Skip to comments.GOP Rep Blasts CNN Anchor: 'Are You Here to Give Us a Tirade?'
Posted on 09/30/2013 12:12:36 PM PDT by cotton1706
CNN's Ashleigh Banfield scolded two Republican congressmen for bringing the U.S. economy "to the brink," and one of them retorted that she was giving them a "tirade."
"[W]hy connect the funding of the government, the entire U.S. economy, why bring it to this brink? Why not do it at all of the other times? All of the other 100-plus congresses have been able to fund the government," Banfield asked Rep. Dana Rohrabacher (R-Calif.). [Video below the break. Audio here.]
Except not all other congresses have funded the government. There have been 17 government shutdowns and funding gaps since 1976. And Rohrabacher didn't like Banfield blaming Republicans for a possible shutdown.
"[Y]ou're telling your listeners that we Republicans are holding this up, and the government is going to shut down. We have actually reached out to the Democrats with a compromise position," he responded. Banfield answered that she was, in fact, blaming them.
"Congressman, that's not fair. Don't you dare put this back on me," Banfield fired back. "You know full well you attached ObamaCare and defunding it."
"Am I a guest on a news show, or are you here to give us a tirade? Let me finish my sentence," Rohrabacher insisted. "Excuse me, do your listeners understand this is the same thing we're putting up with with the Senate? We offer a compromise, they won't
Below is a transcript of the segment, which aired on Legal View on Septembe 30 at 11:15 a.m. EDT:
ASHLEIGH BANFIELD: I have got another number that you know, it might tickle your fancy, because so many people are so frustrated with what is happening. In fact, the words "spoiled children" come to mind. "Acting like spoiled children in the budget debate," Republicans, 69 percent. Democrats, 58 percent. The President, 47 percent. Whenever you hear about the spoiled children, you don't want to be in any of those percents. And yet, my next two guests are going to have to deal with what Americans are saying.
Representative Dana Rohrabacher, the Republican from California, standing beside Representative Marsha Blackburn, Republican from Tennessee, who's also a member of the House Budget Committee. Thank you both for being on the program today. This cannot be an easy day for you, especially when you just heard what John King was laying out in the polls and you just heard what I laid out with regard to the spoiled children factor. How are you going to weather this? And I will begin with you, Congresswoman Blackburn.
Rep. MARSHA BLACKBURN (R-Tenn.): I think that what we look at is that the American people have repeatedly said they want things to be under control and run by an orderly process in Washington, D.C. We completely agree with that. And that is why we have repeatedly sent options, and possibilities to the Senate. And I'll tell you that I think that the House is as disappointed as the American people that the Senate decided they were going to take off and have a weekend to go to ball games and play golf and things of that nature. We have been here working. We wish they were back in town now and we were addressing this. We agree with the American people. Don't shut the government down. We don't want to. What we want to do is keep it open and keep working to fix some of these programs that have very obvious substantiated problems and glitches like ObamaCare.
BANFIELD: It just sounds so simple when you say it like that, and it reminds me of my time in the Middle East, where both Palestinians and Israelis say we just want peace. But you both want your way, and neither one of you seems to want to blink in this ridiculous staring contest where we're the ones that need the Visine. So Congressman Rorabacher, why the continuing resolution? And for those of us that hate the technical speak, why connect the funding of the government, the entire U.S. economy, why bring it to this brink? Why not do it at all of the other times? All of the other 100-plus congresses have been able to fund the government.
Rep. DANA ROHRABACHER (R-Calif.): Well, have you addressed that to the senate? We have already offered a compromise. You are acting you're telling your listeners that we Republicans are holding this up, and the government is going to shut down. We have actually reached out to the Democrats with a compromise position. We passed it
BANFIELD: Congressman, that's not fair. Don't you dare put this back on me. You know full well no, no. You know full well you attached ObamaCare and defunding it.
BANFIELD: But you can't make something up. You cannot make something up.
ROHRABACHER: Am I a guest on a news show, or are you here to give us a tirade? Let me finish my sentence. Let me finish my sentence.
BANFIELD: You passed a bill back to the Senate saying defund ObamaCare.
ROHRABACHER: Excuse me, do your listeners understand this is the same thing we're putting up with with the Senate? We offer a compromise, they won't even talk to us about it. You won't even talk to us about it. Whose bidding are you doing? We have offered the compromise. We don't like ObamaCare, they like it. We have reached out halfway to them, put on the table a proposal, passed a resolution to keep the government going. They opposed the resolution to keep the government going, and now say that there is no negotiations, we get it all and you get nothing. So and you are blaming us for the shutdown of the government?
BANFIELD: So if you want to know whose bidding I am doing, check my Twitter account after this interview where I invited two Republicans on and not a Democrat, so let's just clear the air right there.
ROHRABACHER: Yeah, but you're not letting us speak. You are cutting me off.
BANFIELD: You said that they were doing this, and I think it's important you can in a moment, Congresswoman it's very important for people to understand what's at stake here. There is a continuing resolution, which is the funding bill, just for the next two months to keep the government going. And the Republicans chose under a lot of pressure Ted Cruz for one in the Senate creating a lot of that pressure to attach defunding ObamaCare which is the law of the land. Why would you attach it, when you knew that this was going to create the problem? Go ahead, Marsha Blackburn.
ROHRABACHER: We came to a compromise.
BLACKBURN: Ashleigh, one of the things that you need to realize and I would hope that your listeners and watchers all realize number one, the House passes a budget every year. We have had a problem with the Senate not passing a budget. That is why we continue to work on a continuing resolution. This year, they did pass a budget, but then they said, okay, House, we are not going the negotiate with you, unless you agree to a tax increase. We weren't going to do that. We want to do tax reform. So thereby we get into this process of the continuing resolution.
Now the biggest part of growth in the budget is health care cost. The American people by overwhelming numbers do not like what is happening with the ObamaCare. So the first continuing resolution we sent had a bill that is carried by Tom Graves in the House, and that was a defunding bill. The Senate rejected that. So we went back into the session, our compromise position that we sent back to them carried a bill that by the way, the amendment passed with bipartisan support, and that is the amendment to simply delay ObamaCare for a year.
The President has already given 1,200 waivers, he has had 19 delays, and they have missed 47 regulatory deadlines on this program. It's not ready. So we have sent that to the Senate, and what we are hearing back is, well, they didn't stay here Saturday, they didn't show up Sunday to take action on it, and so they're going to come back today. So we've offered them a compromise.
BANFIELD: I hear you. We are 12 hours and 38 minutes on our countdown clock. Which by the way, is ticking away right underneath Congressman Rohrabacher's tie. 12 minutes and 38 minutes until a lot of people aren't going to get paid and a lot of things are going to shut down. And it could cost this country $2 billion in just muckety-muckety logistics. So I want to ask you, you are both paid $174,000 a year. That's your salary. Would you be prepared to add some kind of a rider or an amendment onto a continuing resolution that would take you out of the essential services category and stop payment on your paychecks in order to get a continuing resolution through, would you both yes or no? Yes or no. Would you both be prepared to stop your paychecks?
BLACKBURN: We are waiting to see what they send back, and I hope that as you were running the countdown clock that you are running the debt clock. I have got two grandsons. Their share of the national debt is now over $53,000 each.
BANFIELD: No no no. I'm Sorry. I asked a really specific question, I wanted a yes or no question. There are a lot of the government workers that are going to stop receiving their paychecks, and a there are a lot of the military service members who are serving overseas who might stop being paid, and there are veterans whose benefits could be affected. Would you be prepared to take a cut, and lose your paycheck as well?
ROHRABACHER: Let me answer your question specifically. Members of the Congress should not be treated any differently than any other federal employee.
BANFIELD: Is that a yes?
ROHRABACHER: For that to happen, whatever happens to the federal employee should happen to us when it comes to what we get in benefits, whether it is retirement or health care . Whatever happens to the average federal employee should happen to us, that rule should not be changed. The bottom line is we have reached out now to the Senate, when you have that numbers underneath my tie, that should be under Harry Reid's picture, not mine. I have already done my job.
BANFIELD: And it will be. Two o'clock is coming soon. Two o'clock is coming soon.
ROHRABACHER: The Republicans have wanted to compromise. They've said hit the road.
BLACKBURN: And we are working. We are working. We are in session, they are not.
