Skip to comments.Utah is Ending Homelessness by Giving People Homes
Posted on 01/24/2014 4:01:53 PM PST by Lorianne
In eight years, Utah has quietly reduced homelessness by 78 percent, and is on track to end homelessness by 2015.
How did Utah accomplish this? Simple. Utah solved homelessness by giving people homes. In 2005, Utah figured out that the annual cost of E.R. visits and jail stays for homeless people was about $16,670 per person, compared to $11,000 to provide each homeless person with an apartment and a social worker. So, the state began giving away apartments, with no strings attached. Each participant in Utahs Housing First program also gets a caseworker to help them become self-sufficient, but they keep the apartment even if they fail. The program has been so successful that other states are hoping to achieve similar results with programs modeled on Utahs.
It sounds like Utah borrowed a page from Homes Not Handcuffs, the 2009 report by The National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty and The National Coalition for the Homeless. Using a 2004 survey and anecdotal evidence from activists, the report concluded that permanent housing for the homeless is cheaper than criminalization. Housing is not only more human, its economical.
(Excerpt) Read more at nationofchange.org ...
I had a look at Jon Huntsman’s facebook page a few weeks back and he was promoting himself as a hero.
What about homeless illegals? Do they self deport them into another state or deport them home?
California’s Gov. Brown probably planted the story, looking to lose some losers to Utah.
Maybe the Libs can come up with a different name instead of “homelessness” - like George Carlin said “Everybody has a home. You just need a house to put it in” ...
Smells of BS to me.
I doubt it. Highly doubt it.
M.H.: More Housing or Moral Hazard?
Because once they have an apartment, they'll NEVER commit a crime or need to go to the hospital! [facepalm]
Where do I sign up?
What is the social worker for? Since there is "no strings attached" these people can deal drugs and traffick kids for sex and not have to worry about being evicted.
They provide employment for much of the SLC PD.
Well there have been stories for years about State’s paying the transportation costs to move their homeless to warmer States during the winter (Florida and Hawaii typically get a surge of homeless in the winter months). So whether the homeless themselves are making these decisions or government agencies are, it seems logical for homeless people to relocate to where there are more free services.
Exactly. Utah is a beautiful State. I wouldn’t mind a free apartment there!
Homelessness due to schizophrenia and/or substance abuse cannot be corrected by giving someone a home.
I would love to live in a teepee or a yurt. But for now I have to live in this darned house (my cats won’t move).
Yes, I’d like $1000 on Section 8 Housing Alex...
I wish all you people moving to Utah well.
I lived in Utah for almost a decade, never could afford a real home there. Always paid rent.
Never even got unemployment from that state when seasonally laid off.
Sure would be nice if the Twelve Apostles would ring me up and give me a nice house in Cottonwood Heights.
Ever see how people treat “free” homes?
So the assumption is that if they have an apartment they won’t have any ER visits and not ever commit a crime to go to jail?
I think Utah will soon be paying for all three and end up costing twice as much as they were saving.
If it does exist, this must be some kind of misguided “program” pushed by the LIBs up in SLC near the university. LIBs...Squash them like bugs.
San Francisco could share their experience with attracting the homeless, if you’d like.
provide each homeless person with an apartment and a social worker
Hmmm what does the social worker look like,might take them up on the free offer.
I want to hear what has happened to all these “homes” two years from now.
Well, technically, if you give someone a home they are no longer homeless. So, I guess you can solve a lot of homelessness by doing this ... if it was financially sustainable for the State to do this
Send them to detroit
Kudos to Utah for taking care of its homeless!
I don’t know how Utah financed this project, possibly federal funds involved, but the states uniquely have the government power to tax and spend for such things, such powers protected by the 10th Amendment.
On the other hand, the states have never delegated to Congress, via the Constitution, the specific power to tax and spend on behalf of the homeless, Congress’s power to lay taxes limited to the specific powers that the states have delegated to it via the Constitution. In other words, you will not find the terms poor, poverty, homeless in the Constitution.
Probably the main reason that corrupt federal lawmakers tax and spend on behalf of the poor is to win votes from economically struggling voters who likely have never been taught about the federal government’s constitutionally limited powers.
I’m guessing that they inflated their “homeless” numbers to include responsible law-abiding families who were in some kind of transition during temporary economic hardship. Those kinds of people would benefit from “a home” but are not the people most of us think of when we consider the “homeless” problem — but most importantly it would APPEAR that a large percentage were helped. A lot of this comes from the liberals’ never ending bastardization of the English language.
