Posted on 10/02/2008 7:17:45 PM PDT by Zionist Conspirator
A friend of mine in the media covered the Republican National Convention and brought me back a souvenir: a navy blue yarmulke with “McCain ’08” printed on it in English and Hebrew. I guess there wasn’t time for the campaign to make them up with Sarah Palin’s name, too, which is a shame. With all the disquiet she has evoked in the Jewish community, that would be a collector’s item.
Jews themselves, and liberals who feel we belong naturally in the Democratic fold, give reasons for the gathering unease about her. A gaping cultural difference is noted. “Eating moose meat is not a big thing here in South Florida,” Senator Charles Schumer told Jewish retirees. One hears that Palin’s views on domestic issues go against the Jewish community’s “core values,” as Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz argued. That she’s anti-abortion is the problematic position most often cited as an example.
Her evangelical faith — more pronounced than that of President Bush — suggests itself as the cultural difference that explains most of the seemingly disparate sources of displeasure.
Which may sound like bigotry on the part of Jewish voters, as we would conclude about some Jewish Democrats, notably senior citizens, who have said to reporters and to me personally that Obama’s being black makes it hard to support him. The sentiment is apparently common in Florida retirement villages.
But unlike racism, the prejudice against evangelicals doesn’t yield to a simple diagnosis. If it’s a form of anti-Christianism, why do other Protestants fail to arouse the same feelings?
You’ll often hear a Jew say he fears being subjected to aggressive evangelization. But no evidence suggests that Palin has any interest in that. The best her critics have come up with is that she sat through a guest sermon at her church by David Brickner of Jews for Jesus. Yes, and at shuls I’ve attended I have sat through presentations by guest speakers that I found distasteful. Even the Anti-Defamation League gave her a pass on that one.
Possibly, some upper-middle-class Jews, with their recent immigrant roots, feel the same fear and loathing for the supposedly déclassé religious right that many gentile parvenus do, out of sheer class anxiety. This would explain the Jewish prejudice that you encounter sometimes against Orthodox Jews, too. But I can’t prove this.
Here is another plausible theory: According to a mythic master narrative that Jews find compelling, we have fared less well under the rule of Christian “true believers” than under Christians who are blasé or conflicted about their religion. (Calling this “mythic” doesn’t mean that, as history, it’s true or false.)
Bill Clinton, a Southern Baptist, could talk God-talk to us. But since he’s a rascal, no one worried about it. Jews could accept McCain, too. Whatever he believes about ultimate questions, he has been allergic to saying much in public on the subject.
The same fact made his pre-Palin candidacy a turn-off to evangelicals and to others who assume that a well-formed worldview, informed by religious beliefs, may be more important in a candidate than how conversant he or she is with national and international policy issues. If elected, Palin would gain that expertise on the job, just as she mastered the intricacies of Alaska politics. Having a mature worldview, identical with wisdom, is a quality that serving in a high office will not bestow upon you.
So Palin speaks openly and confidently about her Christian beliefs, and she lives them, too. Terrifying, right? Yet I’m not sure I buy an explanation that centers quite so simply on her being Christian.
Barack Obama stresses his own faith experiences more than Sarah Palin does hers. The difference is that Palin’s spiritual beliefs are mirrored by her policy preferences, even to the point of giving offense. Hence, in Jewish discussions of Palin, the recurrent mention of the abortion issue. She has said she supports legal abortion only when the mother’s life is in danger — a position for which one could find considerable support in Jewish sources.
Perhaps it’s Judaism, not Christianity, that’s the nub of the matter. Hardly a month after she was introduced to us, Sarah Palin may indeed have managed to touch the exposed electrical power cable that runs through Jewish spirituality.
Torah, whether we like this fact or not, is about nothing if not giving practical expression to religious beliefs, in both private and public life, often in demanding and intrusive ways. That is a basic axiom of the Jewish worldview that offered transcendent meaning in life to generations of Jews before us.
So shouldn’t we be running toward Palin, instead of away? You might think so. But Jews of all denominations have grown increasingly distant from the traditional Jewish view of the world. Want proof?
This year’s exhaustive U.S. Religious Landscape Survey asked Americans how they saw the relationship between religion and politics. The study asked respondents if they would rank their religion as the top influence on their political beliefs. Jews were the group least likely to answer in the affirmative. Only 4% credited faith as so profoundly shaping their views on public life, compared, for example, to 28% of evangelicals.
