Skip to comments.Rahm Emanuel Slanders Supporters of Israel
Posted on 04/30/2014 5:49:05 PM PDT by SJackson
It turns out that American citizens are not allowed to criticize Israel.
Or so says Rahm Emanuel, the mayor of Chicago and former chief of staff to President Barack Obama.
Emanuel was asked his view of the prospects for Israeli-Palestinian peace in an interview appearing in the April 21 issue of The New Republic. He ventured to say that while Israel has a security concern involving geography, geography does not have the same value it did in 1967.
Emanuels strategic notions are highly debatable. Without the territories captured 47 years ago, during the Six-Day War, Israel would be nine miles wide at its midsection. Stripped of the geographical protection of the highlands of Judea and Samaria, Israels security would depend entirely on Arab dictators and terrorists abiding by peace treaties.
But Mayor Emanuel was not content to make dubious assertions about Israels geography and security. He then decided to play the martyr.
The interviewer remarked, Sometimes American politicians cant say things that have already been said in Israel, to which Emanuel replied, You are not allowed to here! Because the Americanwell, for whatever reason, that is a whole different debate.
You are not allowed to here? Could it be that Emanuel never reads the New York Times, and never watches CBS, NBC, ABC, or CNN not to mention dozens of Jewish newspapers where criticism of Israel rules the roost? Of course not. He knows the truth. He perpetuates the canard that Americans are not allowed to criticize Israeli policies because this serves three purposes.
First, it gives critics of Israel a phony martyr status. They can claim to be aggrieved victims who have been unfairly silenced.
Second, it provides an explanation as to why their arguments have not won over the majority of Israelis and American Jews. Of course the real reason that their arguments have not won substantial support is because theyre bad arguments. Their case is based entirely on the publics willingness to ignore constant Palestinian treaty violations, support for terrorism, and anti-Jewish incitement.
Third, its an attempt to delegitimize supporters of Israel. It says that friends of Israel dont play fair, theyre McCarthyites who suppress their opponents.
Rahm Emanuel is probably destined to have a long future in American politics. He is entitled to his opinions, but not to his phony claim of being a suppressed critic of the Jewish State.
Does it matter what Rahm Emanuel says about Israel?
It does. He played an important role in shaping the pro-Arab tilt of the first Obama Administration, and he could very well end up having a hand in Mideast policy in the future. One must assume that he has political ambitions that extend far beyond the municipality of Chicago. Will he next run for U.S. Senator, or perhaps governor of Illinois? Does he dream of running for president one day?
Whatever his future ambitions, Rahm Emanuel has in the meantime injected itself into the debate right now, with his preposterous allegation about tyrannical supporters of Israel.
There are reasonable people on both sides of the debate. There are people on both sides who take a sober-minded look at the facts and reach various conclusions. And then there are the cranks the paranoid fringe element who see pro-Israel lobbyists under every bed. This extremist camp is led by professors John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt, whose 2007 book The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, was a book-length conspiracy theory about the alleged ability of the all-powerful Jewish lobby to twist American policy and suppress debate. The fact that Osama Bin Laden publicly endorsed it tells you all you need to know about the Mearsheimer-Walt book.
Rahm Emanuel is not a hater of Israel. But in falsely claiming that you are not allowed to criticize Israel in the United States, Emanuel has effectively aligned himself with the Mearsheimer-Walt camp. Is that really where he wants to be?
If youd like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
Yes, his position that you can't talk negatively about Israel in the US is an expression of classic antisemitic canards from Jewish control of the media and government to Jews lack of loyalty to anyone but themselves. This doesn't make him an antisemite any more than Kerry's adoption of a classic antisemitic/terrorist canard of Israel's intent to become an apartheid state makes him one.
It's more important to recognize these antisemitic positions have become the mantra of the far left. It's on it's way to becoming the platform not just the far left, but the politically organized left.
Yes, people on the right harbor the same positions. But the right isn't as tolerant of them.
All I know is that I’d feel safer in Israel than in Chicago.
Today J street (Soros) was turned down membership in a group which has 51 member Jewish organizations. J street need a 2/3 vote of 51 and only got 17 votes. J street has backed Abbas and Obama more than BiBi.
So far these 51 organization have not voiced a unified position on Kerry’s BDS and Apartheid remarks.
Me thinks that the little ballerina’s tutu is tu tight.
Cuts off the circulation of blood to his brain, which is located in the middle of his tutu.
This is from a hat ass that was never in the military. Soup on a rope the only weapon he has ever used and then only in the bathhouse with Berry.
“Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations”
After years and years, I still chuckle at that name.
Really, who gives a crap about what this creep says? About anything other than how to scam elections? He’s great at that. I would heartily recommend seeking and obtaining his advice as to how to scam elections. Maybe some ballet moves.
What he has to say about just about anything else is just noise. Why listen to it?
Murder rate of about 2.1/100,000 vs upper teens in Chicago. You would be.
By an extremely wide margin apparently.
Rahm Emanuel’s middle name is Israel, and his father was born in Jerusalem.
None of this matters. Rahm and Ezekiel Emanuel are New World Order clintonites all the way!!!!
A self-hating, atheistic Jew. How pathetic.
The interviewer remarked, Sometimes American politicians cant say things that have already been said in Israel, to which Emanuel replied, You are not allowed to here! Because the Americanwell, for whatever reason, that is a whole different debate.IOW, had he been a prominent Demwit at the time, he'd have contributed to that bigoted screed, "They Dare To Speak Out", alongside such luminaries as "William Fulbright, Philip Klutznick, George Ball, Zbigniew Brzezinski, and the Rev. Jesse Jackson".
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.