Skip to comments.The Decline of the African-American family: Racism as an explanation does not hold up
Posted on 03/29/2014 11:02:30 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
Race in America is set against the backdrop of horrible historic realities, minefields few want to cross -- just ask Representative Paul Ryan. But if we are ever to focus on children who, for no fault of their own, are often raised in environments where a stable father is missing, violence is predictable, education is eschewed, drugs are prevalent and dependency threatens freedom; we must stand up and speak facts before another generation of children are lost.
Racism is the normal explanation for the decline of the black family, but that analysis does not hold up. Thomas Sowell has shown that the black family survived centuries of slavery and generations of Jim Crow where most black children grew up in homes with two parents. In fact, when blacks were just one generation out of slavery, the census data of that era showed that slightly higher percentage of black adults had married than had white adults. One would be hard pressed to believe that race issues in America are bigger today they were in the past.
Still others look to socioeconomic discrepancies for difficulties within the black family. Again Sowells research shows that the particular culture or human capital available to a people has often had more influence on their economic level than their existing material wealth, natural resources, or individual geniuses. Even factoring for economic differences and severe social disadvantages, examples of a vibrant black family institution in Americas are too numerous to ignore.
(Excerpt) Read more at americanthinker.com ...
They were doing just fine before LBJ’s Great Society seized the property they owned and rented back to them Soviet style apartments that the government had to give them money to afford. Then the government started paying black women to have children, but only if they weren’t married. It started downhill from there.
When you raise children in single parent homes and the ‘culture’ you promote does not value hard work, marriage, education, and life affirming behavior then what do you expect.
“i’ll take “Who won’t accept responsibility for their own actions for $500, Alex”
The deterioration of the American black family, as well as all other ethnic groups, is a direct result of the implementation and expansion of federally mandated welfare pogroms crafted by leftist, progressive socialists as response to their own interpretation of the plights of those various ethnic groups.
It has really never been about helping anyone. It has ALWAYS been about the fundamental leftist belief that people are not capable of governing themselves or caring for themseleves; but, a few hundred elitists can rule hundreds of millions. It has ALWAYS been about CONTROL.
I got another explanation: The DemoRat Party.
Indeed. The urban youth of the 60s learned to have contempt for the existing black society and to depend on collectivism to raise them up in the world. That meant their dissrepected fathers and grandfathers who had worked at lower jobs to raise them up proper. Work came to mean servitude.
Dimmacrats created the slave economy in the US. The Republican Lincoln freed them from the physical chains, but the dimmacrats still kept them in economic, educational and cultural slavery. Ninetyfive percent of today’s blacks do not comprehend that yet....
Lincoln freed them...LBJ put them back in chains.
I agree that LBJ great society policies destroyed the black family.
And nothing correlates with bad outcomes as strongly as single parent families (not criticizing single moms, but odds are stacked against them).
Glamorizing “thug life” values is also big problem.
And the democrats who run the places they’re at have policies that destroy jobs.
Who is going to be most hurt by immigration reform?
Who is going to be hurt most by huge increases in the minimum wage?
“The Bell Curve” 1994 cites the fact a black women with graduate degrees will nevertheless, statistically, have children out of wedlock.
IOW it is NOT economic, but rather cultural. Blacks are promiscuous. And violent, too. And corrupt too.
Left to run things themselves, you get post-apartheid South Africa, about the most violent country in the world.
It doesn’t accomplish very much to debate nature or nurture. Detroit or Johannesburg, the result is the same.
The acceleration of descent came with the destruction of racial pride--the trashing of "Grandma's" experience based words to her granddaughter, in both the White & Black communities, that was contemporaneous with the Great Society, that you refer to.
You can actually graph the effects statistically from these various mischievous influences. It is tragically demonstrable.
It’s the legacy of welfarism, years of envy, simmering militance, liberation brainwashing, gangs, gangsta’ rap, an irrational, insane, uncontrollable vengeance to get even. It is pop culture’s degradation of black culture, and the left cheering it on like it is a finger in white man’s face. It is decades of public housing and segregation in the name of fair housing and equal opportunity, as envisioned by the left. The important thing is what black people are going to do to correct their horrible situation as opposed to making it worse. Someday someone will have to correct it as a matter of survival.
