If you are referring to these particular Jews, how do you intend to collect? If you are referring to Jews as a group, I think they paid that price, if you will, in Germany, in the 1940's.
You seem to make a lot of assumptions here that suggest I want to make em pay per se or dislike jews in some manner. Don't involve me in your make believe dilusional BS story bucko.
I happen not to suscribe to the doctrine of eternal damnation. As such, I do not believe that hell is their fate for the stupid and offensive action of burning the New Testament. But one thing the Jews of Israel should realize, is that American evangelical Christians are their most powerful supporters. Many evangelical Christians are more fervent in their support of Israel than many of America's secular minded Jews. Therefore, to antagonize American Christians is incredibly stupid and bone headed action.
Why 1940's? What about everything else before that? The problem with holocaust is that people spend so much time on it, that it basically wipes any history that Jews had prior to that.