BANFIELD: You are not the only two on the hot seat, but you are both really great to come on with me today. Please fix this mess for the rest of us. We really we like to pay you your big salaries, but we'd like for you to do more and do more negotiating and figure it out. You are like intransigent kids.
BLACKBURN: No, we are not. The House has been working
BANFIELD: All of you.
BLACKBURN: and we wish the Senate would work with us. Get 'em here. Get 'em here with us.
Why, yes. That is, in fact, her exact job description. CNN ‘Fit Thrower’ Extraordinaire.
That’s ASHLEIGH (TALI)BANFIELD
I try not to use harsh words on here but... bitch.
I guess she felt that she could represent the Dems all by herself ...
This is precisely what Republicans need to do more of.
David Gregory did the same thing to Ted Cruz yesterday but Cruz didn't take the bait as it was the wrong moment.
I am sick and tired of the abject partisanship by the corrupt MSM who are auditioning to get a government job in the Obama administration.
The ditzy Ashleigh said this? Unreal!
Banfield is a screeching ignoramus.
As noted on another thread...they are making no pretense of being objective now
This is a full court press to brow beat the Republicans into surrender.
Home stretch for the Commies and their propagandists, the Senate Republicans are hiding behind their desks.
“We really we like to pay you your big salaries, but we’d like for you to do more and do more negotiating and figure it out. You are like intransigent kids.
The ditzy Ashleigh said this? Unreal!”
She has no clue (because she’s never been taught) that this push and pull, this political tension, this separation of power within the legislature is what preserves her and everybody else’s liberty.
Rhetorical question, but it was long overdue. “You won’t compromise” is simply “you won’t surrender to the Democrats”. Now, I’m all for compromise in the matter - how about we fund the government through a Continuing Resolution and the Dems give up on only one single issue, 0bamacare. Oh, that’s been offered twice, has it? Pity.
Rohrabacher and Blackburn seem to have been very respectful and measured in their responses.
Why do republicans continue to talk to Obama’s propagandists?
Why do republicans continue to talk to Obama’s propagandists?
“The GOP is acting like kids” is straight out of the Dem playbook. Literally. Jennifer Granholm tweeted something similar today. The presstitutes got their Dem marching orders and are goosestepping along to them.
Sounds like the MSM is losing it.
“....From a practical perspective, shutdowns usually aren't that big a deal. They happened every year when Jimmy Carter was president, averaging 11 days each. During President Reagan's two terms, there were six shutdowns, typically just one or two days apiece. Deals got cut. Everybody moved on.
In 1995-96, however, shutdowns morphed into political warfare, to the dismay of Republicans who thought they could use them to drag Clinton to the negotiating table on a balanced budget plan...”
This tirade of hers is no different than when Commies put an enemy of the state up on a stage and the crowd jeers, attacks, accuses, and blames the individual for their problems.
I know there is a name for it but I can’t think of it right off the top of my head.
Also known as a “useful idiot.”
Here’s what I was looking for.
STRUGGLE SESSION - A struggle session was a form of public humiliation used by the Communist Party of China in the Mao Zedong era to shape public opinion and to humiliate, persecute, and/or execute political rivals and class enemies. In general, the victim of a struggle session was forced to admit to various crimes before a crowd of people who would verbally and physically abuse the victim until he or she confessed.
During Mao’s rule, the Chinese people were forced to attend many different types of struggle sessions, sometimes consisting of 100,000 people. During the 1950s when Mao’s Government began the Land Reform movement, poorer peasants seized the land from their landlords, who were given the title of exploiting class, and an estimated 2 million landlords were swiftly executed after being subjected to a struggle session.
Because we won!
I'd gather BANFIELD...whomever they are...( NEVER HEARD OF THEM...) makes more than a Congressman.
What a putz!!!
“why bring it to this brink?”
In other words, your preferred policies have FAILED to create a ROBUST economy that would have no issue with continuing to operate on its own without governemtn tinkering?
This is an admission that their policies are not doing anything to strengthen the private sector. They are admitting failure with this talking point!
Another Soldout O’Brien???
Go directly to the American People, stop going to the Leftwing media outlets!
Banfield is a whore for Obama and the rest of the lefties.
Members of the GOP are wasting their time appearing on the Communist News Network.
Dana Rohrabacher has always been a fearless debater. Good to hear his voice again.
