Posted on 05/30/2014 12:59:22 PM PDT by wagglebee
The “death with dignity” and bioethics crowds grow increasingly extreme. Now, they are pushing starvation.
First, it was removing feeding tubes from the cognitively disabled, slow killing excused as removing medical treatment. Do it to a dog and go to jail. Do it to Terri Schiavo and it’s merely “medical ethics.”
Now, euthanasia types push VSED, e.g. voluntary stop eating and drinking. Not only that, they want nursing homes and hospitals to be forced to starve dementia patients to death who willingly eat.
I’m on the case in my biweekly column over at First Things. From, “Starvation as the New Death with Dignity:”
But what about people who can eat and drink by mouth? Assisted suicide advocates argue that it isn’t fair that they can’t die too. So, activists promote a form of “self-deliverance” that they call “voluntary stopping eating and drinking,” (VSED), by which suicidal people declare their wish to starve to death.
Click here to sign up for daily pro-life news alerts from LifeNews.com
As a matter of respecting autonomy, doctors won’t force feed these suicidal people. Some even agree to facilitate the death by helping palliate the potential agony that can be associated with starving and dehydrating.
I believe a doctor who helps someone starve him or herself to death is akin ethically to one who helps a suicidal person find the artery to cut and guides the scalpel.
A lawsuit was filed to force a nursing home in Canada to starve a dementia patient to death. That lost and is on appeal. But the drive to force medical personnel to starve patients to death who eat, if they so instructed in an advance medical directive, was boosted recently in the Hastings Center Report:
Bioethicist Paul T. Menzel and physician M. Colette Chandler-Cramer create a sophistic argument to justify their conclusion: People have the right to commit VSED; people also have the right to refuse life-sustaining treatment in an advance medical directive; hence, people have the right to order themselves starved to death (commit VSED via advance medical directive).
Here’s the thing: They are called an “advance medical directive,” for a reason–to control medical interventions. But spoon feeding isn’t a “medical treatment!”
Spoon-feeding is considered “humane care”—not the same thing at all. Thus, under Menzel and Chandler-Cramer’s theory, a patient should also be empowered to order the non-medical withholding of other forms of humane care to hasten their deaths.
For example, why not permit a directive to order that blankets be removed during a cold snap to increase the chances of contracting pneumonia? Less certain, to be sure: But basically the same idea.
The advocacy point of the starve-them-to-death campaign should be obvious to all:
Finally, once we can starve patients, even though they willingly eat, the obvious question arises: “Why not just give them lethal injections?”
Actually, I believe that has been the goal all along. The starvation agenda is merely the horrid means intended to lead us to that horrible end.
Culture of death, Wesley? What culture of death?
Death by starvation can take weeks, yet is considered dignified. A convicted felon sentenced to death took 45 minutes to die and it’s considered a crime.
Euthanasia Activists Pushing Starvation as “Death with Dignity”
Assisted Suicide Moves Closer as Government Allows Free Vote [UK]
Belgian doctors looking for disabled patients to be euthanized, donate organs
Organ-donation euthanasia: a growing epidemic
Democrats Crank Up Death Panel Talk Following Obama Win
Cut state funding to terminal patients so they "can die quickly"
Deaf Twins Going Blind Euthanized
Half of those on Liverpool Care Pathway never told.. [ Death by NHS]
Doctor disputes common acceptance of ‘brain death’
UK Hospitals Paid To Put Patients on Death “Pathway”
What Would Hippocrates Do?
Dutch euthanasia: psychiatric and dementia patients killed
Wesley J. Smith: The International Suicide Industry
Quebec government reveals plan to legalize euthanasia and assisted suicide
Socialized medicine: Patients starve and die of thirst on hospital wards
Hippocrates’ Last Stand (Will we stop doctor-prescribed suicide in Massachusetts?)
Assisted dying: who's to decide when a life is not worth living?
Physician-assisted suicide poisons the mission of medicine
What America Would Look Like under Obamacare
Oregon Offers to Pay to Kill, but Not to Treat Cancer Patient
Do No Harm? Should Patients Still Trust Their Doctors?
Mother pleads to doctor to restore son's food and water
Doctor secretly denied 12-year-old trauma victim food and water
BULLCRAP. It’s the DEHYDRATION they are leaving out????? Dehydration turns a human being into a rock. All the blood coagulates to the tongue and every organ in the body dries up - it’s tortuous and they never do starvation without dehydration. SOBs.
Hi, wagglebee. Dehydration is worse than the starvation although together, they accomplish much.
Thanks for the ping! Welcome home, Wagglebee!
Sick.
(((((Thank you for the Ping)))))
You’re very welcome. ; )
From the article:
“..But what about people who can eat and drink by mouth? Assisted suicide advocates argue that it isn’t fair that they can’t die too. So, activists promote a form of “self-deliverance” that they call “voluntary stopping eating and drinking,” (VSED), by which suicidal people declare their wish to starve to death. ..”
“..it isn’t fair that they can’t die too. “ Totally disgusting.
Odd how they advocate for the death by torture of other people, but never for themselves.
I hope Terri’s listers get back together once in a while. There’s no telling what’s going on in DC. We need to stay in touch.
“Odd how they advocate for the death by torture of other people, but never for themselves.”
That’s right.
And I’ll never forget how antilife-for-others Ted Kennedy spent mega $$ so he could live just a little longer.
Well, in Kennedy’s defense, he has added one more day to the string of days he has gone without taking a drink.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.