Skip to comments.Student Suspended for Taking Razor From Classmate (Who Was Self-Harming)
Posted on 03/20/2014 11:55:06 AM PDT by nickcarraway
We teach kids that honesty is the best policy, but at one Virginia Beach middle school it might be better to keep the truth to yourself.
Last Thursday at Bayside Middle School, sixth grader Adrionna Harris came to the aide of a classmate who was cutting his arm. She faces expulsion for taking a razor from the student, throwing it away and convincing him what he was doing wasnt right. She thought she was doing the right thing, so on Friday she told the school administration what happened. The way school officials responded led to this question: was the schools zero tolerance policy taken too far?
Instead of getting praise from the school administration, Adrionna got a 10 day suspension with recommendation for expulsion. The interesting thing the only reason Adrionna got suspended was because she admitted what happened. The alleged weapon was thrown away, and it was her word alone that led to her suspension.
I was shocked and surprised. I was very shocked that a student would get suspended for saving another child, said Rachael Harris, Adrionnas mother. The school system over-reached absolutely.
The schools own details of the event state Adrionna reported the student had a razor blade. She admitted taking it from the student then throwing the blade away.
I took the razor blade, and then I threw it away immediately I didnt carry it around the school I didnt use it against anyone I threw it away, she told 10 On Your Side.
I felt she did the right thing, said Rachael Harris. Under the circumstances, she thought he would bleed out, as he was cutting himself, and there was no teacher in sight. It was a 911 situation, and there wasnt time to find a teacher.
We asked Adrionna, if she would do the same thing again, knowing she would get suspended for holding the blade.
Even if I got in trouble, it didnt matter because I was helping him I would do it again even if I got suspended, yes, she said.
Most frustrating to the Harris family is they feel like they were ignored none of their calls were returned about the incident until 10 On Your Side got involved. WAVY.com made calls and went to the school. We called school board members, who didnt want to comment, but calls finally came in to the Harris family.
It is amazing. They are listening to us now she should be back in school tomorrow and that would be fair, said Rachael Harris.
Wednesday night, Virginia Beach City Public Schools agreed to do something that makes the Harris family really happy theyve moved Adrionnas suspension hearing, which was supposed to be in ten days, to Thursday.
The Harris family hopes after the hearing, where everything is explained again, that Adrionna will be allowed back to class on Friday or at the latest Monday.
You can count on WAVY.com to keep you updated on what happens.
Government school is child abuse!
That is nuts. This school system needs sued out of existence. And all the administrators sent their pink slips, along with summons.
She should have kept the razor and gotten expelled, instead.
There was a case here a while back where one boy saw another student attack another in the bathroom, and was choking the kid. He broke this up and reported the incident, and got suspended for fighting. Nothing happened to the aggressor because he did not admit to anything.
Kids are being taught how the Transformed America will work.
The school admin is just ticked off that they can’t schedule another 10 days of “seminars” on how to help children who are self-mutilating so they can pat themselves on the back for being sensitive.
“The modern liberal, theres something about his ideology that leads him to invariably and inevitably side with evil over good, wrong over right, the lesser over the better, the ugly over the beautiful, the profane over the profound, and the behaviors that lead to failure over those that lead to success.”
I love how they do all this media stuff about preventing bullying, but at the end of the ay they support it.
Whoever made the decision should be fired, and their boss. but they wont be.
“Government school is child abuse!”
That’s becoming more painfully apparent every day in this nation.
This is a suspension the girl should wear with pride. She did the correct thing. Take the punishment and keep doing what’s right. Begging for “forgiveness” from idiots would be a step in the wrong direction. JMHO
You sit and try to think of just the right comment to these types of instances. About all I can come up with, is that this is 180 degrees against my way of thinking.
The kid should get hazard pay for taking the dangerous device away. Instead they get kicked in the teeth.
These people and their incredible lack of judgement, disqualifies them from being in positions of authority, especially in places where children are involved, and good morals should be being taught to them.
This is gross negligence.
I guess I need to say this again. There is only one reason for “zero tolerance” policies.
When a group of people that have responsibilities (real or implied) are in a position that could perceivable make decisions, they introduce liability. If there is concern that these “decision makers” are not competent, then they invite risk (litigation). The solution is to remove their responsibility to make decisions, thereby mitigating any liability. In this way, an institution can actually fire an employee (union contracts and all that) for violating the policy by “making a logical decision”.
It stands to reason, then, that our government teachers have been classified as incompetent to use good judgement and make good decisions by the very institution that employes them. But they are competent to regurgitate lessons from a book they follow.
