Skip to comments.Germany's Energy Poverty: How Electricity Became a Luxury Good
Posted on 09/06/2013 6:53:43 PM PDT by neverdem
Germany's agressive and reckless expansion of wind and solar power has come with a hefty pricetag for consumers, and the costs often fall disproportionately on the poor. Government advisors are calling for a completely new start.
If you want to do something big, you have to start small. That's something German Environment Minister Peter Altmaier knows all too well. The politician, a member of the center-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU), has put together a manual of practical tips on how everyone can make small, everyday contributions to the shift away from nuclear power and toward green energy. The so-called Energiewende, or energy revolution, is Chancellor Angela Merkel's project of the century.
"Join in and start today," Altmaier writes in the introduction. He then turns to such everyday activities as baking and cooking. "Avoid preheating and utilize residual heat," Altmaier advises. TV viewers can also save a lot of electricity, albeit at the expense of picture quality. "For instance, you can reduce brightness and contrast," his booklet suggests.
Altmaier and others are on a mission to help people save money on their electricity bills, because they're about to receive some bad news. The government predicts that the renewable energy surcharge added to every consumer's electricity bill will increase from 5.3 cents today to between 6.2 and 6.5 cents per kilowatt hour -- a 20-percent price hike.
German consumers already pay the highest electricity prices in Europe. But because the government is failing to get the costs of its new energy policy under control, rising prices are already on the horizon. Electricity is becoming a luxury good in Germany, and one of the country's most important future-oriented projects is acutely at risk.
After the Fukushima nuclear accident in Japan two and a half years ago, Merkel quickly decided to begin phasing out...
(Excerpt) Read more at spiegel.de ...
Coming to a United States of America near you, courtesy of the ObamaBot Flat Earth Society
Resistance is not futile. But you have to actually resist.
― Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Should be required reading......
The article makes no mention of just what they are now, but in 2010 they were 30 cents per KWH. Add in the rate increases and it goes over $0.36 per KWH.
We pay $0.117 in rural CO, an outrageous price already.
Without the environazis ( and there are a few Freeper enviro-nazis too, you know who you are) it would be half, or about 5 cents per KWH.
Germany's rates, 3x ours, is where the environazi's (including the Freepers aforementioned) are taking all of us.
Mentally, triple your electric bill, see where that gets you.
Very sobering quote. More so because succeeding generations seem to have learned little from this. Or in the case of Americans, nothing.
Thanks for posting it again.
While it hurst individuals, many people don't see it as an undue burden because they can pay the bills. But there are whole classes of industries that are very energy dependent, and cannot move into an area with high energy prices. The jobs go elsewhere. Even industries like data centers are extremely rate dependent.
Of course its coming here.
Obama made that clear way back in 2008.
Why don’t the voters turn these wind/solar power whacko politicians out?? You know, why don’t they vote with their.....vote?
I love your quote.
“For instance, you can reduce brightness and contrast,” his booklet suggests.”
Liberal technocrats are the same worldwide - they should not be allowed to become involved with anything more “technical” than a paper clip. This statement is almost fantastically stupid.
Generally, utilities give businesses, particularly large ones, better rates than homeowners. Germany, at this point probably being more industrial than the US, couldn’t survive at the rates shown. I wonder what the disparity is between business rates and homeowner rates there as opposed to here.
left-wing quotes usually are...
welfare is good for the economy - Pelosi
and what was that gem from DWS the other day??
Recently saw a picture of a German wind farm with 30 plus or minus wind turbines within sight of a nuclear plant. It made me wonder if the turbines were there to replace the nuclear plant or if the plant was maintained in order to have power after the turbines failed? Cost efficiency be damned, we go forward with the green agenda, but not without other sacrifices in our lives.
thanks for the details. Incredibly stupid of Germany to shut down their nukes.
Yes, I didn't even bring nuclear into my equations.
Pure, safe nuclear, without enviro-nazis interference, would be well under $0.04, 10% of what Germany is going to be paying, 1/3 of what we pay now.
What was that movie, "The China Syndrome"? Few people realize that they are still paying for that movie every month in the form of higher electric bills.
I guess we should be thankful, 20,000,000 people have already been required to pay for the book, The Silent Spring by Rachel Carlson, with their lives.
Unfortunately, it’s already here. In the Chicago area, we have the first certified passive house. It’s a building that’s 10 times more airtight than code. It uses a ductless heat pump system and an energy recovery ventilation unit that brings in outside air turning over the volume of the house every three hours. In addition, it has a solar water heater and a five kilowatt-per-hour photovoltaic array.
The problem with the description above is that it doesn’t mention the exact indoor temperature especially on a warm July day. Also, a heat pump in the Chicago area seems insufficient for those really cold Chicago winter days. The architect, Brandon Weiss, who worked in Germany, has really sold a lot of folks on this nonsense. But what do I know? I’m just a local architect and contractor.
Local governments have really jumped on the bandwagon. Cook County now requires the recycling of at least 70% construction waste.
I’ve lived in Germany off and on for twenty years....so I can tell this story in a simplified way.
