Skip to comments.Texas may not restore lost abortion clinics despite ruling
Posted on 06/28/2016 8:53:54 AM PDT by Mrs. Don-o
AUSTIN, Texas Long wait times for abortions and lengthy drives to clinics are likely to continue in Texas for months and maybe years despite the U.S. Supreme Court striking down restrictions that since 2013 have drastically reduced the number of providers statewide.
Texas lost more than half of its 41 abortion clinics in the three years since former Republican Gov. Rick Perry signed a sweeping anti-abortion law that justices largely dismantled in a 5-3 ruling Monday. The decision amounted to the Supreme Court's strongest defense of abortion rights in a generation and could imperil similar restrictions in other states.
The Texas laws required doctors who perform abortions to have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals and forced clinics to meet hospital-like standards for outpatient surgery. But even with those mandates now gone, Planned Parenthood and others providers are not yet making promises about breaking ground on new facilities in Texas.
And any openings, they cautioned, could take years, meaning that women in rural Texas counties are still likely to face hours-long drives to abortion clinics for the foreseeable future.
Buildings need to be leased. Staffs need to be hired. Clinics must still obtain state licenses and funds for medical equipment must be raised. Meanwhile, the Republican-controlled Legislature is all but certain to remain hostile to abortion providers that try to expand.
"We really have a daunting task to determine whether and how we can reopen our health centers," said Whole Woman's Health founder Amy Hagstrom Miller, whose chain of abortion clinics in Texas includes the state's only provider on the southern border with Mexico.
Planned Parenthood President Cecile Richards also would not immediately commit to the nation's largest abortion provider opening more Texas clinics, but she expressed hope.
"Just to re-establish services in a community and get the licensures is just not something that is going to happen overnight," said Richards, who is the daughter of former Texas Gov. Ann Richards.
For now, providers are celebrating because it could have been far worse: Had the law that former Democratic state Sen. Wendy Davis once temporarily blocked with an 11-hour filibuster been found constitutional, only 10 would have remained open in a state of 27 million people.
The bill propelled Davis, at the time a state senator who ran for governor in 2014, to national stardom when her filibuster packed the Texas Capitol with raucous protesters whose shouts deafened the Senate floor as time ran out on the measure.
More than 40 abortion clinics in Texas were open at the time, but neither Richards nor abortion rights groups would predict whether Texas would ever reach that number again. Davis said the expectation for now is that areas without a nearby clinic will at least see one reopen within the next six months, and that the goal may not necessarily be getting back above 40 facilities.
"The benchmark is more closely aligned with geographic proximity," Davis said. "If women are able to geographically access that care without tremendous costs or burdensome travel then we'll be back to where we need to be."
Monday's ruling now gives Texas abortion providers the go-ahead to continue offering abortions in smaller facilities that are akin to doctor's offices. Many clinics had faced multimillion-dollar renovations to comply with the law, such as upgrades to air ventilation systems and hallways wide enough to accommodate hospital beds.
Republican Texas Gov. Greg Abbott rebuked the justices for taking away rules that he says protect the health and safety of women, and Republican leaders in states including Michigan, Missouri and Pennsylvania have used similar arguments while enacting nearly identical laws. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, writing in a concurring opinion, said it was "beyond rational belief" that the Texas law looks after women.
The landscape of abortion in Texas changed drastically over the last three years: Most remaining clinics are concentrated around the major cities of Dallas, Houston, Austin and San Antonio, leaving many women in vast rural swaths of the state facing long drives to the nearest provider. The result was that wait times at some Texas abortion clinics started exceeding 20 days, Davis said, while opponents of the law also warned about women seeking out abortions in Mexico instead.
Obama’s administration has set the example for all to follow: Laws means nothing. Supreme Court ruling mean nothing.
I hate what this country has become. May God condemn and destroy this Court for the evil it has done.
I wouldnt either. Eff Obastard and his bands of p@#cks.
Defy em and lets see what they do? What? They gonna take away all those federal gubermint goodies? Good, then escort all the federal agencies the hell out of the state and put up tolls on the borders for the highway systems.
Well, just like Obama said last week following being shot down by SCOTUS on his immigration “Executive Order,” the enforcement policy will not change. It won’t be a priority of his Administration to enforce the immigration laws passed by Congress. So Texas doesn’t have any priority rush to dismantle its abortion restrictions.
God Bless Texas!!!
Yup! Drop all the so-called entitlements, and watch the cockroaches leave the state.
Setting moral and ethical questions aside, this seems eminently reasonable to me. Abortion is an outpatient medical procedure, it should be treated as such.
That "More than Half" of the clinics chose to shut down, rather than adapt the minimum required standards, says all sorts of things, none positive.
But remember, Conservatives - and especially Donald Trump - hate all women. That's the meme, don't stray from it, even when the facts are as plain as day.
The irony is that this ruling will make it legal for a guy with a coat-hanger to provide abortions. Preventing him from doing so would be an “undue burden” on women.
And the babies rejoiced.
The Democrats war against women continues - yet again, they say it is just fine for a surgical center like an abortion clinic to not meet the same standards as any other surgical center, nor have admitting privileges when something goes wrong.
Because these regulations are ‘unfair...’
Meanwhile, lawful gun owners are being entered into the FBI RepBack database which will report back to the local Hawaii police station any encounters with law enforcement, just in case there’s an excuse to seize the weapons.
SCOTUS gave its opinion. Now let them try to enforce it.
I wouldn’t. Let Obama sash shay his little a$$ down to Texas and enforce it himself. Don’t use your human shields, sissy a##...do it yourself, Muslim Sodomite.
I remember one of the talking points used to support abortion early on was that women needed to be able to get an abortion from a competent doctor in a real medical facility. The contrast was made to shoddy doctors in back alley rooms doing illegal abortions.
If standards are not met in abortion clinics comparable to other medial care, then aren’t we legally sanctioning the shoddy doctor in the back alley room?
Next session - make a new law, but different, that again makes it difficult to establish and run these murdering facilities. Get more shut down, resist any new ones starting. So what if they take it to court, again. That process that years. If you lose. Repeat.
Requiring doctors to be doctors is unconstitutional?
How many divisions does SCOTUS have ?
IMHO now is the time for Governor Abbott to channel Andrew Jackson and inform the “supreme court” that as they have made their “ruling” the “supreme court” now needs to enforce their “ruling.” Enough of this legislating from the bench in order to protect made up and fictional Constitutional rights which the “supreme court” made up in the first place. Worse thing that can happen if Governor Abbott stood up for the people of Texas is TEXIT! Now that would be a win-win!
If cities all over this country can refuse to enforce immigration laws by declaring themselves "Sanctuary Cities", then Texas can refuse to obey this ruling.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.