The next Republican congress and POTUS should make things abundantly clear to Israel that as soon as they are in office in the US, Israel should immediately take all of Jerusalem. No Paleo owns any property any more in Jerusalem.
Then they need to immediately nationalize all Holy sites in Israel and declare them to be Israeli property, with no other national or religious claims to ownership accepted. And while providing generous lease terms to those who use them, let them know that their use is entirely conditional on good behavior.
If they do both these things immediately, they will have a minimum of two years of Republican support for things to settle down. But they cannot procrastinate, they must act immediately.
Their insurance to the nationalization is that if any state attacks Israel over these claims of ownership, those holy sites may be forfeit. As in bulldozed, if the Israelis choose to do so. And this includes the al-Asqa mosque.
I wish it were that simple. Bush also backed off the claim of making Jerusalem the capital of Israel. The answer is that all Jews must speak with a clear voice on this. No one can stand against that.