Posted on 05/10/2003 4:26:12 AM PDT by Lorenb420
Most mothers report feeling disappointment on Mother's Day, despite receiving more attention than fathers do on Father's Day, a new study has found.
"Mothers have higher expectations of how the day should go," said Nicole Gilbert, the author of a study that compares the two holidays and a graduate student at Mount Holyoke College, Mass. "Fathers don't have expectations and are less likely to be disappointed."
Ms. Gilbert said mothers' high expectations are likely the result of all the advertising and media attention devoted to the day.
But according to the 53 married couples she interviewed for the study, mothers reported feeling unhappy on their day because of such disappointments as lacklustre gifts, family strife and whiny children.
She also found even those couples who expressed egalitarian ideas on gender roles in marriage embraced traditional stereotypes when it came to their celebrations.
"There's a difference in belief and [action]," she said.
Fathers, for example, are less likely to be taken out for dinner, perhaps because of their traditional role as providers, Ms. Gilbert said. Mothers are more likely to visit extended family members on their day.
Mother's Day celebrations emphasize nurturing female stereotypes, Ms. Gilbert said. Gifts are typically flowers, taking mothers out to dinner and relieving them of household chores for the day.
Fathers' gifts are usually related to employment and athletic pursuits -- for example, a tie, golf clubs or hunting equipment.
Sixty-two per cent of mothers said their holiday includes doing fewer of the family chores, while only 29% of fathers reported that. And almost 85% of mothers reported being taken out for dinner as opposed to 64% of fathers.
Linda Marlow, greeting card director for Hallmark Canada, agreed holiday cards also reflect gender differences. Father's Day cards tend to be more humourous and focus on cars, sports, tools and fishing, while Mother's Day cards tend to be serious and emotional, she said.
Hallmark Canada registered $8-million in Mother's Day sales in 2002, as opposed to $7-million for Father's Day.
People celebrate these holidays because of commercial messages and obligation, as opposed to genuine reflection on what a parent means to them, said Alan Mirabelli, executive director of The Vanier Institute of the Family.
Mr. Mirabelli said he was not surprised at the greater emphasis and expectation placed on Mother's Day. "We've always celebrated and discussed the nurturing role of the mother -- the father was often an afterthought. The intimate side of fathering is often missing from our discourse."
Parent-based holidays tend to reaffirm stereotypes more than any other, Ms. Gilbert said. During her research, the test group's Father's and Mother's Day gifts were evaluated on a scale of masculinity and femininity. Gifts from other such holidays as birthdays were also presented, and found to be much more gender neutral.
"I'm not advocating an abolition of Mother's and Father's Day," she said, adding she hopes her research opens people's eyes to stereotypes that may often go unnoticed and moves people to think beyond traditional gifts and holiday-related events.
"These holidays offered us a prime opportunity to see how families construct gender."
MOTHER'S DAY BY THE NUMBERS:
A new study says Mother's Day and Father's Day are very different in terms of gifts, events and family rituals. Traditionally, we tend to show more love to our mothers -- more money is spent on their gifts and more time is put into their holiday celebration. The following is a study in contrast between the two holidays that honour our parents, as well as a look at expected Canadian purchases for Mother's Day 2003. 65 Percentage of Mother's Day shoppers who will buy cards, according to the International Mass Retail Association
- 35 Percentage of Father's Day shoppers who will buy cards
- 53 Percentage of Mother's Day shoppers who will purchase flowers
- 0 Percentage of Father's Day shoppers who will purchase flowers - 14 Percentage of Mother's Day shoppers who will purchase perfume
- 11 Percentage of Father's Day shoppers who will purchase sporting goods
- $8-million Value of Mother's Day Hallmark card purchases in Canada during 2002
- $7-million Value of Father's Day Hallmark card purchases in Canada during 2002
- 20 Percentage of Mother's Day cards that will be purchased by men as opposed to women
- $144-million Value of Mother's Day Hallmark card purchases in the United States during 2002
- $90-million Value of Mother's Day Hallmark card purchases in the United States during 2002
- 42-million Estimated Canadian credit-card expenses on jewellery for Mother's Day 2003, according to Moneris Solutions
- $100-million Estimated Canadian credit-card expenses on restaurants and dining for Mother's Day 2003
- $28-million Estimated Canadian credit-card expenses on jewellery for Mother's Day 2003
- $10-million Estimated Canadian credit-card expenses on the theatre for Mother's Day 2003
- $62-million Estimated Canadian credit-card expenses on hair and beauty products for Mother's Day 2003
- 82 Percentage of Canadians expected to buy gifts for their mother
- 20 Percentage of Canadians expected to buy gifts for their wives
- 15 Percentage of Canadians expected to buy a gift for their mother-in-law
- 61 Percentage of Canadian moms who expect to sleep in this Mother's Day
- 40 Percentage of Canadian Mothers who believe they will receive breakfast in bed.
Glad my mom isn't like this. I hope when I have kids I can be as generous and caring as she is.
The above strikes me funny...even Democrats apparently find it hard to deny that men and women are different.
Glad you have a nice mother, mine was too.
The time will come quickly enough when I will miss those smiles, then I will be happy if they rememebr to call. I have already gotten the best Mother's day gift there could be. I have the memories of the greatest love anywone could know. What could come after that?
Prime opportunity my big hairy a$$. Gender? We don't know what the hell that is anymore in our transexual world. Maybe I will just prance around in fairyland all dressed up on mom's day and you can tell me about gender, cause it is getting confusing with all the stupid idiocy being spewed by the left.
I wonder what lesbians with kids do on mommy day? Give each other the day off?
knowing she was dying she gave me what she considered her most prized possession.
It was an inexpensive vase which my Brothers and I had purchased nearly 50 years go. With it was the original "Mothers Day" card which simply said "From your three Sons"
A few days ago, I was talking to one of my Sisters and we agreed Mother was the most perfect person we had ever known. So kind and gentle that it sometimes amazed me. Of course no one is perfect we agreed but when we tried to think of Mother's faults we literally could only come up with one. We remember she used to complain about Daddy's Mother wanting him around too much.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.