Jews were also the second-most liberal religious group, with 34% identifying with the political left, behind only Buddhists (who include many born-Jews). Many politically conservative Jews I know likewise can’t explain how beliefs about God legitimately shape thoughts about anything broader than one’s own private behavior. Yet the Torah is about much else besides personal ethics.
The flight from what Sarah Palin represents, maximizing the voice we give to God in the world, has become a “core value” of contemporary Jewish life. That Jews would be unnerved by her is no shock.
Ping.
she is kicking his butt. Am I too right wing to see this clearly. I think she is beating him up.
I guess no live thread on the debate?
Sarah reminds me of a little school teacher from the US who helped save a small country being attacked on all sides. Remember the name of the lady? Golda Meir. Jews should be far more afraid of someone who’s father, brother, step-father and relatives are Muslims. Obama’s campaign also had people on it closely connected to Hamas.
Nixon was attacked by liberal Jews and some said he was an anti-semite. People with any knowledge knew Nixon shipped Israel everything he could get his hands on during the dark days of the Yom Kippur War. Some told Nixon not to do it and it could harm him with European allies. Nixon sent planeload after planeload of ammo and military supplies. Golda Meir and others in the know realized Nixon was a great friend to Israel.
I have a Jewish friend who left Europe with his wife and kids because he said western Europe is finished for the Jews and Christians with Islam growing exponentially. This is due to European leftists who support Obama. Jews or Christians should lose sleep at night with Obama in the White House. I know a tough Sarah Palin would be protecting my family and Jewish families.
Donate and volunteer to help McCain-Palin now.
“That Jews would be unnerved by her is no shock.”
It is shocking to me — really.
Since 9/11 I have met some wonderful Jewish people online.
They are not “shocked” by me and I am not “shocked” by them.
I am a born-again Christian conservative.
The Jewish people I speak with (online, email, freepmail) are young and older Jews — observant to very observant Jews — and all conservative in various degrees.
Anyway, threads like this make me feel quite sad — especially here
on FreeRepublic.com.
Cindy
Obama: Sen. Barack Obama served as a paid director alongside a confessed domestic terrorist and granted funding to a controversial Arab group that dubbed the creation of Israel as a “catastrophe.” The founder of the Arab group in question, Columbia University professor Rashid Khalidi, also has held a fundraiser for Obama. Khalidi is a harsh critic of Israel, has made statements supportive of Palestinian terror and reportedly has worked on behalf of the Palestine Liberation Organization while it was involved in anti western terrorism.
Palin: "I love Israel, the only flag I have in my office is Israeli."
I have given up trying to figure out why Jewish liberals are liberal.
Its too paradoxical for a people for who are generally so very intelligent and well-educated as well as who have been so perscuted by strong governments in the past.
What a remarkable woman! She stands alone... and moves me when she looks into that camera so fearlessly... what a fabulous stand she takes... alongside the faithful. GO SARAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I judge Obama by the fruit he bears, as a Christian, I wish no fellowship with the works of darkness. Part of the fruit he bears is declared clearly by his Reverend Jeremiah Wright, the preacher of hate which seems to have more in common with the Black Muslim theology.
So, because she tries to live her faith, this is a bad thing? I just don’t get it.
I ain’t votin’ for no Senator.
Hamas endorses Obama.
Any other questions?
The author seems to be implying that liberal Jews object to Sarah Palin because she’s more Jewish than they are, in every way except genealogy.
I don’t understand how a group can make being the victims of genocidal persecution a primary element of their self-definition, while at the same time having free abortion as their number one demand from the government. “Nobody can commit genocide on us - we’ll do it ourselves!”
Warning! This is a high-volume ping list.
I cringed when I heard Sarah call for a 2 state solution.
Am I wrong in being bothered by that?
Last night in the debate, she had me with the words “Embassy in Jerusalem” — she’s on the right side folks.
Didn’t bother me too much, she has said something to the effect of two democracies...ain’t gonna happen, and she probably knows that.
Don’t expect any politician to actually call for Israel to take over all the land & expell the Palestinians.
