Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

The Mosque to Commerce: bin Laden's Special Complaint with the WTC
Slate ^ | Friday, December 28, 2001, at 8:58 AM PT | Laurie Kerr

Posted on 12/29/2001 9:07:20 AM PST by Asclepius

We all know the basic reasons why Osama Bin Laden chose to attack the World Trade Center, out of all the buildings in New York. Its towers were the two tallest in the city, synonymous with its skyline. They were richly stocked with potential victims. And as the complex's name declared, it was designed to be a center of American and global commerce. But Bin Laden may have had another, more personal motivation. The World Trade Center's architect, Minoru Yamasaki, was a favorite designer of the Binladin family's patrons?the Saudi royal family?and a leading practitioner of an architectural style that merged modernism with Islamic influences.

[Dhahran Air Terminal]

View of the King Fahd Dhahran Air Terminal The story starts in the late 1950s, when Yamasaki, a second-generation Japanese-American, won the commission to design the King Fahd Dhahran Air Terminal in Dhahran, Saudi Arabia. His design had a rectilinear, modular plan with pointed arches, interweaving tracery of prefabricated concrete, and even a minaret of a flight tower. In other words, it was an impressive melding of modern technology and traditional Islamic form. The Saudis admired it so much that they put a picture of it on one of their banknotes.

[5 Riyals, (1966)]

Saudi banknote, 1966

For Yamasaki, an architect with a keen mathematical mind and a taste for ornamental pattern-work, this brush with the intricate geometries of Islamic architecture was inspiring, and he began to incorporate arabesques and arches into his work. For the next 12 to 15 years he played with Islamic forms in projects as diverse as the Federal Science Pavilion at the Seattle World's Fair, the Eastern Airlines Terminal at Logan Airport, and even the North Shore Congregation Israel in Glencoe, Ill.

[World Trade Center plaza]

View of the World Trade Center plaza

Yamasaki received the World Trade Center commission the year after the Dhahran Airport was completed. Yamasaki described its plaza as "a mecca, a great relief from the narrow streets and sidewalks of the surrounding Wall Street area." True to his word, Yamasaki replicated the plan of Mecca's courtyard by creating a vast delineated square, isolated from the city's bustle by low colonnaded structures and capped by two enormous, perfectly square towers?minarets, really. Yamasaki's courtyard mimicked Mecca's assemblage of holy sites?the Qa'ba (a cube) containing the sacred stone, what some believe is the burial site of Hagar and Ishmael, and the holy spring?by including several sculptural features, including a fountain, and he anchored the composition in a radial circular pattern, similar to Mecca's.

[View of a World Trade Center tower]

View of a World Trade Center tower

At the base of the towers, Yamasaki used implied pointed arches?derived from the characteristically pointed arches of Islam?as a transition between the wide column spacing below and the dense structural mesh above. (Europe imported pointed arches from Islam during the Middle Ages, and so non-Muslims have come to think of them as innovations of the Gothic period.) Above soared the pure geometry of the towers, swathed in a shimmering skin, which doubled as a structural web?a giant truss. Here Yamasaki was following the Islamic tradition of wrapping a powerful geometric form in a dense filigree, as in the inlaid marble pattern work of the Taj Mahal or the ornate carvings of the courtyard and domes of the Alhambra.

[January 28th!]

The shimmering filigree is the mark of the holy. According to Oleg Grabar, the great American scholar of Islamic art and architecture, the dense filigree of complex geometries alludes to a higher spiritual reality in Islam, and the shimmering quality of Islamic patterning relates to the veil that wraps the Qa'ba at Mecca. After the attack, Grabar spoke of how these towers related to the architecture of Islam, where "the entire surface is meaningful" and "every part is both construction and ornament." A number of designers from the Middle East agreed, describing the entire façade as a giant "mashrabiya," the tracery that fills the windows of mosques.

In the early '70s, as the trade towers were nearing completion, Saudi Arabia was awash in oil revenues, and the state embarked on a massive modernization and building campaign. Yamasaki was premier among the many foreign architects hired during this period. Unwilling to take on too much work, Yamasaki decided to accept just three choice projects in Saudi Arabia: the Saudi Arabian Monetary Agency head office, the Eastern Province International Airport, and the King Fahd Royal Reception Pavilion at Jeddah Airport. In all three projects he continued his explorations in melding traditional Islamic form with modern materials, methods, and functions.

Five Critics Dish on the Best Movies of 2001

More Bogus Spin From the Cloning Industry

What's a Stadium Name Worth?

