Skip to comments.Church of England bishop says 'Anglican experiment is over'
Posted on 10/26/2009 3:22:02 PM PDT by NYer
Members of the traditionalist Anglican group Forward in Faith recently concluded their annual gathering, which was dedicated to discussing Pope Benedict's overture to Anglicans. The general impression left by the conference was the Anglican experiment is over, a mood that was reinforced by Bishop John Hind officially announcing he is ready to become Catholic.
The 2009 National Assembly of Forward in Faith was held in the Emmanuel Centre, Westminster, London, October 23-24. The Assembly was originally scheduled before the Vatican announced its unprecedented move, but the issue dominated most of the discussion.
Speaking to the press during the event, the Right Reverend John Hind, Anglican Bishop of Chichester, announced he is considering becoming a Roman Catholic.
Hind, the most senior traditionalist in the Church of England, told The Telegraph that he is willing to sacrifice his salary and palace residence to join the Catholic Church.
This is a remarkable new step from the Vatican, he said. At long last there are some choices for Catholics in the Church of England. I'd be happy to be re-ordained into the Catholic Church.
The bishop said that he expects his previous ministry will be recognized in the Catholic Church, but stressed that the divisions in the Anglican Communion could make it impossible to stay. How can the Church exist if bishops are not in full communion with each other? he asked.
During the conference, the Right Reverend John Broadhurst, who is the Anglican Bishop of Fulham and the Primate of Forward in Faith, affirmed that the Anglican experiment is over.
Bishop Broadhurst said that Pope Benedict has made his offer in response to the pleas of Anglicans who despair at the disintegration of their Church. Anglicanism has become a joke because it has singularly failed to deal with any of its contentious issues, said the bishop.
There is widespread dissent across the [Anglican] Communion. We are divided in major ways on major issues and the Communion has unraveled. I believed in the Church I joined, but it has been revealed to have no doctrine of its own. I personally think it has gone past the point of no return. The Anglican experiment is over.
In an emotional closing speech on Saturday, Bishop Broadhurst used the metaphor of the frog and the boiling pot to describe the current Anglican status.
"The temperature at the pot has become intolerable, but the process of boiling started before the ordination of women The truth is, the tragedy for us is the Church of England has presumed. It's presumed to know better than the tradition on many matters and it's presumed to know better than Jesus Christ about some matters, he explained.
And It is the presumption of our Church in this present period that has caused such pain and anguish to many of us.
Oh yes, the ordination of women was the water being turned up; we knew that we were going to be cooked to death ...
And what the general (Anglican) Synod did, was to say, We will push the pot towards the edge of the gas, as long as you stay on this side of the pot, with a few ice cubes, it'll be all right, Bishop Broadhurst said.
Then he explained: We've never claimed that Anglicanism is the Church of Jesus Christ, and we've always claimed and believed that there needs to be catholic unity.
This is about Anglicans in communion with Rome and not about Anglicans ceasing to be Roman Catholics, he also said.
The Right Reverend Martyn Jarrett, Anglican Bishop of Beverley, also insisted on the fact that there are questions over the church's survival, explaining that the Church of England has changed too dramatically for some traditionalists.
The offer from the Vatican is momentous and I felt a great sense of gratitude that the Roman Catholic Church is thinking about the position of traditionalist Anglicans, he added.
Another participant at the Forward in Faith conference, Fr. Edward Tomlinson, Anglican Vicar of St. Barnabas, said that he would be following the lead of Bishop Hind.
The ship of Anglicanism seems to be going down... We should be grateful that a lifeboat has been sent. I shall be seeking to move to Rome. To stay in the Church of England would be suicide, Fr. Tomlinson said.
Forward in Faith is a worldwide association of close to 1,000 clergy and thousands of lay Anglicans founded in 1992 in opposition to the ordination of women as priests or as bishops, and most recently, to the ordination of active homosexuals. The association says that it finds such practices not only contrary to the Scriptures as they have been consistently interpreted by the two thousand year tradition of the churches of both East and West, but also as a new and serious obstacle in the way of reconciliation and full visible unity between Anglicans and the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches.
No price too great!
NOW can they burn Rowan Williams at the stake?
Freep-mail me to get on or off my pro-life and Catholic List:
Please ping me to note-worthy Pro-Life or Catholic threads, or other threads of interest.
Obama Says A Baby Is A Punishment
A HUGE “WELCOME!!!”
Would they be called “Anglican Catholics”?
As the titular head of the Anglican Church, can the Queen step in and tell these bishops to stay where they are? Just wondering. Obviously, her position is little more than ceremonial. I don't know what, if any, power she might have over the bishops and their desire to return to the Roman Catholic Church after six hundred years.
There are, and have been, a lot of good people in this church and it is not their fault how their Church was founded. The East-West schism came down to bickering about supremacy, as Henry did, though the Eastern Church left because they see it as a Communion of Bishops of sorts (with the Pope on equal footing with Constantinople.)
If you see an Anglican service, it has become more respectful and sacred than the American (Roman) Catholic church’s has become. At least they still kneel for Holy Communion. We should go back to doing that ourselves.
I am so happy to see this.
They will be following the Anglican Use Rite, so that seems like a reasonable title. I am Roman Catholic but practice my faith at a Maronite Catholic Church. They are called Maronite Catholics.
Correction: ...after 500 years or so...
DUH Tell me something I don’t know Archbishop
I believe you told me about a priest in Greenville, SC who is of your Rite. I just emailed him a letter today!
May Christ heal His Church...I welcome them as brothers and sisters in Christ. :)
FWIW, as I mentioned on another thread, my husband is Anglican, and we are very excited about this. :)
I was an acolyte (at 40) in an Anglican church in Los Angeles. The service was far more orthodox, reverential and sacred than anything I’d ever experienced before or since - and that includes quite a few Catholic churches.
That said I have decided to swim the Tiber without waiting to see what traditionalist Anglicans will do.
I sometimes wonder what the Queen herself thinks of gay marriage and these other changes.
Wonder if she will at least allow Roman Catholics to be reigning monarchs now?
Taking the Plunge? LOL...
The Masses in other countries are far more reverent, trust me.
I attended a Jesuit high school way back when and was horrified by the “folk mass” we attended monthly next door.
If it were up to me, guitars would be banned from Mass. :-)