The two state solution happens to be the hypothetical goal of Israel as well as the Bush Administration. It's easy to say as a catch phrase, but practically impossible to achieve in a satisfatory manner.
I think there’s something to it.
What does it mean to be a Jew? It’s been suggested that the crisis that followed the exposure of the false messiah, Sabbatai Zevi, turned a lot of Jews in a more secular direction, and they became “progressives.” There was considerable discussion what it meant to be a Jew when it was declared that all Jews could be citizens of Israel.
The Holocaust, too, although it should certainly be honored, became a kind of substitute religion for many Jews.
Christian Evangelicals remind Jews that they should be obeying the Covenant, and many of the secular Jews or more liberal Jews just don’t want to hear that. And it can be embarrassing when you run into Christians who seem to be stronger in defense of Israel than you are. (I have experienced that as a Catholic, when I have supported Israel in situations where some of my secular Jewish friends seem to take the other side.)
The great majority of the Jews in places like Miami are liberal, secular or near-secular. So it’s not surprising that someone like Sarah who takes her religion seriously—and who takes Jewish religion seriously, too—would bother them.
I don’t think too many Jews instinctively fear Sarah Palin. It’s mainly Dummycrat politicians who are trying to stoke such a fear of Palin in Jewish voters who are inclined to jump to the GOP this year. They even went so far as to ridicule Palin for hunting moose, implying that she can’t be favorably disposed toward Jewish causes if her lifestyle is so alien to that of most Jews. Hopefully, most Jews can see this appeal for the prejudice inherent in it.
High volume. Articles on Israel can also be found by clicking on the Topic or Keyword Israel, WOT
..................
If David Klinghoffer really believes Jews somehow fear Sarah, that's a reflection of the people he hangs around, not reality. I note that Schumer and Hastings, among others, attempt to stoke religious and racial fears, Anybody toting guns and stripping moose don't care too much about what they do with Jews and blacks, a function of their own bigotry.
Needless to say you haven't met David Klinghoffer or Chuck Schumer.
You’ve got that right!
Amen to everything you said.
My impression of Klinghoffer (which, granted, is mainly based on work of his I've seen in First Things) is that he is a serious and committed Jew. This article doesn't seem to reflect his own views, but those which he sees in the secular Jews around him and which he is trying to understand and explain.
Schumer, of course, is another story. He seems to be a committed and serious Schumerite! ;-)
*HUGS*
Thank you snuffy smiff.
Smiling at you.
From what I know about Liberal Jews as I talk to many on website to do with religion..Many of those Jewsih People think today’s Christians are way to judgemental and hypocrites, many tell me as a Christian the only reason Christians love Israel and support the Jewish people is because they know GOD said *I will bless those who love Israel and persecute those who curse Israel*.
They also say Christians are waiting for Jesus to come and think they have to convert Jews as many as they can so Jesus will come...
Lastly many of these Jewish people have not gotten over the fact that many people that professed the Christan faith stood by and did nothing during the Holocaust and still blame the Jews for calling on the death of Jesus..
This is what many Liberal Jews have told me, that is why they stand up for Gay rights or atheists and Obama and other groups that are not embraced by conservative christians.
One doesn't mean to be judgmental, but killing your own offspring because conservative Christians would prefer you didn't is insane. Perhaps there's a communication problem.
Orthodox Judaism is Pro-life except where the mother’s life might be in danger...Reform and Reconstructionist are Pro-Choice...
I do follow the teachings of Messianic Judaism.. The teachings of Jesus before Christianity of Paul and Constantine... it is in line with Conservative principles and how *grace* is the core of the Christian teaching.
> According to a mythic master narrative that Jews find compelling, we have fared less well under the rule of Christian “true believers” than under Christians who are blasé or conflicted about their religion.
Geez. How about counterexamples like... Hitler, Stalin...
Seems clear from this writer that over 70% of today’s Jewish/socialists/liberals see themselves as socialists (anti-Christians, anti-capitalists (pro-communists ?)) FIRST, and as a religious people with actual morals second.
Or maybe last.
What does he mean “we,” keemosavee? Her religious fervor is a big draw to me, because Christians have outgrown religious coercion and discrimination. Their cries of jubilant faith are reassuring and safe. A pity the same can’t be said for Muslims and Lefties.
Baruch HaShem
etz chaim he...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.