Skip to comments.Private Sector Investment of $100 Million Trumps Taxpayer-Funded Bailouts
Posted on 05/25/2014 4:32:08 AM PDT by Kaslin
J.P. Morgan Chases (NYSE: JPM) announcement that it will invest $100 million in Detroit during the next five years exemplifies the critical importance of private sector involvement in spurring an economic renaissance.
The investment is a welcome boost for the Motor City, which still is seeking to restructure its finances through a rare municipal bankruptcy filing. Investment directed at projects that offer a banking company a chance to profit and enhance its long-term business prospects beats taxpayer-funded rescue packages that run the risk of going to politically connected people and projects rather than the ones most likely to develop sustainable businesses and contributing members of society.
The $100 million investment, championed by J.P. Morgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon, will provide:
-$50 million split between two Detroit development projects, Invest Detroit and Capital Impact Partners.
-$25 million to blight-removal activities, such as $5 million for the Detroit Land Bank Authority, $5 million for a Rehab Loan Pilot Program that will help families buy homes through the citys property auction and $1 million to expand the Motor City Mapping survey to create online access to properties in the city.
-$12.5 million in an array of training programs and efforts to help city residents obtain jobs and training.
-$7.5 million to partner with agencies in the city that support small business development.
-$5.5 million to the proposed M-1 Rail project and similar initiatives.
The worlds largest bank is putting its money where it can enhance Detroits appeal as a place to live and to work. It also is aiding in the start-up and sustainability of job-creating small businesses.
Legislators in economically battered Michigan are considering a costly proposal that would devote $350 million during the next 20 years to prop up Detroits underfunded pensions and prevent the sale of artwork from the Detroit Institute of Arts during the citys bankruptcy proceedings. With the states tax dollars precious and scarce, it is hard pressed to fund road improvement projects, among other priorities. Any siphoning off of $350 million to help bailout Detroit from obligations its elected leaders created would be money unavailable to other parts of the state.
The situation also shows that doling out government funding is a zero-sum game in which a limited amount of money is available and lawmakers are put in the awkward position of needing to rob Peter to pay Paul.
Financially strained cities in Michigan extend beyond Detroit and include Flint and Hamtramck, among others.
Detroit, the largest U.S. city ever to file for bankruptcy protection, has been losing population for decades amid the decline of the U.S. auto industry. The citys population has plunged more than 40 percent from its peak of nearly 1.2 million in the 1950s when the domestic auto industry was cruising along comfortably.
American vehicle manufacturers subsequently took on onerous labor contracts that led to huge legacy costs to fund expensive healthcare programs for retirees and family members, hurting the domestic manufacturers in competing with lower-cost foreign rivals.
Detroits July 2013 bankruptcy filing followed decades in which the city paid its bills by borrowing money and struggled to provide basic services. The citys budget deficit is estimated at $380 million and its state-appointed emergency manager said he opted for bankruptcy rather than taking money from police, fire and other services in the face of the citys $18 billion in debts.
Detroit and Flint once provided ample good-paying jobs to blue-collar workers. Now, the cities both have emergency financial managers and the challenge of trying to deliver services to their remaining citizens amid shrinking revenues and the thinning ranks of taxpayers.
Indeed, Flints population fell below 100,000 in 2013 for the first time since the 1920s, the U.S. Census Bureau reported on May 22 in its latest estimate. As populations in cities such as Detroit and Flint shrink, so do the number of taxpayers. And burdensome tax increases further drive residents and businesses into the suburbs or out of state.
The investment by J.P. Morgan Chase is a good step forward for Detroit in preparing to move beyond bankruptcy into a brighter future for its residents and its businesses. It is an investment that governments faced with conflicting demands for resources increasingly cannot afford to pursue. But government leaders can help by adopting policies that attract rather than discourage private sector investment in their communities.
I read recently that GM has a two year supply of unsold Cadillac coups based on the Volt. According to one of my car magazines, under orders from Obama’s handlers, GM shut a plant producing a popular gas model and retooled it to produce 100,000 Volts per year. They’ve rarely sold over 3,000 Volts in any month. They’ve several times shut the plant “for maintenance” to keep down the over-supply.
Money invested by private individuals is usually efficiently invested to obtain profit. Money spent by the government is inefficiently invested for political ends. Therein lies the difference...and, why government should be kept as cash strapped and powerless as possible.
They’ll get a return like Zuckerberg in Newark NJ; nothing (but a huge donation to the Democratic Party).
Why live and work in a place that will only tax one to death?
Detroit had one resource, the auto industry, and when they wised up knowing that their corporations cannot survive in a socialist run govt heavily dependent on tax revenue - plus the exhausting failure of union dues, pensions, and over priced entitlements that unions shell out...they left!
Until the govt. up there changes to a more conservative, business friendly, and capitalist economic and social structure - that city is doomed...
Plus, it has become a “little” Middle Eastern haven chalk full of Islamic immigrants that could care less about working and concern themselves when the next attack on the Great Satan will take place!
$100 million in 5 yrs will just keep the dying patient alive a bit longer...what a waste of money!
First replace every politician with honest officials to insure the money is not stolen and taken by graft.
I understand the anti-GM sentiment here, but America really, really needs to pay attention to keeping and to bringing back American jobs.
Whether they are for GM, Ford or for a foreign manufacturer at an American plant, we all need to support America.
About 35 years ago I worked on Great Lakes ore boats (on the lakes ships are called boats). There were a good number of Arab immigrants from Yemen who worked on these freighters.
They lived in Dearborn, MI. They were to a man hard working and reliable, they never showed up drunk or on drugs.
Still lots of Arab immigrants arriving in the area. Despite the fantasies to the contrary far more are Christan than muslim. Chaldean, Copt, Maronite, Assyrian etc.
Perhaps...the insurgents in Iraq that killed/murdered 17 guys I know never showed up drunk or on.drugs either...it,s there religious beliefs ..not their work ethic that concerns me...
“Money invested by private individuals is usually efficiently invested to obtain profit.” Unless it is crony capital. Check out the “solar power” “investments.” JPMorgan will be reimbursed for its losses. “Detroit has plenty of problems but none that can’t be overcome with a little thought.” “A little thought!?” The entire population of Detroit must be replaced along with the corrupt politicians they vote for. Why not invest this money in Mogadishu? It may be better spent.
A punishable offense, both by Big Government and Big Media.
JPM is going to rue the day they decided to do this.