The left’s motivation doesn’t matter. So what if they sought control or simply thought they were helping? What really matters is their policies are destroying communities, and I’m not only talking about minority ones.
I can’t even blame individuals from becoming dependent on the social welfare state. It’s not easy to do the right thing when one looks around and sees others prosper for doing wrong. It will end badly of course, but the system protects people from making bad choices in the short term.
When it does all come apart, who do you think will be better off? Will it be the welfare mom who is thoroughly dependent on the state or those of us who know how to do things for ourselves?
The exploitation of white guilt for the purposes of creating the Great Society became a way of absolution for the sin of racism. This loose vehicle for reparations made the purpose of the black father irrelevant. With the government, you ride first class. Feminism demonized the father as the cause of your 2nd class position. Liberalism gave the father reason to run from the responsibility of fatherhood. The Commies exploited the failure of the black family as a means to gain power. Hello Jessie Jackson and Al Sharpton, you Marxist whores.
If you hate a race enough you can;
1) Make the males have no economic value through welfare.
2) Make the males move out so that mama can get the money.
3) Pay mama more for each baby.
4) Teach them that their plight is someone else’s fault.
5) Teach them that anyone that tries to rise out of the milieu is a traitor to their race and a sellout.
6) Kill as many of them before they are born as possible through funding of such killing.
I can’t imagine who would hate any race so much as to do that. But there is the plan.
And the people who talk loudest about racism really aren't talking much about the decline of families -- or only very indirectly. Most of the time they just ignore the problem.
Your assertion is proven by statistics.
Here is a recent Townhall article “The War on Poverty Has Made a Difference but the Wrong Kind”. See one of the first charts.
And how does one escape poverty? There’s a proven formulae. 1. Finish high school. 2. Get a job. 3. Get married. 4. Stay married. The government has made all of those impossible for Blacks.
True, it’s near to impossible for a black man to overcome those obstacles.
LBJ is smiling from his grave.
The Welfare State is the explanation. The family doesn’t have to help and support each other when they all are sucking on the public teat.
“The government has made all of those impossible for Blacks.”
BS. Blacks can do it if they want to.
‘BS. Blacks can do it if they want to.”
I come from a long line of hard working, successful peple. Most of them had college educations. Success was assumed. My mother laid books all over for me to stumble across. My parents invested time and love in me. Now, imagine you live with a woman who has kids by a half dozen men. You’ve never met your father. You know nobody who isn’t on welfare. Not only are there no educated role models, the role models you do have include daily drug use. Every person you’ve met has spent time in prison. Your peer group will beat hell out of you if you act white be excelling in school. I only know one black man who escaped that scene. One day he told me that not one person in his family has a key to his house. He said, “they’d steal me blind to support their drug habits.” He has not one person he can depend on in his family. When he had to have somebody take care of him after an operation, it was a couple of us white folks he knew from work. No, it is not easy to escape low expectations.
Swiped from either a poster here or on some newsmedia comments page, about some failed holdup, but succinctly sums it up for the entire class of drones.
“This thuggish behavior is that of a subculture raised on anti-white animosity, envy, and entitlement mentality. It is triggered by black racism and misplaced hatred, instilled and encouraged by a Leftist Hollywood and public school victimist propaganda.
They are often ignored and protected by the liberal news media, Political Correctness and empowered by a corrupt DOJ. They are forgiven by an endless list of affirmative excuses and lowered expectations, glorified beyond recognition by a fawning TV media, the movie screen, and gangsta Rap, which nourishes this descent into tribalism.
This is the new standard, void of personal safety, common decency, and civilized behavior that the Left has forced upon us, and until the politicians and the liberals cast aside their blind obedience to Political Correctness and recognize this behavior for what it is, violent crimes like this - and the reactions like this shop owner - will only escalate in violence and frequency.”
CitizenUSA, you are correct.
I have no doubt that my family is much better prepared to survive the collapse than most of the people in the larger cities.
We are pretty much self sufficient. We hunt and fish, we have gardens, orchards, hand and power tools, all the things that are needed to survive without the common infrastructure.
My fear is that the folks in the cities will be heading this way, as soon as the Twinkies are gone and the EBT card no longer works. That will get ugly, very quickly.
We’ll see. We’ll see.
Stay safe, and stay FRee.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.