As a scion of the Binladin contracting firm, destined to inherit some portion of its vast operations, Osama Bin Laden would certainly have been aware of Yamasaki's Saudi Arabian projects. Indeed, his family may have built them. (Minoru Yamasaki Associates won't say, but the Binladens were involved with almost all royal construction.) While Osama was in college in the mid-'70s, Yamasaki was designing his second generation of Saudi work, and the World Trade Center?then the tallest building in the world times two?came to completion in New York. This period was the high-water mark both for Yamasaki's world reputation and for the Saudis' national construction plan?which in Saudi Arabia must have brought a heightened sense of importance to the World Trade Center.

Having rejected modernism and the Saudi royal family, it's no surprise that Bin Laden would turn against Yamasaki's work in particular. He must have seen how Yamasaki had clothed the World Trade Center, a monument of Western capitalism, in the raiment of Islamic spirituality. Such mixing of the sacred and the profane is old hat to us?after all, Gilbert Cass' classic Woolworth Building, dubbed the Cathedral to Commerce, is decked out in extravagant Gothic regalia. But to someone who wants to purify Islam from commercialism, Yamasaki's implicit Mosque to Commerce would be anathema. To Bin Laden, the World Trade Center was probably not only an international landmark but also a false idol.

TOPICS: Culture/Society; Miscellaneous
KEYWORDS: basque; eta
Of course, I knew all of this all along.
1 posted on 12/29/2001 9:07:20 AM PST by Asclepius
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Asclepius
Looking for logic where only evil exists!
2 posted on 12/29/2001 11:16:28 AM PST by OldFriend
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Asclepius
Fascinating. Wonder why no one else has covered this.
3 posted on 12/29/2001 12:04:25 PM PST by M. Thatcher
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: OldFriend
That's right. Let's turn off our brains. Everybody ready? .... CLICK!!! Aaah! Bliss!
4 posted on 12/29/2001 12:21:31 PM PST by Arthur McGowan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Asclepius
Funny, but I remarked about that to my wife a day or two after 9/11. It struck me that the arabesques on the bottom of the towers might have caused offense, I didn't realise all the others puns in the complex too.

Coincidentally, the brand new Joe Moakley Federal Court House in Boston where they bring the shoe bomb guy uses some similar designs - so I suppose it'll be next.

So the lesson is - we can't be over sensitive to these foreign cultures?

5 posted on 12/29/2001 12:28:59 PM PST by Riflema
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Riflema
Sorry missed the /sarcasm closing tag there.
6 posted on 12/29/2001 12:30:11 PM PST by Riflema
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: Asclepius
This article is terrific..bin Laden is an architectural engineer...he would have been aware of all these Muslim influences incorporated into the was probably the icing on the cake for him to destroy this architect's vision of the melding of such vastly different worlds...not to mention the obvious Freudian implication of phallic size inferiority that the Towers probably stir in the Arab world where women can only be kept faithful by government edict and medieval repression.
7 posted on 12/29/2001 12:45:51 PM PST by foreshadowed at waco
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Asclepius
Interesting find. I think it is just another layer of an onion. Thanks for the post.
8 posted on 12/29/2001 12:50:52 PM PST by PA Engineer
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: PA Engineer
Madrid's tower was ETA target

MADRID, Spain -- The Basque separatist group ETA had planned to target Madrid's tallest building as part of a foiled 1999 "Christmas massacre" attack, police revealed on Thursday.

Police had thwarted the December 1999 attempt to blow up the Picasso Tower after discovering two vans packed with explosives, but it remained unclear what the target had been -- until this week.

Police questioning two suspects arrested in connection with a Madrid car bomb on Tuesday were told that ETA had planned to hit the skyscraper, national police chief Juan Cotino said.

The interior minister at the time of the interception, Jaime Mayor Oreja, had said ETA had planned a "Christmas massacre" in Madrid.

The Picasso Tower is a 44-storey glass and steel building, home to 5,000 office workers, and located near a shopping centre.

It was designed by Minoru Yamasaki, the man behind New York's World Trade Center.

ETA suspect Ana Belen Egues, arrested in connection with Tuesday's bomb blast which injured 95 people, "admitted that it was planned for the vans to be placed at the Picasso Tower," Cotino said.

Police had stopped one van on December 20, 1999, heading for Madrid loaded with 1,980 pounds of a chlorine compound used in explosives and 110 pounds of dynamite.

The discovery led investigators three days later to a similar van abandoned in a hotel parking lot in northeastern Spain. It was packed with 1,650 pounds of explosives and a timer.

Despite investigations, police had been unable to find out what the target had been.

The police chief said the dynamite was probably stolen in France and smuggled into Spain.

ETA -- which stands for Basque Homeland and Freedom -- has been blamed for the deaths of some 800 people since 1968 in its campaign for an independent Basque region.

9 posted on 03/11/2004 1:04:35 PM PST by Shermy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson