Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

The Real Roots of Terror
The Atlantic Monthly ^ | December 5, 2001 | Jack Beatty

Posted on 12/07/2001 12:39:27 PM PST by aculeus

Debate over the causes of the terrorist attacks on America has been inhibited by the fear that to inquire into them is somehow to extenuate evil. So let's substitute "sources" for the morally fraught "causes." Do that, and this becomes clear: All but three of the terrorists, like Bin Laden himself, were from Saudi Arabia; Mohamed Atta, their ringleader, was from Egypt, as is the number two man in al Qaeda, Dr. Ayman al-Zawahiri. Something about these countries helped to produce the terrorists. The terrorists are dead; bin Laden will soon join them. But that something endures. The domestic political arrangements of Egypt and Saudi Arabia should be regarded as among our real enemies in the war on terror.

The regimes in these countries, we know, are repressive, but so are governments throughout the Third World. What is special about the repression in Egypt and Saudi Arabia is that both governments escape its consequences by redirecting popular anger toward the United States. Thomas Friedman, of The New York Times, has written several columns documenting how this works. Through government-sponsored media in Cairo and Saudi support of fundamentalist schools, or madrassas, at home and abroad, these regimes have made anti-Americanism the equivalent of their missing domestic politics. "The terrorists who perpetrated the September 11th attacks were products of a system that allows individuals no room for legitimate political activity and little alternative to the mosques and madrassas that fill their minds with hate," writes Martin Indyk, the former U.S. ambassador to Israel.

Egypt, under threat from Islamic terrorism, has been governed under a state of emergency virtually since 1967. A glance at the Human Rights Watch report on Egypt for last year reveals a political tourniquet: suspects arrested and held without being charged, dissidents tried by military courts, parties outlawed, opposition candidates from Islamic parties jailed on security charges just before elections and thus kept from winning office, torture used to extract confessions, political prisoners dying while in custody. The U.S. gives Egypt $1.2 billion in military aid every year, and doubtless Egypt uses a considerable amount of that to keep the tourniquet tight. Egypt exports the terrorists the repression produces, but not before its state-dominated media has taught them to blame the misery and backwardness of Arab nations on the U.S. The terrorists then attack the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. We are not a wicked nation but, as long as we subsidize this fated cycle, we are a stupid one.

The alternative is to make our aid, which also includes $700 million in development assistance, conditional on reform. Our government should tell Egypt: You want our money? We want more for it, after September 11, than simply peace with Israel. Loosen the tourniquet. Call off the media attacks on America. And do this to preserve yourselves, you Egyptian governing elites. Consider Algeria: a secular regime that denied its Islamic opposition political space—even cancelled an election because the Islamists would have won—and paid for it in a civil war of unimaginable savagery. And note: the Islamic terrorists in Algeria targeted the Westernized elites for assassination early on.

But the chances of the U.S. saying anything like this to Egypt look to be low. It would require President Bush to think through the difference between the causes of September 11, the evil hearts of "the Evil One" and his henchmen, and the sources of the attack. For the same reason it is unlikely that we will put pressure on Saudi Arabia, even though it sponsors madrassas across the Muslim world— most of the Taliban leadership learned their attitudes on women and infidels at madrassas in Pakistan—and otherwise spreads its home-grown radical Islamic faith. "For decades," the Middle East scholar Kanan Makiya wrote recently, "the Saudi royal family could count on support from the United States even as it allowed Wahhabism to project its hate-filled vision of Islam around the world. Such support, so contrary to American principles of freedom and toleration, is widely interpreted in the region as indifference to the suffering of ordinary Arabs in the Middle East..." Since we protect the Saudi oil fields we have leverage to tell the princes to curb these institutions, and to cease exporting the anti-Western fundamentalist strain of Islam that numbered the Taliban among its converts. But President Bush, as reported by Maureen Dowd in The New York Times, thinks this is out of bounds. We have no more right to ask them to change their religious practices, according to Bush, than we do to ask the Methodists to change their practices because Timothy McVeigh was a Methodist. The analogy is depressing: the Methodist Church is not teaching hatred of America.

Instead of taking the war on terror to Iraq, we need to take it to Egypt and Saudi Arabia, terror's source. We need to reach beyond these autocratic regimes to their peoples. Stability and protection of the oil fields, the two pillars of U.S. policy in the region, are rightly seen on the Arab street as selfish aims, and our claims to stand for human rights and democracy are seen as hypocritical—human rights, but not for Arabs; democracy, but not for Arabs. The region won't be stable, the oil fields won't be secure, and America won't be free of the fear of terrorism unless we identify with the aspirations of the Arab people to live under legitimate governments. The risk of reform is the one Algeria faced a decade ago: that radical Islamist parties will gain popular favor, win elections, and establish a theocratic state. But if that risk exists today, imagine how much higher it will be tomorrow.

TOPICS: Editorial; Foreign Affairs; Israel
If we continue to bankroll Egypt we should dole the money out in weekly installments. If they don't cool the anti-Americanism we shut off the money valve until we are satisfied.

Saudi Arabia will require a different approach but we must not allow these regimes to encourage hate-America movements inside their borders or in client states like Pakistan.

1 posted on 12/07/2001 12:39:29 PM PST by aculeus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

Comment #2 Removed by Moderator

To: aculeus; Sabertooth; dennisw; Lent; patent; onyx
Good article.
3 posted on 12/07/2001 12:45:34 PM PST by Travis McGee
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: aculeus
Good point, but we need Anwar up and running first. We also need some legislators and a president with the guts to do it. I'm certain that this will never happen in my lifetime!
4 posted on 12/07/2001 12:51:22 PM PST by Sunshine Sister
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: aculeus
Our government should tell Egypt: You want our money? We want more for it, after September 11, than simply peace with Israel. Loosen the tourniquet.
No, we should not tell them how to deal with their domestic insurrections. That's their problem, not ours.

Call off the media attacks on America.
That, however, is something we should have done long ago. You badmouth us, you don't get our money. That should be pretty obvious.

5 posted on 12/07/2001 12:57:07 PM PST by N00dleN0gg1n
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Travis McGee
6 posted on 12/07/2001 1:16:08 PM PST by patent
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: aculeus
It took three months for the pundits to figure this out?
Perhaps they ought to read the threads on Free Republic the week of Sept. 11.

As for Bush maintaining that it is "out of bounds" to insist that Saudi Arabia tone down the "hate America" rhetoric, if true, this will peove to be his fatal mistake.

When it becomes obvious to the average Joe that Saudi and Egypt are active players in the hatred, the stuff will hit the fan.

7 posted on 12/07/2001 1:54:15 PM PST by Publius6961
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: aculeus
Good analysis. I have been yelling and screaming this ever since 9/11. I'd go further though: end all foreign aid, including to Israel.
8 posted on 12/07/2001 2:36:42 PM PST by SteamshipTime
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson