Skip to comments.The Severity of COVID-19 Now Depends on Your State’s Politics
Posted on 08/08/2020 4:57:08 AM PDT by Kaslin
If we have learned anything from the coronavirus, its that science and statistics are now political. What is now considered science is based on the feelings of those using it. While the average American may see little merit in weighing the politics of each state as the world contends with a global pandemic, the media care for nothing else.
Indeed, the media first look at the political affiliation of local officials before evaluating the COVID-19 response success. The media then uses their own bias-based prism for evaluation, ignoring empirical evidence. Their coverage depicts Democrat-run states as logical and resilient, while residents of Republican-led states are portrayed as science-denying troglodytes more concerned with reopening their economy than caring for the sick and immunocompromised.
The narrative-setting took place in real-time on social media, as reporters echoed commentary from their peers with frightening predictability. Democratic leaders are logical and resilient, tireless in their advocacy for their constituents against a hapless Republican president bumbling through a pandemic. Residents in those states, theyd say, happily wear masks because they actually cared about other people and believed in science. Meanwhile, Republican lawmakers represent states whose residents were so desperate to reopen their local economies that theyd endanger the sick and elderly to make it happen. Their constituents are selfish, science-deniers who care not for the common good, but instead, their own comfort and privilege.
To achieve such a narrative, the media ignores empirical evidence demonstrating these preconceptions are false. There is perhaps no greater example than the water-carrying they have done on behalf of Governor Andrew Cuomo (D-NY). Despite accounting for just 6 percent of the U.S. population, New York is responsible for a staggering 1 in 4 coronavirus deaths in America. The media have dutifully excused Governor Cuomos woefully inadequate response a response made worse by the incompetence of New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, who apparently waited longer to sanitize subway cars than he did to keep Hasidic children from playing in city playgrounds.
As merely a victim of President Trumps incompetence, they implied, Governor Cuomo was simply doing the best he could and he could do no wrong at that. After calling the presidents response to coronavirus worse than Watergate, he quipped that No one died in the Watergate scandal, ignoring his own role in the deaths of tens of thousands of at-risk New Yorkers.
When it was uncovered that his decision to cram elderly and sick patients in nursing homes created a petri dish of coronavirus primed to infect the most at-risk New Yorkers and those who cared for them, the press uncritically regurgitated a widely-debunked report from the governors office insisting they werent responsible for nursing home deaths. At least 6,600 nursing home residents died of COVID-19, while 37,500 caregivers contracted coronavirus from serving these patients. If, according to Governor Cuomo, he is not responsible for the decision he made to group in close quarters elderly and sick people who were at the highest risk for contracting and dying from coronavirus, how then is President Trump?
As the narrative of Cuomo victimhood plays out on network television and newspaper stories, so, too, does one about how red states like Florida, Arizona and Texas are seeing COVID-19 spikes due to Republican negligence. Because these states suffered fewer cases than the rest of the country at the height of the pandemic, they opted to begin reopening incrementally and earlier than states who peaked earlier. For the first month or two, this yielded no significant upticks in cases or deaths. But, eventually, cases began to rise.
The media pounced. GOP-led states like Texas, they argued, were out of control, opening too early and allowing people to resume daily activities too quickly. They happily ignored that while positive cases were on the rise due in part to greater testing accessibility, local health care systems arent overwhelmed as they were in New York. In an interview with CNN, Houston Methodist Hospital CEO explained that patients admitted to his acclaimed health care system have been younger with less severe symptoms, stay in the hospital for less time and are far less likely to die from COVID-19. He also says that despite media claims of bed shortages, hospitals are operating at normal capacity.
As of this writing, Texas, home to 29 million people, has fewer than 7,700 coronavirus deaths. New York, with a total population of 19.45 million much smaller than Texas has 32,413. Indeed, Texas has benefitted from increased knowledge, better supply access and greater time to prepare than New York did. But, surely, this does not entirely explain why the Empire State has 420 percent more fatalities than the Lone Star State.
Then, there is Florida, led by Republican Governor Ron DeSantis. In addition to being a popular vacation destination, Floridas 21.48 million residents welcome hundreds of thousands of part-time Floridians each year who own homes in the Sunshine State. At the pandemics peak, this made Florida the next anticipated hotspot.
Yet, it wasnt. To date, Florida has seen 7,401 COVID-19 deaths, despite the state being partly open for the past few months. In fact, Florida accounts for just 4.8 percent of the nations coronavirus deaths, despite being the countrys third most populous state with 27 percent of its population older than 60.
CNN host Chris Cuomo, brother of New Yorks governor, has made it a personal mission to cheer on the coronaviruss spread in Florida in apparent efforts to deflect from criticism of Governor Cuomos COVID-19 response. Can we trust the data from [sic] floridas governor? Cuomo asked on Twitter last week, setting aside journalistic standards of impartiality to imply without evidence that De Santis was misrepresenting the severity of COVID-19 in his state. Perhaps most galling of Cuomos statements was the assertion the White House Coronavirus Task Force chief prais[ed] the gov who mishandled the pandemic, referring to encouraging remarks from Vice President Pence directed toward Florida officials.
Cuomos politically prejudiced criticism is remarkably tone-deaf, given the broad admonition he and his brother endured for their variety show-styled daily interviews on CNN, where the television host provided an open forum for the governor to tout his administrations coronavirus successes and lambast President Trump. Their giggle fest, complete with phony debates over who is their mothers favorite child, happened night after night as tens of thousands of New Yorkers succumbed to the disease, with thousands dying due to overcrowded nursing home exposure at the governors direction.
To the political press, none of this matters. Because far fewer people are dying in conservative states, the media have shifted their focus from the number of deaths to the overall number of cases. This number tells us very little about the current state of the virus, as it doesnt demonstrate the severity or likelihood of death associated with contracting to it. Instead, it simply obscures the human toll in states that fared worse in the pandemic.
Even as late-hit states have voluntarily enacted measures that would roll back some of the reopening and enforce masking in public spaces, the media continue to fan the flames of hysteria, with The Daily Beast characterizing Florida hospitals as being in the thick of New York-level chaos whose health care workers fear the worst is yet to come. Thankfully, COVID-19 in Florida bears little resemblance to New York, whose worst daily death rate was eight times that of Florida, despite having 2 million fewer people.
So far, little mention has been made of how the virus is now spreading to areas that hadnt yet seen widespread transmission. Their outbreaks arent worse and if anything, theyre not as severe and are better managed. Theyre just coming later. The media have also neglected to cover how the states currently experiencing outbreaks are among the hottest in the U.S., driving residents into packed indoor facilities, like bars, to escape the heat. Meanwhile, places that had already experienced their peaks had seen individuals indoors in the colder months, where residents could shield themselves from the cold and snow. From an epidemiological perspective, its clear that densely occupied indoor spaces for long stretches pose the greatest exposure threat, while risks from outdoor activities remain very low. Apparently, the medias hyper-politicized coverage leaves no room for scientific insight reporters should be sharing with the public.
Lawmakers and health officials should still maintain reasonable COVID-19 measures for their states. In places where coronavirus spiked later than others, special care should be paid, especially to those who are older or face health challenges. Coronavirus is serious, and we must heed all public health guidance.
We dont have to buy a media narrative thats meant to disparage entire states simply because of who their elected leaders may be. For the sake of sound public policy, we must educate ourselves not only about how to secure public health, but also on what strong local leadership in a global pandemic really looks like. Unfortunately, that now involves doing our own research, since the media are more interested in protecting their narratives than protecting us.
Cuomo didn’t just send WuFlu patients back to their nursing homes.
He allowed confirmed positive employees to continue working in their facilities until almost the middle of May.
Why isn’t the press talking about that...?
Most elderly people are conservative voters. Gotta ballot-harvest those voters to the correct party once they die.
Really informative article, worth reading every word. The politics is true but I learned much more about the facts of the the various states experiences with Covid. Some of this I already knew, but not the way it was all put together in this article, and much of this I did not know.
Great article. Thanks for posting.
I suspect this had more to do with Medicaid.
I wish someone would take a look at the mortality rates for WuFlu patients in NYS based on insurance carried: Medicare, Medicare/Medicaid dual eligible, and Medicare with MediGap.
I bet those statistics would be very interesting.
Multi faceted plan to rig the election and keep the criminals in power
Mr. President, you should get some folks you trust to run those numbers for you.
I find it annoying that so much of the press, even the conservative press, will go to great lengths to avoid the fact that a large fraction of the late surge in cases is due to migrant farm labor (much of which is illegals).
This disease could have been stopped quickly with much less impact by strict quarantine. Let those areas with no infections live life normally, but stop anyone from leaving areas with community transmission. If this had been done in March, aside from occasionally having to run down clusters from a quarantine breach, the only infections by June would have been in those metro areas where it became a major problem.
There are over 330,000,000 people in the USA-—NOT counting all the illegal invaders.
IF 300,000 are dead by the end of the year from the virus, that is LESS than 1/10th of ONE PERCENT of this population.
ANYONE wish to guess how bad it would have been if Trump & others hadn’t done all that they DID DO???
Of course, that doesn’t factor in protests, and riots, and funerals for sainted martyrs...
“....New York is responsible for a staggering 1 in 4 coronavirus deaths in America. The media have dutifully excused Governor Cuomos woefully inadequate response a response made worse by the incompetence of New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, ....”
SHOCKING and horrible!
Americans need to wake up! This disease should be treated in its 1st phase which is viral replication. There are over 70 studies showing positive results when treated early with HCQ and zinc. https://c19study.com
For elderly and high-risk patients this is a MUST. Why are people being told to go home and wait until they are having problems breathing? By then they are in the 2nd stage of the disease that involves different and more dangerous medications, as well as possible failure of multiple organs, are involved.
When you are diagnosed with a tumor, do they say go home and come back when we have to use radiation because it is too late to remove it with surgury?
Your primary care doctors need to be free to prescribe what has been shown to work freely in an outpatient setting when 1st symptoms show up.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.