All the Republicans need to do is call the Dems and media racists. Until they do that , they will continue to get their asses kicked.
Typical liberal biased media. Seems like the reps did decent holding there own
Date of Birth
29 December 1967, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
In 2004, Banfield married real estate financier Howard Gould, who founded the carbon credit trading company Equator Environmental
I thought Banfield, like the late Petuh Jennings, was Canadian?
- Anyone have a .wav file of Banfield’s “kneepads for Slick Willie” public comment from the Clinton Impeachment days?
Why do Republicans insist on going on Democrat TV channels??
I will never get that.
” The presstitutes got their Dem marching orders and are goosestepping along to them.”
and any that go against the MediaMatters/OFA-approved Current Truth know, by the numerous examples already made, that it means the end of their careers.
Very few are willing to trade the high-life and celebrity for a part-time weekend 3rd-shift dealers job at the local Indian Casino.
Howard Kurtz of The Washington Post reported her as saying of Clinton: "I'd be happy to give him a bl** j** just to thank him for keeping abortion legal."
Two years after their accidental meeting, Ashleigh and Howard were married on July 24, 2004 at the Royal Lake of the Woods Yacht Club. Ashleigh spent much of her childhood at the club, so it seemed like the perfect place to begin life with her husband. The ceremony was performed aboard a custom-built, 85-ft. yacht from the 1930’s named the Grace Anne II.
Her interviews with Arab groups, extremist and otherwise, werent assailed for her performance, but for having taken place at all, as if Americans would rather clap their hands over their ears than listen to disagreeable or different viewpoints.
As a journalist, she told her audience, Im often ostracized just for saying these messages, just for going on television and saying, Heres what the leaders of Hezbollah are telling me, and heres what the Lebanese are telling me, and heres what the Syrians have said about Hezbollah. Like it or lump it, dont shoot the messenger, but invariably the messenger gets shot.
Banfield also decried the way some cable news operators wrap themselves in the American flag and patriotism and go after a certain target demographic, which is very lucrative.
In his book Lapdogs: How the Press Rolled Over for Bush (2006), Eric Boehlert writes, As for American correspondents, there was one who, during the height of the pro-war frenzy in the spring of 2003, stood up and asked serious questions about the MSM [mainstream media] war coverage. And for that, her career came to a screeching halt.
When Banfield returned to television in 2005, as a guest host on Court TV, she was immediately Swift-boated by the past. Somebody called. I wont say what magazine. They called and said, Were doing a story, we had a tip that you sprinkled World Trade Center dust all over yourself to pretend that you were somehow in the midst of the crisis when it happened. I felt sick to my stomach. They said, Were going with the story, we have an unimpeachable source who said they swear they saw you sprinkle yourself with dust in order to inject yourself into the story. It was shocking. Just sickening.
Viewers never knew that Banfield lost two friends in the Trade Center attacks and sought help for post-traumatic stress disorder, whose symptoms include bouts of uncontrollable weeping. People fail to realize that journalists are people, and whoever was caught down there lived through a calamity, she says. The magazine never went through with the story I dont know why but they stirred up a lot of very, very painful emotions, to say the least.
Banfield is the only nonlawyer in truTVs daytime lineup
If I want to be successful in this business, Im going to have to take it on the chin and cope with it. This business is not for the thin-skinned, and I dont know that I have the thickest of skins.
When it comes to this undeclared war the socialist driven media has been waging against American value traditionalists
I’m reminded of the famous quote from a non signator of the Constitution and member of the Virgina delegation. Later elected its governor.. “Peace Peace but there is no peace”.
If the Republican party’s leadership hasn’t realized with the 2012 loss that they had better start unifying including stepping aside as they did during the revolution as Patrick Henry did for the good of the nation, with the various factions called the “tea party” and including them. Our country will be doomed into a disunited mess controlled by Demo-Coms
These exchanges with the media are going to be the main means of political attack that the regime is going to use to split the Republicans from their base which is the “Tea Party” and thereby render it useless.
This exchange is where the subject of CNN complicity to the series of racially motivated murders resulting from their Zimmerman coverage comes into play and used as examples demonstrating not only their mendacity but untrustworthyness to use as information.
I wouldn’t sit down with that bitch for any reason.