And we wonder what is wrong with our public education system in America.
Virginia Beach City Public Schools.........?????
Guess this means in the DC area?????
The sheer mindlessness of this kind of BS depresses me almost to the point of giving up on the human species and moving permanently to the Alaskan Wilderness.
One wonders that given the sheer mindlessness of this incident if it is even true, or is this a joke or a prank or supernatural beings???
Some think humans are millennial descendants of chimpanzees! Are we seeing a reversion???
Believe me, the liberal that made this decision thinks it’s the right one.
Pure liberal idiocy. Stick a fork in us...we’re done.
The message here is to do nothing on your own initiative - ever. Report it to the “government” and wait for them to file a report after it is over. Never, ever, never act on your own or you will be punished by the drone collective.
I’m convinced the east coast (~D.C. and northward) has taken leave of its senses to a greater degree than the west coast. These no-common-sense stories always come from “there”.
So, you should abandon your religion, if the government tells you to.
That is the message but the lesson is to do what is right and then lie to the government. Who would have thougth the middle class would ever need a “no snitching” campaign.
This is nuts.
This really is child abuse....God help Amerika
Once again, so-called academics prove themselves to be the most narrow-minded, rigid and bureaucratic people you will ever meet.
its a paradox, but the times have given it proof.
Maybe Adrionna (or one like her) is the next Patrick Henry, in wait. We need another call to arms: “Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, Give me Liberty, or give me Death!” Unless that part of history has been expunged from their books...
Virginia Beach is 3-4 hours away from DC.
This crap has been going on for a long time. Similar thing happened in the 90’s in my hometown, except that the perp was waving gun around, and the other student talked him into surrendering it. Yep, the peacemaker got suspended (not sure if he was expelled), and the punishment was upheld by the school board.
Fornicate public schools.
The suspended student thought for herself and acted upon her innate morals and ethics. This cannot be allowed in the new and improved liberal fascist States of America. It is verboten to allow drones to think for themselves in the brave new world of the DNC and NEA.
This nation is truly upside-down. It breaks my heart and pisses me off to no end.
I don't think the Left would view its job as done until the students view Government as their religion.
These government school rats operate with impunity in the darkness.
Shine a light on them, let the world know what abuses they heap on the helpless, and they they scurry for cover, backpedaling looking for cover.
How can schools teach critical thinking, when they don’t even apply it to their jobs? Good grief. The “educated” educators are idiots.
Oh, I have not doubt of that. :^)
I agree with you. This girl is a person of real character.
Sue for millions
Any word on the boy and his family?
A wrongful life suit maybe?
She needs a private or home school
She did the right thing, and the school was wrong. The girl must be reinstated, given an apology, and a monetary compensation.
The idiots who did it must be fired without recourse.
This is not zero tolerance. It is stupidity.
That is true.
Every child needs private or home school.
Is that satire?
Critical thinking went out long ago
So what did the school administrators teach the children, keep your mouths shut and watch another child kill themselves or you also will be expelled.
that explains it, it’s dead
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again.....
Government school teachers generally care more about covering their ass and protecting their lucrative pensions than the welfare of the children.
Liberals don’t want ordinary people to be heroes, they want all the heroes to work for the government.
I believe you have nailed the chief reason. Nobody trusts the judgment of the person in charge at the lower levels. Constant policy revisions, forms and procedures are put in place to remove any room for common sense or judgment calls in dealing with students (or any one else for that matter)
I'm aware of one school system that wants its teachers to plan their lessons in 6 minute intervals instead of allowing them the freedom to adjust their teaching to the students' needs or shortcomings in a given area.
I have also seen it at the corporate level with manuals for offices even designating how many inches apart the desks should be separated.
And all of them need to have their names plastered all over the Internet.
If they want anonymity then let them be self employed. As public servants they make public decisions.
Contact a lawyer and get ready to move out of state.
Anti-bully campaigns can be used to promote speech (thought) restrictions and teach kids how to be ruled as opposed to how to be free.
Yeah. Amazing. Simply amazing.
If you just sit and think about this for a minute, I don’t know how anyone with a modicum of intelligence could come up with these actions.
Anyone associated with this (making the rule, interpreting the rule, applying the rule, etc.) is not fit or intelligent enough to sweep street gutters with a hand broom, much less be in contact with children.
This is torch and pitch forks stuff...
Actually, they are being taught THAT the Transformed America will work.
However, it doesn't. It will not because it cannot work.
It has failed every time it has been tried.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.