Skip to comments.Zimmerman tries to profit from Trayvon Martin slaying with painting; AP demands halt to sale
Posted on 01/25/2014 4:17:51 AM PST by don-o
ORLANDO, Fla. The Associated Press has demanded that George Zimmerman halt the sale of one of his paintings because the news agency says it directly copies an AP photo.
(Excerpt) Read more at johnsoncitypress.com ...
How many pixels in a picture have to be different before there is no infringement?
He should countersue them
for their knowingly-false abominable “reports”
of “news” -— which were libel against him.
Good question. They would have to prove that it indeed their copyright image.
iirc, he is suing several media. AP should be on the list.
The pic shown at the source looks more like a computer generated rendition of the photo that an actual painting.
My Sweet Lord-He’s so fine. Nuff said
Or to put it another way, I’m sure that some AP photographer somewhere has taken a picture of Mount Rushmore. So if I stand in the same spot where the photographer was when he snapped that photo, and I paint what I see, am I violating his copyright?
If I were that guy, I'd change my name to Jorge Carpintero and move to Sedona.
I’m sick of the AP whoring itself to advance commie bs. Covering Obama and his misuse of the “Bully Pulpit” to divide this country. Not “sourcing” publication but did this AP story have a by-line ? Who wrote this diatribe ?
Zimmerman tries to profit from Trayvon Martin slaying............................... Like Sybrina Fulton??? Maybe George should trade mark his name too?
All the Zimmeister has to do is declare painting a parody and he’s covered.
Did they sue that punk who made the “Hope” image of the Clown?
Why can’t he just say it is a PARODY of their image, like satirists do with songs...or like costume shops do with “purple dinosaur” outfits (so they don’t have to pay “Barney” copyright fees)?
beat my question by two posts. :) congrats.
I’m surprised he doesn’t have a signature model LC9.
George Zimmerman was handed a buttload of lemons by the
state and feds. Nice to see him making lemonade. He needs
to countersue AP for malicious conduct and threats.
The image he is selling is not a copy by ANY definition
of the word. It’s an original work based on an image that
AP published for the world to see. This is just more
persecution by the media at the behest of Holder and the rest of the criminals in Washington. He needs to sue the
living bejeebers out of AP.
My understanding was that you can create a painting of anything and the original painting does not violate a copyright. You only get in trouble if you mass produce copies. Zimmerman’s painting looks like enough of a departure from the original image that he shouldn’t have a problem anyway...shades of Warhol.
Great minds think alike!
This is totally ridiculous — AP is just going after Zimmerman, just to have a reason to attack him.
Zimmerman sat through his own trial and saw the prosecutor.
<>Here is how to thoroughly refute the APs case against GZ<>
Thanks for pointing that out — at 1:19 here:
George needs to call AP’s bluff —
George Zimmerman, unlike Fulton, is deeply in debt. I would not call this profiting.
Actually, George Zimmerman would be very wise to copyright his name and image. Lots of sports stars and other celebrities do so. His copyright would also be set in concrete if he gave limited permission in writing for their use by those he liked, as well as selling them for a nominal sum, $1, to several people.
And this is fair warning to anyone who gets thrust into the spotlight. Get your name and image copyrighted immediately, as it will make it much harder for scoundrels to abuse you.
Um, wouldn’t this make most of Andy Warhol’s paintings illegal?
Zimmerman is suing NBC, I think it was, for broadcasting a version of the nonemergency phone call in which an answer and then a different question were omitted to put a racial slur in his mouth. Well and good, but he is only suing for $2 million, which in context is a poultry amount. Poultry? Dont you mean paltry? No, I mean poultry - its chicken feed!
And, as you suggest, the real problem is not a single news outlet but the entire system of news publishing - which means the AP, but also the membership of the AP individually. Joint and several liability. NBC wouldnt have done what it did without the support and instigation of all the others - it was far to blatant for an individual publisher to undertake if it werent for the everyone is doing it pseudo defense.
But when you recognize that all the news outlets are - via the AP - in cahoots, that is no defense at all. The AP and its membership really should be defendants in a civil RICO suit, because the libeling of the middle class in America is what the AP and its membership, jointly and severally, do. If it isnt Zimmerman, its the Duke Lacrosse Team, or the Swiftboat vets, or somebody. And the fact that the Democratic Party goes along and gets along is no excuse, it just makes it that much more egregious.
I’m betting if the little kittle thugs’ family did the same there wouldn’t be a word!!!
Artist Shepard Fairey got in a legal dispute with the AP after he used an AP photo in his famous Barack Obama "HOPE" poster. Fairey sued the AP in an effort to get a court declaration that he did not violate AP's copyrights when he made the Obama image. The AP countersued, saying the uncredited, uncompensated use of its picture both violated copyright laws and was a threat to journalism.
Claims between the news agency and Fairey were settled in 2011, with Fairey agreeing to pay the AP $1.6 million.
It’s as if I could take a picture of the Empire State Building and thereafter no one could produce a painting of that building from the same angle....it’s ridiculous.
n the News/Activism forum, on a thread titled Zimmerman tries to profit from Trayvon Martin slaying with painting; AP demands halt to sale, don-o wrote: to my question about a by-line (author of diatribe)
“No byline” .
Seen the earlier announcement posted here in FRs. Just read the heads which wasn’t so inflamatory Probably added to by the publication...
Yes, their is no way GZ painted that pic with a real brush. He separated it into three levels and assigned three shades of orange to them. Could be done in 2 minutes max. There are even places online that will do it for you instantly for free. Some artist! Lazy effer.
here is another ap suit
You have stated it well.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.