In the 1970s...along came the Greens and the environmentalists. In the beginning...they rarely got any platform space in newspapers, magazines, or TV journalism. By the 1990s, that had changed and they used their platforms to hustle and scare folks.
There aren’t alot of nuclear power plants in Germany. None have been built since the 1980s, and the current plan....enthusiastically rejoiced by the bulk of the public after the Japanese disaster...will shut down within the next fifteen years.
In the weeks after Japan’s episode, they milked the system as much as they could....convincing everyone of the terrible nature of nuke power. The conservative party backed itself into the corner and just said they’d make it the national agenda.
Power companies over the past decade in Germany have looked at the future. It’s screwed up. Between regulation, lack of nuke power, and confusing politics....there’s only one answer. Dump as much electrical power ability within Germany, and move out to border states. They are helping to make wind and solar power for the moment look great. Course, locals are now a bit hostile over the ever-growing windmill situation. You drive from Kaiserslautern to Mainz, and there’s around three hundred of these windmills across the countryside.
The gut feeling by 2030? As the nuke plants shut down, and more power has to be bought from outside sources....the prices will double within a short period of time (maybe less than five years). The power companies will have guessed right, and France, Poland, and Czech will benefit from taxing the power that is sold to the Germans. Everyone benefits...except the Germans. But they will be happy not to have dangerous nuke power....like those Japanese guys.
How will you afford $400 a month for electrical? (without AC, mind you). That’s the curious question in the end. I think the candle market will take off, and guys will be on street corners in the afternoons....selling two or three candles to make it through the evening. Silly, but it’s the way of “saving” their precious land.
The difference is: in Germany, the enviro-nazis are actual Nazis.
On the other side of the equation homes constructed in the U.S. are designed to save electricity. And they could be without being horrible in cost or appearance.
I meant “are not”.
An air-to-air heat pump isn't just "insufficient" on cold winter days, it will usually produce ZERO heat. In order to produce heat, the heat pump evaporator temperature must always be lower than air temperature. When the evaporator temperature is at the "dew Point" ("frost point" when below freezing), it simply clogs up with frost and produces no heat at all. This is almost all the time on cold, humid days.
You can’t blame the movie for being right. Westinghouse and GE insisted on using technology that is capable of melting down, when far safer technologies such as pebble bed and molten salt were and are still available. Then Jimmah Carter decided to stockpile partially used fuel instead of reprocessing and voila, a radioactive cluster***.
Nuclear power is a corrupt idiocracy that has in effect destroyed itself by lobbying for the least safe, most illogical approach.
There is nothing I would like to see more than a nuclear driven economy, but with the low-information President and Washington palm greasing machine it just ain’t gonna happen.
“Even industries like data centers are extremely rate dependent.”
You didn’t get the point. Electricity for comercial use is cheap in Germany. Consumer prices for energy are going thru the roof only. It’s quite complicated, but i’ll try to explain:
The large investments for green energy have to get paid by someone. So the state subsidizes these investments. Therefore large investments cause large subsidies. The problem in the case of germany are the subsidies. But in the end it’s a no brainer to understand why this model won’t work.
1) The whole european network is intermeshed and all countries in europe have free trade.
2) German grid operators have to prefer green energy by law in their networks and have to buy it at a high fixed rate. To make investments in green energy attractive. The grid operators get the difference in between the energy stock price and the fixed rate refunded by a government operated fond/pool. Due the volatile character of green energy, this forces conventional energy producers to lower their production on demand.
2) Operators of conventional power plants are forced by law to keep their capacities for network stability. That means that huge power plants are forced into a standby role. To reduce the costs of spare capacities, conventional power plants flood the EU market outside Germany on the energy spot market with their capacities when not needed. This largely reduces the stock price on energy in entire europe.
3) The government pool/fond is filled by a tax on energy called “Energieumlage”. Commercial energy consumers are largely exempted from this tax. So only “private” consumers have to pay this tax.
The more green energy is produced in germany, the lower the price on energy stockmarket in europe gets. This lower stock price raises the gap between the fixed rate for green producers and causes a higher energy tax.
Higher energy prices for german “private” consumers. Lower energy prices for business and all over Europe ! The german taxpayer now subsidizes also his french neighbors electricity bill.
“Its a building thats 10 times more airtight than code.”
But...the first time someone farts in the house during football season after Polish sausage, pizza, and beer during a Bears game, there will be casualties.
This is why either the TEA Party takes over the GOP or the GOP dies and a new party rises. There are issue after issue that the GOP can capitalize on, but they don’t.
We should be skimming a significant portion of the urban vote, but it goes nearly all Democrat.
I wonder if the Clintons’ are still using the FBI files of long ago or if the NSA, like the IRS and the entire government apparatus, is simply an extension of the DNC.
Who knows what information they hold. The Obama Administration was aware from the beginning that they were radicals with a radically anti-American agenda. They came expecting a revolution and the GOP came expecting business as usual.
We need smart street fighting politicians who get it and will go to the mat with it. Not Lifers in loafers.
This cycle it’s been Rand and Cruz on the national level with a host of solid GOP governors and statehouses leading the charge at the state and local level.
The battle between the seen and the unseen continues unabated. We’re always shown just half the accounting.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.