Almost every week. Absolutely no pride in “ownership”.
If you are homeless, they give you a house.
They never consider the practical reality of why you don't have a home.
Liberals are mostly professors and theoreticians and unicorn lovers. Practical issues are beside the point.
Being right is all about the classroom and research. And the world of pretend.
What is amazing is that when one generation of liberals dies without proof...another generation of fools is born to replace them.
Dont Worry . . . Be Happy.
Who pays for the utilities, groceries and transportation? Or is that also “free?”
I have to pay my own bills. I’d love to be where I can live my life without having to figure out how to make ends meet.
It sounds too good to be true. Its like winning the lottery and ka-ching, one goes from rags to riches overnight.
Ohh tell the Somalis there is FREE HOUSING in Utah! Get ready for the rush!
The program doesn't have to be run stupidly, and it doesn't have to be automatic for everyone.
I think its a very good idea. First things, first, get them off the streets and out of jails and shelters.
The sheer cost alone - of tax money down the drain - of the present methods is a thundering support of this strategy.
Sometimes you have to deal with problems one step at a time. I think this is the right first step - at least conceptually. But like anything else, it has to be run right.
I know, I know, what, anywhere, is run right by the government? Still, what we now do is an abject failure.
“What about homeless illegals? Do they self deport them into another state or deport them home?”
Well the Mormon Church has been at the forefront of bringing “our Hispanic brethren” here from Mexico and points south. The home my grandparents owned in Provo Utah 30 years ago now houses five (5) non-English speaking Hispanic families. Isn’ that just wonderful. And here I though California had the lock on Hispanic immigration! It’s a disgrace and the Mormons and the Catholics are in cahoots to bring Mexico into our country whether we like it or not.
My thought exactly. In human nature, there's usually an inverse relationship between the effort expended in acquiring an item of value and the degree to which the recipient foists responsibility for the item onto others.
I'd say that two years from now, those homes will be judged uninhabitable and condemned.
They’d best get ready for the stampede of the other half of the deposed middle class then. The remainder of them will be unemployed and along shortly.
fail, you are rewarded.
succeed, and your success is legally confiscated from you to give to those who fail.
liberal solutons like this are why we can’t have open immigration - ie letting in anyone who wants to come here. we can’t fund this kind of crap.
we can’t pay our normal bills. states are billions to trillions in debt, and fedgov is massive trillions in debt.
“What is to keep homeless people from all over moving there and getting a free apartment?
For the sake of the rest of the country, hopefully nothing. LOL “
Somebody send this to the governor of Maine. He wants to get rid of his Somalis who are notorious for finding the best handouts.
Well that comment flipped my switch. We completed our dream home during the real-estate crash and during that fiasco got stuck holding our first house (not worth what we owed etc. etc.) Around that time a family we knew were foreclosed on and needed a place to live -- mother and father and two teenage girls. So we put several thousand into the old place on new paint, carpet and I sacrificed a couple weeks of my free time doing small repairs to make the place nearly new for them. We then rented it to them for several hundred a month less than the going rate for that sized house. It was meant to be a stop-gap until they got on their feet again. Three years later they were still there with no sign of ever leaving.
When I heard the market was back up and that we could actually pocket a few bucks if we sold that house we gave them notice and instead of 30 days said they could take 60 days. They took over 120 days to move out and when I got the keys I was floored at how filthy the place was. No bashed in walls or anything stolen, but grease and dirt everywhere, filthy tile grout, disgusting refrigerator, shower scum that needed a paint scraper, a self-cleaning oven that hadn't been cleaned in three years, etc. etc. He promised that in place of the discounted rent he'd take care of the landscaping -- nope. Vines grew out of control and destroyed my custom back fence. Trees overgrown to the point where the back lawn had shriveled up from lack of sunlight, dog-chewed doors and door frames where dry rot had set in, Destroyed screens and screen doors, and the back lawn turned into a cratered minefield from their pet rabbits, garage concrete that reeked of animal urine, badly oil-stained driveway etc. etc.. It took me three months and several thousand dollars in materials to get it right doing all the labor myself. And after all that they went around telling mutual friends how selfish we were for not giving them their $1000 deposit back.
Nope, there are some people who are just incapable of owning a home or taking care of things. The government can give away all the houses they want. In a couple of years those free house will be wrecked and unlivable. Count on it.
Sure. And the rising taxes on the few people left working will drive them to homelessness too.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.