the FReeper who said Cruz has very little executive experience. If I had to choose between someone weak on conservative ideology but strong on executive experience, versus someone who was solidly conservative with little experience, I’d probably go with the latter. Nevertheless, it’s reasonable to acknowledge the lack of experience.
The same thing goes with Cruz’s citizenship. He makes the point that he was brought here at four years of age, and America is all he’s ever known. Illegal alien dreamers like to make the same point. It’s hardly relevant to whether one is a natural born American citizen or not.
Jim Robinson makes the point that Senator Cruz was an American at birth even though he wasn’t born in the USA. That’s a reasonable point. Does “natural born” mean something different than American by birth, i.e. not naturalized?
So glad you asked. First, I never said THAT was a pathetic argument. What I said was pathetic was your reasoning on why Cruz didn't fit the bill as NBC. Two related, but not specifically the same, arguments.
Second, you aggrandizing of an accident of birth is unnerving and illogical. There are many people born in America who hate it, and plenty who were born elsewere who love it. By your absurd notion, we should choose the former over the latter if it comes down to that, which, by damn, it just might.
You know, folks like say .... Senator Rick Santorum (although it apparently wasn't necessary for Senator Santorum to remain in the Senate back then - for the good of the country).
And he's banned.
You would think if he was going to lie, he’d at least make up something that makes a damned bit of difference.
the term “natural born” means that one is an American citizen at birth, as opposed to “naturalized”, indicating that citizenship was granted after birth.
Is a child born of an American mother not a citizen of the U.S.? If not, what are the “disqualifying” circumstances?
I suspect some posters don’t know their ass from a hole in the ground when it comes to the actual law and the constitution but they have so much invested emotionally in the crackpot birther conspiracy theory that they’re caught in a trap of their own making. Gonna have to chew their own leg off to get free.
I hope he listens to our pleas!
keeping Cruz in the Senate for the good of the country is not a bad argument, but that does not excuse the absurd and bureacratically smarmy technocratic arguments being made against Cruz by some. Its a totally different, and valid, discussion.
Personally, I like Cruz more than any other possible at this early time, but I am far more focused on two other things: A: the 2014 mid terms and B: the horror of so many so called conservatives ignoring clear original intent and getting caught up in technicalities and divining very circumspect intent to prove how much more of a purist they are. Pharisees of our time....
Speculation on future..
Further information: United States presidential election, 2016 On March 14, 2013, Cruz gave the keynote speech at the 2013 Conservative Political Action Conference in Washington DC. He came in tied for 7th place in the 2013 CPAC straw poll on March 16, winning 4% of the votes cast.
Cruz planned several speaking events for the summer of 2013 across Iowa, New Hampshire and South Carolina which are early primary states, leading to speculation that he was laying the groundwork for a run for President in 2016.
As Cruz was born in Canada, various commentators from the Austin American-Statesman and the Los Angeles Times, right after Cruz defeated Texas Lieutenant Governor David Dewhurst for the Republican nomination for U.S. Senate in July 2012, began raising questions about whether Cruz is a natural-born citizen eligible to run for the office of President of the United States. The majority of legal and historical opinion has been that he would be eligible given that he was a U.S. citizen at birth as his mother was a U.S. citizen who lived in the U.S. for more than 10 years. On August 19, 2013, Cruz said he does not believe he has Canadian citizenship and would renounce any that he might have.
They need to get over that stuff!
I think we should be able to discuss the issue politely. That said, do you have any evidence that Senator Cruz has or had a Canadian passport or took any action at any time that shows he intended to claim or use his rights as a Canadian citizen? If so, please present it.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.